4 ms·
> The first statement is not fact. "Not really women" according to whom? Do you agree that they are male, though? And that they typically prefer to wear clothi
by brengola 4y ago
> The first statement is not fact. "Not really women" according to whom?
Do you agree that they are male, though? And that they typically prefer to wear clothing and other adornments that are culturally associated with being female?
> The second statement is what is implied by Rowling's call for "biological women only restrooms".
It is not implied. The argument for excluding transwomen from female-only spaces is the same as for excluding any other male, and doesn't equate to the second statement you made.
> see Caster Semenya as an example
Caster Semenya is a male with testes, who has 5-alpha-reductase deficiency, a DSD which causes a highly undervirilized penis.
Not the best example to cite considering that Semenya has competed and won in female athletics competitions, using the strength and endurance advantages of having undergone male puberty.