3 ms·
Dubbing something "virtue signaling" is ad hominem. You're saying, "Nobody actually believes this argument. They're just pretending". You're not engaging with t
by jfengel 4y ago
Dubbing something "virtue signaling" is ad hominem. You're saying, "Nobody actually believes this argument. They're just pretending". You're not engaging with the question.
If you have something to contribute, assume that at least one person genuinely believes what they're talking about. People do, in fact, mean what they say.
- bell-cot 4y agoNot quite. I think they mostly believe the argument. (+/- how much the average human really believes any "proper" creed from their bubble.) But I have developed a sadly clear impression that the virtues signaled on-line (by a huge number of people, and I have no way to tell whether any particular HN'er might be one of them) are ~99% conditional on the signalling having a net-negative cost. FWIW - I just Googled for web pages about boycotting Florida tourism, in reaction to a certain Florida Governor's headline-grabbing opposition to Trans Rights. Perhaps the SEO geniuses at VisitFlorida.org have brilliantly blinded Google to the many & highly-popular efforts to actually do something, at the slight cost of changing vacation plans. But my inner cynic say that is a false hope. );