I’m not really bickering about names here, just trying to succinctly describe ideas. The irony of the GGP comment is that it claims mathematical ideas are succ

I’m not really bickering about names here, just trying to succinctly describe ideas. The irony of the GGP comment is that it claims mathematical ideas are successful ones and philosophical ones aren’t, but that’s not a mathematical claim. So either it’s right and it’s wrong, or it’s wrong.