4 ms·
In Defense of J.K. Rowling
- bell-cot 4y agoZzz. Jumping into internet witch-hunts against authors is popular because it's fast, free, and a good way to signal your "virtue" as one of the ideologically-correct "in" crowd - at least in your bubble. And (all too often viewed as a plus) spewing intolerance and/or hate. Vs. - I currently live in "Shining Citadel of Enlightened Liberalism" Ann Arbor (MI). It's been widely known, for a decade or more, than Kroger treats its employees poorly. But Kroger has been and is the grocery store that most of those enlightened local liberals support with their weekly grocery purchase decisions.
- jfengel 4y agoDubbing something "virtue signaling" is ad hominem. You're saying, "Nobody actually believes this argument. They're just pretending". You're not engaging with the question. If you have something to contribute, assume that at least one person genuinely believes what they're talking about. People do, in fact, mean what they say.
- bell-cot 4y agoNot quite. I think they mostly believe the argument. (+/- how much the average human really believes any "proper" creed from their bubble.) But I have developed a sadly clear impression that the virtues signaled on-line (by a huge number of people, and I have no way to tell whether any particular HN'er might be one of them) are ~99% conditional on the signalling having a net-negative cost. FWIW - I just Googled for web pages about boycotting Florida tourism, in reaction to a certain Florida Governor's headline-grabbing opposition to Trans Rights. Perhaps the SEO geniuses at VisitFlorida.org have brilliantly blinded Google to the many & highly-popular efforts to actually do something, at the slight cost of changing vacation plans. But my inner cynic say that is a false hope. );
- jdmtheNth 4y agohttps://archive.is/IrW8c https://archive.is/IrW8c I'm a little surprised to see the NYT allowing an article in support of a person unjustly accused of transphobia. Maybe some sanity is returning to the media.
- drekk 4y ago"Unjustly accused of transphobia" I think it's cool how cis people get to determine what is and is not transphobic. Forget about her writing a novel in which the protagonist is a male dressing as a woman to kill people. Forget about her bio-essentialism. Forget about her comment that only women menstruate. Forget about her desire for "biological women only" spaces. Forget about her "I'd march with trans people if they were discriminated against for being trans". Just forget everything because a billionaire said trans activists were mean to her ;(
- jdmtheNth 4y agoShe's not wrong, and disguises are a perfectly valid trope in literature. Grow up.
- fsociety 4y agoThe article skips over the whole dichotomy of “I fully support trans women and want them to live full and free lives” and “they are men dressing up as women and living a lie”.. and instead tries to paint a billionaire as a victim who’s public mansions, with public addresses on Wikipedia, were “doxxed”. I do think activists go overboard and do not condone doxxing, but it is hard to buy what the article is selling.
- brengola 4y agoIs it a dichotomy though? One can consider transwomen to be a variety of cross-dressing man, while also supporting their rights to live their lives freely without abuse or harassment.
- drekk 4y agoYou don't support their right to live freely without abuse or harassment if you call them "cross-dressing men". You can't have it both ways. There's no way to say "I think trans women are perverted deviant men in costumes trying to sexually assault people in women's restrooms" while also supporting trans rights. You are dehumanizing them with that statement.
- brengola 4y agoThis: > if you call them "cross-dressing men" is a very different viewpoint to this: > to say "I think trans women are perverted deviant men in costumes trying to sexually assault people in women's restrooms" The first statement just points out that they are not really women. No big deal, just a statement of fact, and not at all incompatible with upholding their human rights. The second statement is full of unsubstantiated accusations about their conduct. I agree that it's intended to demonise and dehumanise. However, it's nothing at all like the first statement - to conflate the two is a nonsense.
- drekk 4y agoThe second statement is what is implied by Rowling's call for "biological women only restrooms". The first statement is not fact. "Not really women" according to whom? Do we have to test all "women" for karytotypes nowadays? What if their primary and secondary sex characteristics don't line up. If it's about reproduction then are sterile women not women? The fact of the matter is you cannot come up with a definition of womanhood that ONLY excludes trans women. It's kind of incredible people don't understand the dehumanization behind "you're just pretending sweetie I know your gender better than you" EDIT: it's also very much the case that these laws about ascertaining "biological sex" hurt cis women too. see Caster Semenya as an example. so if Rowling really cared about cis women she wouldn't be advocating for segregating trans people into their own spaces.