3 ms·
The failure of the DMCA is that there is no consequences for filing an incorrect takedown request. The entertainment industry has, on many occasions, taken dow
by wvenable 15y ago
The failure of the DMCA is that there is no consequences for filing an incorrect takedown request. The entertainment industry has, on many occasions, taken down content that doesn't belong to them. In one instance, with the megaupload video, it appears the DMCA was used maliciously.
This is, in fact, the main reason to oppose SOPA and PIPA. It gives the entertainment industry even more takedown powers (ads, financial instutions, domain names) and even less oversight.
You could argue that SOPA/PIPA isn't unreasonable if there were added protections of due process and significant penalties for abusing the system. But there isn't. If the DMCA is currently being abused, it stands to reason that SOPA/PIPA will be as well.
- coffeeaddicted 15y agoI see the anti-circumvention provisions of the DMCA as another really bad part of that law. Bascially the reason why watching legally DVD's on a pure opensource system is no longer possible in the US.