2 ms·
> You always try to read the law and tick the boxes, and I’m here to tell you its a profoundly uninteresting thing to do when not in the company of lawyers. Nob
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> You always try to read the law and tick the boxes, and I’m here to tell you its a profoundly uninteresting thing to do when not in the company of lawyers. Nobody here cares about the formal requirements or motivation behind bail. We care about how this fraudster came to sit at home playing video games and chatting up witnesses all day, while many many others sit in jail as their cases drawl out, and many indeed die there.
He does it because of the formal requirements and motivations behind bail, and particularly how those differ between the federal system and the bulk of the state systems.
So, you can not want to talk about the details of formal requirements and motivations, but then you don’t really care about how he got where he is when other accused criminals are treated differently. You just want to vent about the difference without understanding.
- zmgsabst 4y agoNo — they’re interested in how as explored through power dynamics, not how explored through technical analysis of the pretense used. The latter is uninteresting; the former interests the public who is concerned by inequality in our legal system. No amount of screaming “but the pretense type checks!” will be a useful or interesting answer to this discussion about social class.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> No — they’re interested in how as explored through power dynamics The motivations behind bail are the power dynamics. And the difference between the motivations–the power dynamics–in the federal and most state systems are central to the issue here, and are directly reflected in the different formal requirements. Waving those off is choosing ignorance.