4 ms·
And (currently-existing) lumberjacks have always cut down trees, and (because of an identity now largely grounded therein) probably always will. Still, I'd rat
by SilasX 15y ago
And (currently-existing) lumberjacks have always cut down trees, and (because of an identity now largely grounded therein) probably always will.
Still, I'd rather not have to depend on charity-lumberjacking, you know? If someone wants to chop down trees for free, that's between him and his god (or dryad, as the case may be). If that's the only way trees ever get cut down? God help us all.
Above statement refers, for purposes of argument, to sustainable tree harvesting, so as to avoid irrelevant side tangents.
- ThomPete 15y agoWay to go making a comparison that makes no sense at all. A lumberjack can't digitally mass produce cutting down trees. They have to actually be present at each tree.
- SilasX 15y agoYes, I know that you can identify differences between abolition of copyright and a ban on all monetary compensation for lumberjacks. What you cannot do, however, is find a difference that distinguishes them in a way that defends your argument that we shouldn't worry about a world where X is only produced by charity, since some people do X for free. If you don't care that art would only be produced for free, neither should you care if lumberjacking only happened by charity. If you're not ready to go that far, you might not want to lean so heavily on the argument that "(some) artists create for free".
- ThomPete 15y agoAgain who is talking about doing something for free? Don't blame me for you lack of imagination that would have allowed you to see a world where artist could create without making money on digitally mass produced songs. It is possible plenty of people are doing it. So please spare me the strawmen.
- SilasX 15y ago>Again who is talking about doing something for free? The guy that cracked your account and used it to make these comments: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3480634 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3480634 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3480674 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3480674 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3480761 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3480761 >Don't blame me for you lack of imagination that would have allowed you to see a world where artist could create without making money on digitally mass produced songs. I'm sure, that, just as with making music, there are revenue models for lumberjacking that don't involve charging for lumberjacking services. For example, they could broadcast live video of themselves chopping down trees and charge for that. Or maybe trees should only be cut down by their owners so they're not technically earning money from chopping down a tree. Or, you know, we could just bypass the whole charade and let people charge for the lumberjacking/artistic creations that they were responsible for (if they so wish) rather than stick to some ideological belief that it's somehow wrong to do so while hoping they come up with some convoluted way to accomplish the same thing with more restricted means. It's great that there are ways to produce good X without invoking exclusivity rights in X; but for those (many) cases where X wouldn't otherwise be produced, I would like for that model to be an option. That doesn't mean the current copyright regime is optimal; far from it. It just means that the mentality of "IP sucks and everyone will produce valuable stuff for free" is looney.
- ThomPete 15y agoYou know just because you keep repeating the same strawmen it doesn't make them more true. If you cant see the difference between a performance and copying the performance to re-sell it, then frankly there isn't much to discuss.
- SilasX 15y agoJust in case you're not noticing it (and I can understand why you wouldn't), your involvement on this topic pretty much consists of: - offering an argument, - being shown how it is flawed, and then - ignoring the explanation you were just given, to fall back on a variant of "copying is free". I think a lot of us readers would prefer it if you engage the arguments given to you.