9 ms·
Apple Reportedly Planning to Limit iPhone 15 USB-C Port in Same Way as Lightning
- cm2187 4y agoWould a USB-C port that cannot connect to anything but Apple's approved hardware even comply with the legislation? I thought the whole point was interoperability, particularly in term of chargers. If Apple sticks a port that looks like a USB-C port but that doesn't behave like a USB-C port, surely it won't be treated as a USB-C port?
- baybal2 4y ago[dead]
- CubsFan1060 4y agoI don't think anyone is talking about that. Currently you can use any USB-C or USB-A charging brick to charge your phone. And even non-certified Lightning cables charge the phone. Even if they limit it "the same as lightning", charging will be just fine. The EU rulings seem to be exclusively about charging: https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2022/10/24/common-charger-eu-ministers-give-final-approval-to-one-size-fits-all-charging-port/ https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2022...
- toyg 4y agoConsidering that charging is the most dangerous thing a cable can do, Apple's motives for this sort of restrictions can be boiled down to the usual monopolistic approach.
- CubsFan1060 4y agoAnd yet... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juice_jacking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juice_jacking Specifically, note "Mactans" https://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2013/07/31/researchers-demonstrate-how-to-install-iphone-malware-with-a-malicious-charger/?sh=525a06ca254e https://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2013/07/31/resear... "As a proof of concept, the three researchers created a malicious version of an iOS Facebook app that also includes a Trojan that runs in the background, capable of taking screenshots, simulating button touches, and sending data to a remote server."
- toyg 4y agoThat was done by exploiting developer mode, and was fixed by asking the user before any data transmission is enabled. The only thing that is allowed "blindly", and hence the most dangerous, is charging. No need for any racketeeri-- sorry, Apple-controlled whitelist.
- sa1 4y agoHow is it fixed when a significant percentage of the customer base will end up clicking yes, some due to ignorance, some by pure error? This isn't how security works.
- toyg 4y agoMoving goalposts will not change the fact that Apple whitelisting this or that device does nothing beyond helping their bank balance.
- reaperducer 4y agoConsidering that charging is the most dangerous thing a cable can do You must not have been around for the era when data exfiltration via charging cables and bricks was a thing. Buy a charging cable from some random Chinese reseller on Amazon, and bingo — data in your phones goes back to the PRC. I still have about five little black USB security dongles in my drawer from this era. They only allowed the charging pins to connect to the phone or computer. The data lines are physically disconnected. We used to call them "charging condoms."
- palata 4y agoMFi is not about the cable. It's about authenticating the accessory. I see it as some kind of DRM, because you can't reverse-engineer the protocol and connect your own accessory. I like Android's AOAP better for this reason.
- theshrike79 4y agoSee the case of fried Nintendo Switches a few years ago to see how messy the USB-C power delivery scene is.
- CubsFan1060 4y agoBefore everyone freaks out, consider that it's highly likely that: * All USBC Cables will work for charging * Probably all USBC cables will work for connecting to accessories * Data will only be allowed to pass to a certified accessory I think this is more likely to be very careful about what accessories you can use versus trying to stop you from being able to use an average usb cable to charge.
- rfoo 4y agoOK, so that's trying to stop us from being able to use an average USB cable to do anything but charge.
- CubsFan1060 4y agoYup. Which satisfies the EU law and behaves the same to lightning cables. I don't see anything in the EU law that says every single device has to interoperate with every accessory.
- mqus 4y agoWhile this may be true, it is just a short-term solution because the EU will just change the law again if it annoys too much. It would be far more easy for all of us to not only follow the letter of the law but also its spirit. But this wouldn't be a very Apple thing to do.
- CubsFan1060 4y agoThe stated goals of the eu law are about ewaste. Can you explain how you think the spirit of the law is that every device needs to support all accessories? Do earbuds have to support external hard drives?
- sowuttho 4y agoFWIW personally fine with Apple MITM the verification process. USB cables available online from any arbitrary retailer could be so wildly out of spec they burn out gadgets, or include some phone home thing. Of course technologists will scoff as of course they’re the only people on the planet.
- nickvanw 4y ago> It is worth noting that the USB-C interface currently used by Apple in the 10th-generation iPad, iPad mini, iPad Air, and iPad Pro, do not contain an IC chip for authentication, meaning that this would be a first for ports of this kind offered by the company. These are rumors, easy bait for clicks. I'll happily eat my words when this comes to fruition, but at this point is there any evidence Apple is actually interested in doing this?
- giobox 4y agoThe MFI (Made for iPhone) program is today a significant revenue generator, allowing Apple to take a commission on every certified iPhone accessory. if Apple wish to continue licensing accessories for money in this way they will likely need some way of identifying approved accessories as they can with Lightning today. The MFI program largely makes money because Apple control the lightning connector interface and can thus be the gatekeeper. While I don't like it personally, it does make some sense to me the mfi program might want this feature for a USB-C iPhone and future iPad models. Like others, I suspect it would be data access only limited to the certified devices - any old USB-C cable will likely still work to charge. This likely satisfies the EU charging law changes and lets them keep much of the MFI revenues. That the MFI program exists is frankly evidence enough for me to believe Apple would do this - they sell many more iPhones than iPads, and the change can be incorporated into future iPad models. > https://mfi.apple.com/ https://mfi.apple.com/
- reaperducer 4y agoMFI (Made for iPhone) program is today a significant revenue generator Apple is notorious for not breaking out revenue specifics in its public financial reports. What source are you using to determine that MFI revenue is "significant?"
- giobox 4y agoYou don't need to be Apple to work out that its a large number - the number of devices and cables bearing the MFI logo sold every year across the world is pretty nuts.
- unxdfa 4y agoLets wait and see. Most of the Apple rumors have about a 50% hit rate. Sometimes things are worse, sometimes better. I know that's not very exciting but there's just no point in reacting to something which isn't on the market yet. There was the same complaints thing when the iPad Pro moved over to USB-C and that turned out to be a full TB3 implementation after a couple of generations.
- japanman425 4y ago>50% hit rate As in, they are either correct or they are not…
- Gigachad 4y agoFaulty way of seeing it. Like saying the sun has 50% chance of rising tomorrow as it either does rise or it does not.
- japanman425 4y agoNow you’re getting it!
- renewiltord 4y agoThat's the thing about Steph Curry and me both taking 3s. Either it goes in or out. 50% chance. Signing up for the Warriors next week.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwntoday 4y agoThere's really no winning for Apple here. Whether they limit cable types or provide a disclaimer, people will go to their stores and complain "This phone is broken, it won't connect to my computer!". They'll train their employees to explain "Sorry not all USB-C cables are capable of transmitting data" much like they had to train them to say "No that iPad uses USB-C, you can't use a lightning cable to charge it". No one will ever blame themselves, or the shoddy cables, they will always blame Apple.
- malermeister 4y agoIf they add some custom authentication chip to limit compatibility however, Apple will be to blame if things don't work.
- selcuka 4y agoNot really. If you purchase a cable from somewhere else and it doesn't work with your iPhone, Apple will say "no idea, it's not our cable". If your Apple custom USB-C cable doesn't work with your Android phone, Apple will say "no idea, it's not our device". Apple only guarantees that an Apple iPhone can transfer data through an Apple (or Apple certified) USB-C cable. Nothing more, nothing less. They don't have to manufacture their cables to be compliant with USB-IF standards as the EU law is only about charging and not about data transfer.
- malermeister 4y agoWell Apple can say whatever they want, that doesn't change the fact they're to blame. The reason it wouldn't work would be that they put in hardware to prevent it from working. Of course that's their fault.
- selcuka 4y agoThe EU laws are to blame. The law should have been "the manufacturer will implement USB-IF compliant charging and connectivity" instead of "there will be a port that has the same form factor as USB-C that can be used for charging". I believe the second revision of the law will be to this effect, which Apple will comply in 2030.
- bastard_op 4y agoAnd now you have USB-C-Apple to keep you guessing. So this just brings us full circle that now we're going to have still apple vs. everyone else connectors, power adapters, etc and now it's going to be more confusing as you won't always know the difference until something frys. All this means is the first Chinese company to get their hands on the new chips will still reverse engineer it, clone the first keys they get, and resume dumping cloned apple crap gadgets without any certifications. All so Apple can keep selling goddamn dongles to the rich herds that don't mind the Apple tax. Way to go, the perfect perversion of the intended results. I do hope the EU crams this down their throats and keep them on the hook for non-compliance by just creating a new divergent usb-c spec for themselves.
- palata 4y agoI don't know if it counts as a divergent USB-C spec to be honest. For instance, I can create a device that takes USB-C for charging and for a keyboard, but that does not mean that my device must support ethernet-over-usb, right? Such an iOS device could support USB-C charging, but e.g. only accept ethernet-over-usb from certified adapters. I don't think that they can force the cable to be authentified, it's really just that there must be their authentication coprocessor on the accessory side.
- smoldesu 4y agoUSB is a universal serial bus - if you're using that bus to eliminate the universality or seriality of it's data, you may as well be using your own cable. If Apple goes through with this (and I suspect they won't), the antitrust response will drop like a Smash Brothers character announcement. It happened when they got cheeky with Dutch regulators, nothing is stopping it from happening again.
- scarface74 4y agoTake a random USB C cord today. Will it transfer video? What data speed will it support? What power?
- 4y ago
- zahma 4y agoThis sounds naive, but why is it advantageous for Apple to limit transfer speeds? I understand adding a chip to control which accessories are fully compatible, but isn’t this a missed opportunity for Apple to tote new transfer speeds? Or would they only relegate transfer speeds for uncertified products?
- GloriousKoji 4y agoMarket segmentation. If you want the fancy new advertised transfer speeds you'll have to buy the more expensive Pro line.
- ThatPlayer 4y agoI believe it's simply that their older SoCs do not support USB 3 because it has never needed it. And the base not-Pro models will probably re-use the last year's Pro SoCs as it did this year. My bet is the new Pros will use a new SoC, and then the year after base phones will re-use that SoC and have USB 3. Even when they re-used the iPhone SoCs for iPads, their solution is to add a separate USB 3.0 host controller, while leaving the client USB on the SoC USB 2.0: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/ipad-mini-6-is-still-usb2-0-when-connect-to-mac.2313014/ https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/ipad-mini-6-is-still-us... . That didn't stop them from advertising it as USB 3.0 of course.
- kelnos 4y agoI guess we shouldn't be surprised. It feels like Apple does this sort of thing out of spite. "You're going to require us to do something? Ok, but we're going to pervert it and twist it and avoid the spirit of the requirement."
- CharlesW 4y agoIt's interesting that you feel that Apple is somehow anti-USB-C, when Apple contributed to the standard and was an early adopter both on laptops and tablets. I'll propose an alternative explanation to "Apple has contempt for users like me": At Apple scale, the first version of any radical change (and this is one, after a decade of Lightning) must limit risk. Based on that, of course Apple will initially limit connections to chargers known to work, and the way they do that is via MFi.
- fold3 4y agoWhat will happen for people that have Ipad pro cables and accessories? Those are usb-c and don't have any mfi chip afaik.
- palata 4y agoMFi is there to authenticate the accessory (using an authentication coprocessor which supposedly cannot be reverse-engineered). But that does not say that the chip has to be in the cable, does it? It just means that the iOS device may require authentication, so the accessory device needs the chip. In that case, it's all compliant: we could reuse the chargers/usb cables. It's just that not all accessories will be allowed, which is another problem. Of course I'm not a big fan of the MFi-related costs, and I think it would be nice to have an open version of it (just like AOAP on Android). But in terms of security, being able to cryptographically authenticate the accessory from an iOS app is actually nice.
- AbusiveHNAdmin 4y agoNot necessarily. Tons of audio-connector cables stopped working overnight when Apple pettily disabled them. One end of the cable was Lightning, and the other two ends were USB A and a 1/8" stereo audio plug.
- palata 4y agoI see. Well I can't imagine that it would be fine to require an MFi chip in USB-C cables. Because that destroys the whole point of using USB-C cables indeed. If the rumor is true, I would bet that it's more about bringing MFi to USB-C devices. Which is totally compatible with USB-C.
- AbusiveHNAdmin 4y agoIt's about two things for Apple: 1. Wringing extra revenue out of every possible angle 2. Preventing developers from doing anything unforeseen; a longtime Apple mania
- tshaddox 4y agoI'm not sure if I believe this rumor yet. I haven't seen that "This accessory is not supported" message on an Apple device in many years (and even then, it was only when a legit cable was starting to wear out). I've used several cheap chargers and accessories that I'm almost certain are not "Apple certified." Does this program even still exist? Also, iPad Pros have USB-C, and as far as I can tell they are broadly compatible with things like USB audio interfaces which I'm also fairly confident have not gone through any sort of Apple certification process.
- AbusiveHNAdmin 4y agoThat's because all those third-party vendors probably went out of business or abandoned Apple. I had lots of Y adapters to work around the problem Apple created but never solved: There was no way to charge the phone AND use an asinine headphone-jack dongle. The answer was a simple cable, with no power source. Overnight, they all stopped working because Apple wasn't getting its fee from those manufacturers.
- palata 4y ago> I haven't seen that "This accessory is not supported" message on an Apple device in many years Well with the lightning cable it's pretty clear that it has to be MFi-certified, right? > iPad Pros have USB-C, and as far as I can tell they are broadly compatible with things like USB audio interfaces which I'm also fairly confident have not gone through any sort of Apple certification process. Sure. The thing is that MFi is some kind of authentication that goes on top. To me it really feels like they were forced to move to USB-C, so they did it, and now the rumor says that they are porting MFi to USB-C (which makes total sense, I don't see a reason for them to drop the MFi program). "Activating" MFi with USB-C is just a matter of updating the software (assuming that they have the cryptography hardware in the device). IMHO the rumor is really plausible. Actually I was expecting MFi to be there from the beginning on, and I was confused by the fact that it was not there: I don't see USB-C as a technical reason for them to drop MFi.
- tshaddox 4y ago> Well with the lightning cable it's pretty clear that it has to be MFi-certified, right? I don't know, but I would have said no. Is this thing certified by Apple? https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/USB-mini-Fan-Custom-Logo-Promotional_60782661620.html?spm=a2700.galleryofferlist.normal_offer.d_title.27f31113FiwiTb https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/USB-mini-Fan-Custom-L...
- gigel82 4y agoDoes that include limiting to USB2.0 speeds for copying images to PCs?
- b212 4y agoThat’s hilarious. EU: everyone has use USB-C now. Apple: hold my beer. As much as I loathe "late stage capitalism" - the USB-C was a wrong choice from the very beginning.
- AbusiveHNAdmin 4y agoThat doesn't make sense.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- system2 4y agoI am totally fine with USB-C charging only. I don't remember the last time I plugged my phone for anything else.
- Brian_K_White 4y agoApple's disingenuous safety excuse is easily dispatched: It's not Apple's job to police the world of cheap usbc cables.
- palata 4y agoActually, USB is generally a security concern (some corporations disable the USB ports in their computers). So there is a case to make for security by having more control on the data that goes over USB. But I don't think that it is about authenticating the cable. Rather it's about authenticating the accessory. Which I believe makes sense in terms of security (well Android doesn't do it with AOAP and nobody cares, but that's a design decision).
- alviezhang 4y ago[dead]
- blacklight 4y agoI still fail to see the case for a tech-savvy user to ever purchase or use a single Apple device. We don't need an ecosystem that doesn't allow to change much on our devices. We don't need an ecosystem that won't even let us charge our devices with the cables that are supposed to fit them. Apple deserve to rot and die in its own arrogance.
- jacknews 4y agoIMHO if USB-C stuff doesn't work with Apple's USB-C, then Apple's USB-C is not really USB-C and should n't get certification. Standards must be defended against corruption and degradation, and if those standards are mandatory, then everyone's implementation of it must be compliant.