8 ms·
As a cpu buyer, I'd like amd and intel to get stuck at 50-50 market share and fight tooth and nail by introducing cheaper and faster models every year. And mayb
by nottorp 4y ago
As a cpu buyer, I'd like amd and intel to get stuck at 50-50 market share and fight tooth and nail by introducing cheaper and faster models every year. And maybe discover low power computing, although that's wishful thinking.
- sagarm 4y agoYou can set lower power limits for both AMD and Intel's chips to improve perf/watt. AMD benefits more than Intel when doing so. Here's some more reading if you're interested: https://www.anandtech.com/show/17641/lighter-touch-cpu-power-scaling-13900k-7950x https://www.anandtech.com/show/17641/lighter-touch-cpu-power...
- nottorp 4y agoI can and I have. There's a ryzen limited to 70 W in the bios under my desk :) 99.99% of the population doesn't know this option exists. And 0.01% want BIGGER NUMBERS OMG 720FPS!!! and ruin power consumption worldwide for everyone else.
- sliken 4y agoI blame Intel for that. They pushed the clock speed high for silly small perf gains. AMD could take the high road, then media would brag about how fast Intel is and AMD would lose market share.
- MrFoof 4y agoIndeed. The game Intel used to play is now the game everyone plays -- Intel, AMD, and NVIDIA, for both consumer CPUs and GPUs. At least on the desktop. They tend to run them to redline by default, because numbers. It's all about getting that big splash at launch, to ride it for higher average sale price as long as possible. Which is unfortunate, because when it comes to benchmarks, understanding the context of a test setup is extraordinarily important. Are you buying that very high-end memory the test setup used and then manually adjusting timings? No? Then you're not getting those numbers. Heck, you may be losing 20% or more performance compared to the test rig on just the difference in memory. Never mind adjusting other things, ensuring the system's thermals are entirely kept in check to prevent throttling, etc.
- snvzz 4y ago>AMD could take the high road, then media would brag about how fast Intel is and AMD would lose market share. This already happened in previous generations (especially Zen2). AMD has to play this stupid game, unfortunately, because the press is what it is.
- midoridensha 4y ago>I blame Intel for that. As you should. I worked at Intel back in the 00s when they were in the "megahertz wars". All they talked about internally was "we're winning the MHz wars!!! Yay!". When anyone mentioned power consumption, or how fucking loud the cooling fans were, or MIPS/Watt, they didn't care; all that mattered was MHz. Hitching their wagon to RAMBUS memory was part of this. Then they got pissed and indignant when consumers didn't want to spend a fortune on RAMBUS memory and bought AMD CPUs with cheap SDRAM instead.
- sliken 4y agoThat fits. The p4 had a long pipeline, high clock speed, and poor perf per MHz. AMD pushed the general performance score, forget the name, and seems like the succeeded. Doubly so since they shipped x86-64 first, which people did care about. I wrote a few microbenchmarks to explore the performance promises of rambus, and didn't find anything.
- ncann 4y agoWhat is this option? I would like to know more about it.
- sliken 4y agoMy summary is AMD is hurt MUCH less than Intel by lowering the power. One example from the article: Cinebench R23 multithread: Ryzen 7950X 230 -> 125 watts = 95% Ryzen 7950X 230 -> 105 watts = 93% Ryzen 7950X 230 -> 65 watts = 81% Intel I9-13900k 253 watts -> 125 watts = 78% Intel I9-13900k 253 watts -> 105 watts = 72% Intel I9-13900k 253 watts -> 65 watts = 56% Other benchmarks like C-ray show ZERO slowdown going from 230 -> 125 and even 105 watts. Intel drops by 21% for 125 watts and 30% for 105 watts. Personally I'd rather get the 7900X (or non-x) and you'd keep an even larger fraction of the performance within a given power limit. It's pretty clear who has the worse core and has to push harder into high clock/terrible power usage for not much gain curve.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoI'm a little dubious of benchmarks that compare only one pair of chips when it comes to details like power efficiency and tweaking. The silicon lottery can make a big difference.
- sliken 4y agoSure. Various forums corroborate the reducing the Ryzen 7000 series at 65 TDP is often a less than 10% decrease in performance. Also keep in mind that "performance mode" on Intel can significantly increase the default 253 watt TDP. Anandtech reviews of the i9-13900k hit 380 watts I believe. So sure there's chip to chip variation, but generally the AMD chips are more power efficient and have much lower penalties for reducing the TDP.
- inawarminister 4y agoDo you know how to undervolt laptop Ryzens? I'm really interested if we can increase the battery life by another 30-40% or so
- scheme271 4y agoThe easiest way is to go to the bios or cpu settings and change the precision optimizer so that you have a negative pbo setting. That'll reduce the stock voltage at a given frequency. It'll also potentially speed your chip up since this lets the chip boost to higher frequencies at a given power level. I think the lowest you can go is -30, but try -20 or so and see if your system is stable before trying lower values.
- joveian 4y agoYou can set various power settings that suggest that they are limits, but at least in the Skylake NUC I have they really don't do much and certainly don't limit the maximum power the system uses at all. The article doesn't talk enough about the actual power use vs the settings although it sounds like while both are going over there might actually be some limiting in the recent chips.
- sagarm 4y agoThat Anandtech article did include some power measurements on page three, but given those measurements show the limits are applied inconsistently between AMD and Intel it would have been nice to have power measurements on other graphs too.
- imiric 4y agoThe upcoming Phoenix APUs from AMD are a game-changer for portable and handheld devices. Between 15 and 45W TDP, Zen4/RDNA3... They're slowly trickling out to thin and light laptops, but I can't wait to get them in the next Steam Deck killer.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI still want them to release a 6W chip. Intel still owns that part of the x86 market, and actually has decent chips.
- vamega 4y agoAgreed! The N5105/6005 have been remarkable, and maybe they’ll replicate that with the Alder Lake N chips. Chinese ODMs seem to have already started making mini-pcs with the new chips, and I imagine routers will follow quickly. Until AMD’s media engine improves, the Intel chips will still be valued by the Plex/Emby crowd.
- nottorp 4y ago> I imagine routers will follow quickly. I'd love a new router board with a 6 W CPU and some storage ports. But all I can find is media player boards with at most one ethernet. Dream board atm would have said 6 W CPU, DC power, two ethernets, one 2.5 Gbps, and some M.2 and SATA slots. For a combined routing/storage box.
- vamega 4y agoHave you seen this? It’s a 10W CPU but mostly seems to hit everything you’re looking for. I imagine an Alder lake N version of this will appear sooner or later, and the N100/N200 should give you the 6W part you’re looking for. https://m.aliexpress.us/item/3256804762512339.html?gatewayAdapt=Pc2Msite https://m.aliexpress.us/item/3256804762512339.html?gatewayAd...
- nottorp 4y ago
- sliken 4y agoIndeed, ideally 3 companies to help ensure there's not some agreement to raise prices. Apple's largely not in the same market, but is pushing the edge when it comes to performance per watt, even shipping products gasp without fans.
- diordiderot 4y ago> 3 companies My sweet summer child. You should read about tacit collusion.
- sliken 4y agoDoes it happen, sure. Seems like Apple's increasingly happy to hit lower price points and disrupt the price structure for AMD and Intel based product lines. Similarly Intel seems to finally be getting it's act together and setting up to disrupt the AMD and Nvidia GPU market. Here's hoping. I saw a pretty decent GPU (RTX3080) for $420 recently!
- 0cf8612b2e1e 4y agoUntil I can slap an Apple chip into my random Linux build, those numbers are meaningless to me. Would require absolutely enormous performance improvements to justify making such a huge leap.
- sliken 4y agoLike say going from 80GB/sec memory bandwidth to 400GB/sec? Or maybe having the iGPU performance go up 4-8x so most won't need a $500+ GPU? I'm considering an Apple studio, once refreshed with the M2 Max, even for Linux. Sure the GPU driver isn't quite there, but it's improving quickly.
- dotnet00 4y agoYeah, don't really need a $500 GPU on a platform which barely supports applications which really need that $500 GPU.
- outworlder 4y agoI would prefer many competitors instead of a duopoly. Do not forget ARM.
- xwdv 4y agoNo, it is better for AMD to pull far ahead so that the next challenger is forced to come up with even greater innovation to steal market share. This is better than just having two large vendors locked in a back and forth game of one up manship and incremental innovation.
- midoridensha 4y agoScrew that; I want them to dump x86 altogether and move to ARM, or maybe come up with something even better, to compete with Apple's M2. Why are we stuck with this shitty old ISA from the 1970s?
- jeroenhd 4y agoARM came out the same year as 32 bit x86. Both architectures are very old. I very much doubt that architecture is all that relevant for their advancements in power usage. Apple's chips contain a significant x86 feature without ruining battery life. Meanwhile, Qualcom is struggling to compete with Apple in both performance and efficiency despite being in the ARM space for much longer. I'm sure if Apple could've gotten an x64 license ten years ago, they would've made their own x64 chips instead of switching to ARM. When Apple's plans started coming together, there simply were no competing architectures they could base their chips on. MIPS was practically dead already, x64 was extremely closed off, RISC-V wasn't even announced and struggles to keep up today and it wasn't even announced when Apple started selling their own chips. Maybe they could've licensed POWER6 or an early version of POWER7? The POWER architecture isn't exactly widely used or designed to be power efficient; power management wasn't introduced until 2017 and even then it was optional. There simply weren't any serious alternatives to licensing ARM and Apple would be stupid to develop an entirely separate CPU architecture for their desktop/laptop/tablet form factors.
- wkat4242 4y agoIt would have been pretty cool if they'd gone back to the Power platform though. Full circle.
- thowieruo2343 4y ago... because we're stuck with the shitty programming languages and development paradigms from the 1970s.
- kibwen 4y ago> Why are we stuck with this shitty old ISA from the 1970s? ARM is from the 1980s, let's just jump right to RISC-V instead. :)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bartread 4y agoI agree with you, although I'd prefer to see (at least) a three way duke out between Intel, AMD, and ARM. I really don't think living in a world where there's (basically) only one CPU architecture and instruction set is going to be as beneficial as one in which there is competition on more than simply price and power consumption.