4 ms·
People who equate speech with violence have generally never known physical violence. I've always held that position firmly. The trouble is, people are turning
by CamperBob2 4y ago
People who equate speech with violence have generally never known physical violence.
I've always held that position firmly. The trouble is, people are turning out to be a lot more programmable than I thought they (we) were. You could almost say that we're becoming more like machines at the same time that machines are becoming more like us. To the extent that's true, the part of the old saying that goes "... but words will never hurt me" can be seen as less valid.
- fallingknife 4y agoPeople who equate speech with violence are usually looking for a way to respond to speech with violence.
- pessimizer 4y agoAgreed. It's an announcement that you've determined that some speech has to be crushed, but also preemptively framing it as self-defense. It's like when you first hear about Libertarians having a Non-Aggression Principle at their core, but then you start to hear how they redefine "aggression." In a very similar way, when Group A starts calling Group B "terrorist," it's really an announcement that Group A is going to be compromising their own professed ethics and processes to destroy Group B. It's an announcement of martial law, not a label that reliably describes any particular behavior by "terrorist" groups. Speech- and thought-violence rhetoric is just empty rationalization and crybully rhetoric from the powerless, but it's often a prelude to a brutal crackdown when it comes from the powerful.
- flippinburgers 4y agoYou bring up a very observable fact about how the extreme left is approaching the right via antifa. I don't see a reason for downvotes.
- fallingknife 4y agoMy comment is not directed towards any one political orientation.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI don't know if this is true all the time. I think knowingly sending rape threats to rape victims is pretty violent behavior. I think knowingly trying to trigger someone into an eating disorder relapse or coercing someone into suicide are heinous things that fall into violence. I think there is a line where speech can be violent or said with the intent to harm someone the same as a punch is.
- CamperBob2 4y agoI think knowingly sending rape threats to rape victims is pretty violent behavior Compared to the actual act of rape? No. That kind of thinking just devalues the victim. That said, specific threats aren't normally examples of protected speech. Extreme cases make bad law.
- Ztynovovk 4y ago[dead]
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI also agree extreme cases make bad law. That's why I'm disagreeing with the extreme that there are no exceptions to the notion of speech not being violent.
- CamperBob2 4y agoI think we have to be careful not to put words in each others' mouths here. To be clear, I am not saying that specific, credible threats of violence should be treated as "speech" in the First Amendment sense. In my view, the status quo, where most speech is fair game until it rises to the level of coercive threats, is about right.
- robertlagrant 4y agoThings can be bad without being violent. I don't understand this widespread push to try and erase the difference between non-violent bad things and violent bad things.
- johnny22 4y agohow much physical violence is enough? Getting jumped by a crowd of dudes for no reason? Getting held up at gunpoint? There was definitely some other stuff as well, but those are the most memorable. I do admit that i haven't been in an actual warzone though.
- CamperBob2 4y agoSo you're saying that you equate speech (not credible, specific threats or other extreme examples of non-protected speech) with having your life threatened physically. I wish I could understand where you're coming from. I genuinely do. ------------- Replying here due to rate limit: That's why I said "generally." I'm not setting out to invalidate or disrespect any individual's experience. It's likely that we'd have no trouble finding Holocaust survivors who would equate Nazi rhetoric with violence, for instance. They would agree with your position, given that such rhetoric arguably facilitated violence against them that would not otherwise have occurred. German law reflects this point of view. But my position has traditionally been that prior restraint empowers the bad guys to an even greater extent. You don't want Nazis spreading messages of hate and violence... but you really don't want them telling you what you can say, if/when they come to power again.
- johnny22 4y agoThe quote was: > People who equate speech with violence have generally never known physical violence. Just wondering if that meets the standard or not. Not that I think all speech is violence though. I just think you setup a strawman.
- anigbrowl 4y agoHe said nothing like that.
- CamperBob2 4y agoThe important thing is that you're here to tell us what everybody else is saying. The ironic thing is that nobody can be certain what you're saying.
- Zetice 4y agoI dunno if I agree with you overall, but getting punched in the face in the street is wildly different from someone calling you a bad name on the Internet, so on that point I entirely agree. Getting punched in the face is primal, it gets into that part of your brain that we’re all wisely told to suppress, the animalistic nature of us upright apes. It’s… well, nobody has ever said anything to me online that has caused me to feel even a fraction of what I’ve felt getting punched in the face. I don’t know how or even if that contributes to the conversation, but I think it’s worth saying.
- neonsunset 4y agoAgree, nor do they have accurate grasp of reality, living in sheltered environments expecting internet rules apply to physical world. Getting punched in the face is a good start.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI have a lot of experience with physical violence. The Brandenburg criteria of specificity and imminence are useful legal yardsticks, but they also assume every set of circumstances is isolated from everything else and can can considered independently, almost in a social vacuum. This is partly the outcome of the Anglo-American legal tradition and the reductive philosophical approach it uses. It's less clear cut in the real world. To some extent one must be willing to tolerate negative incoming messages, or otherwise one would never leave one's home ot risk any interaction at all. On the other hand, to argue that no speech act can ever have a violent component by definition is facile; much speech as a prelude the violence, and a lack of specificity in space, manner, or time just as easily be designed to stoke fear by strategically using uncertainty to render its object paranoid and exhaust their defensive capability in advance. Much of this discourse at present is purely strategic, and often wildly disingenuous. Many people who speak in lofty terms about free speech (not specifying anyone in particular here) are notably silent when it comes to people harrassing librarians or allegations that drag shows = groomers + pedophilia and therefore are legitimate targets for physical or terroristic violence (bomb threats and the like that are sufficiently credible to provoke a police response).
- trieste92 4y ago> that are sufficiently credible to provoke a police response They do promote a police response because making a bomb threat is illegal in itself. Harassment is illegal in itself You don't need to redefine a bunch of words and do a bunch of mental gymnastics to make something that's already illegal illegal
- anigbrowl 4y agoSo what? I'm not arguing about the legal contours, I'm arguing about general concepts of meaning and risk management, outside of a legal context. I said so explicitly at the beginning of my comment.
- CamperBob2 4y agoMuch of this discourse at present is purely strategic, and often wildly disingenuous. Many people who speak in lofty terms about free speech (not specifying anyone in particular here) are notably silent when it comes to people harrassing librarians or allegations that drag shows = groomers + pedophilia and therefore are legitimate targets for physical or terroristic violence (bomb threats and the like that are sufficiently credible to provoke a police response). Now, imagine that the bad actors you're referring to have come to power, and because you've nerfed 1A, they now have the power of prior restraint over your speech, and that of their victims. Still think it's a net win? ------------Replying here due to rate limiting: The big problem I have with what you wrote is "much speech (is) a prelude (to) violence," used in a context that seemingly justifies equating the speech with the violence that ensues. This is an argument for prior restraint. No?