3 ms·
Judge orders SBF to stop using VPNs [pdf]
- LatteLazy 4y agoOn the one hand it's nice judges are patient and lean towards liberty. On the other hand people who keep blatantly, knowingly breaking bail conditions should go to jail.
- macinjosh 4y agoI don't like the guy but if the judge had to amend the bail conditions to exclude VPNs did he really break the bail conditions in the first place by using a VPN? It was a gray area that has been clarified by the judge. That's all really.
- anigbrowl 4y agoOh nonsense. This is just an attempt at hacking the legal system by playing definition games. It's like being told not to shoplift and argue that you never touched anyone else's goods because you wore gloves the whole time. His lawyers just responded to the allegation by trying to turn it into a basis for negotiation.
- tablespoon 4y agoIn other words: the thinks he's oh so clever and smart, but he's really just stupidly underestimating other people's intelligence and tolerance.
- LatteLazy 4y agoSo... His previous conditions banned him from using encrypted communication apps except Whatsapp which he could use only with monitoring software. To my techie brain, setting up a VPN seems like an obvious breach of that since a VPN will presumably encrypt anything that passes over it (all of which is reasonably communication even if it's just communicating with Uber to request a taxi). Maybe the judge didn't understand (or fully accept) that. Maybe there is some legalise question about how specific bail conditions have to be. Either way, specifically banning vpns solves that. But i don't think it's the courts job to play whack-a-mole while SBF plays the fool. I wouldn't expect that if I got very generous conditions then broke them twice...
- kurisufag 4y agoI am skeptical that the Judge (or whoever else was involved here) understands what precisely they're talking about. By my reading, HTTPS would also violate the order, and there isn't anything you can do with an explicit VPN protocol that you can't do with a day or two of infra setup using another technology. I am reminded of when weev set up services for himself so prison phone calls to a particular number would be automatically uploaded to soundcloud[0] and posted on twitter though prison e-mail[1]. IIRC tweets containing his name were also spooled, printed out, and mailed to him every week. [0] https://soundcloud.com/weevlos/weev-live-from-prison-2013-04 https://soundcloud.com/weevlos/weev-live-from-prison-2013-04 [1] https://www.fastcompany.com/3007961/convicted-hacker-troll-weev-livetweets-prison-sentence https://www.fastcompany.com/3007961/convicted-hacker-troll-w...
- fsckboy 4y agowhen a judge orders you to not hide your online activity, it literally means that and doesn't matter how easy or inadvertant it is. "but judge, if I..." okay, don't do that either. "but judge, i can't..." ok, don't do that either. >I am skeptical that the Judge understands what precisely they're talking about. the judge knows s/he's not an expert in every domain but the law and plain English. You are required to understand plain English, or have your counsel explain it to you. If you don't have counsel, judges are actually very patient in explaining, but not in forgiving repeat offenses. a better way to look at it is, what is the judge's goal, and how can you help him achieve that goal? otherwise, playing a game of cat and mouse risks angering the judge, and just like you can't help but hide your activity, he won't be able to help but deny your motions. I also am reminded of weev. weev went to jail. SBF is out on bail, with conditions. If he can't meet the conditions, the alternative is choosing jail.
- notch898a 4y agoThe plain English doesn't mean dick to a judge though. A Mexican here on a non-immigrant visa is most definitely a person but absent a few exceptions, you are going to jail if found with a gun. No matter that right is ascribed to "people" not "citizens." It's only through a lot of not-plain-english mumbo jumbo that you might discover the Mexican is not a person to the judge. Weev is definitely an interesting case. He was released after conviction for being tried apparently in the wrong jurisdiction. It appears his prosecution was incompetent, or stupid. He somehow ended up with a Transnistria passport and resides in Ukraine, afraid they will re-prosecute the case in the correct court next time. He still appears here occasionally under the name 'rabite'.
- smaudet 4y agoHonestly not using a VPN is a pretty lenient ban. He could have been banned from using computers, and forced to use a court appointed intermediary for everything...
- smaudet 4y agoFunny thing is it appears he was watching the superbowl, of all things: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/02/sam-bankman-fried-got-in-trouble-for-super-bowl-vpn.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/02/sam-bankman-fried-go...
- wwfredrogersdo 4y agoThose punishments are for the poor.
- ASalazarMX 4y agoFor those who don't follow crypto news, SBF is Sam Bankman-Fried , founder and CEO of FTX, the crypto exchange.
- giardini 4y agoA VPN is an "encrypted messaging application". The judge should have revoked SBF's bond and tossed him into the slammer. And b/c SBF broke the agreement, the bond should be collected in full.
- smaudet 4y agoThen he should be banned from using the web. Any interaction with an ssl website is an encrypted messaging application. You might not be able to say much, and your data is almost definitely not secure, but it is def encrypted, and sending messages, and usually an application (excluding I guess static websites on https, which I guess the resolver is still an application? But have to draw the line somewhere, windows explorer accessing a bitlocker drive could be deemed an "encrypted messaging application"...
- misnome 4y agohttps doesn’t completely hide the destination, only the contents. And if he was using https to connect to a site purely for the purposes of obfuscating activity, that would probably be squashed under the same rules. If he was using an encrypted remote drive to communicate with others that would also be a breach. You can’t “well, technically” your way out of obvious breaches of clear court instructions.
- jaequery 4y agoi don't think we were supposed to have let a guy like SBF loose like that on the internet :scratch head: