6 ms·
SBF Caught Using VPN While Awaiting Criminal Trial [pdf]
- notch898a 4y agoThe state is playing whack-a-mole on somebody who's allowed internet access. It's a losing proposition, he will always find another way to technically not break the rules.
- inasio 4y agoThere's also the possibility that the state doesn't really want to stop SBF from incriminating himself, he seems to have been doing a pretty good job so far.
- anonkogudhyfhhf 4y agoAnd his well connected family of high profile lawyers will get him out of any punishment https://mobile.twitter.com/unusual_whales/status/1625929943275417600 https://mobile.twitter.com/unusual_whales/status/16259299432...
- ceejayoz 4y agoWe'll see. "His well connected family of high profile lawyers will get him out of any indictment" was a common opinion here leading up to his indictment.
- hnthrowaway0315 4y agoI think this is too big. Look who signed on that bail. Best case they made some deals under the table and let SBF eat all of the shit. Worst case SBF hang himself or something similar.
- cmeacham98 4y agoThe problem is not that he's "breaking the rules" (technically or not), the problem is that the government is afraid SBF will use the VPN to cash out crypto he has through a no-KYC exchange and make a run for it. It's about bail - if you know somebody could easily obtain money without the government knowing (and is doing the thing that would enable them to do that), then they become much more of a flight risk (at least in the prosecution's eyes, and they hope the court agrees).
- notch898a 4y agoYou're talking about the reason for the rules. I'm saying as long as he has internet access they will be playing whack-a-mole to make rules that achieve the very goal you express. I don't see any reasons why both our statements cannot exist without opposing each other. As an aside, I would squabble that breaking the rules, or not, is a relevant problem.
- mywittyname 4y agoMaybe he shouldn't be out on bail if he's so huge of a risk.
- selectodude 4y agoI think most people would agree. Unfortunately the one person who matters is the judge and the 78 year old Lewis A. Kaplan does not seem to be swayed by that argument.
- radicaldreamer 4y agoObviously... bail was initially granted by a judge who's famous for being lenient to white collar criminals, until that judge stepped aside because her husband worked for a firm which did work for FTX...
- tombert 4y agoI think you're right, but I have to think that if this is something they're genuinely concerned about, then maybe he should, you know, not be given bail? IANAL, but isn't it pretty common for people who are flight risks to not be let out on bail?
- elif 4y agoNo, mostly they are concerned about him communicating with other defendants and/or victims and/or paid fall guys and pre-orchestrating his trial. He wouldn't get very far if he tried to outsmart interpol.
- mblevin 4y agoThis dude just cannot tell the truth even for a second. Obviously nobody needs a VPN to watch something on a national broadcast and he's clearly up to SOMETHING that he shouldn't be under the guise of accessing his NFL game pass account. This is continual sociopath behavior from someone who can't possibly believe that they could ever do anything wrong, and they are simply misunderstood. It's utterly maddening.
- elif 4y agoI might feel that entitled too if I just got to fly a stolen first class ticket to my stolen mansion when I was meant to be in jail. Then again maybe he actually is entitled and I'm the dumb one for thinking rules apply to rich people.
- eddsh1994 4y agoStolen mansion?
- elif 4y agoWhen you steal $10B and can only pay back $1B, you don't get to keep the $1B you had since 1992.
- pvarangot 4y agoHe bought a house for his parents with the money from his allegedly-very-fraudulent business and is now living there. I think part of his bail money is also from a mortgage on said house.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoKeep digging, Sam.
- pphysch 4y ago> Today, it came to the Government’s attention—based on data obtained through the use of a pen register on the defendant’s gmail account—that the defendant used a VPN or “Virtual Private Network” to access the internet on January 29, 2023, and February 12, 2023. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pen_register https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pen_register
- gzer0 4y agoI mean, I knew that there was mass surveillance occurring, but to this extent... perhaps I needed a refresher on just how much warrantless data is being collected on the citizens of the United States. The DEA has warrantless access to with no judicial oversight under "administrative subpoenas" originated by the DEA. The DEA pays AT&T to maintain employees throughout the country devoted to investigating call records through this database for the DEA. The database grows by 4 billion records per day, and presumably covers all traffic that crosses AT&T's network. Internal directives instructed participants never to reveal the project publicly. Information that is legally collectible according to 2014 pen trap laws includes: Phone * Dialed numbers * Received call numbers * The time the call was made * Whether the call was answered, or went to voice-mail * The length of each call * Content of SMS text messages * The real-time location of a cell phone to within a few meters Email * All email header information other than the subject line * The email addresses of the people to whom an email was sent * The email addresses of people whom received the email * The time each email is sent or received * The size of each email that is sent or received Internet * IP address, port, and protocol used * The IP address of other computers on the Internet that information was exchanged with * Time-stamp and size information of Internet access * Protocol traffic analysis to obtain URL web addresses surfed on the web, emails posted or read, instant messages exchanged, and information posted onto message boards The last one is particularly damning. Interesting that no warrant is needed for any of this. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/02/us/drug-agents-use-vast-phone-trove-eclipsing-nsas.html?hp&_r=0&pagewanted=all https://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/02/us/drug-agents-use-vast-p... [2] https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/09/02/us/hemisphere-project.html#p19 https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013... --- Crucially, they said, the phone data is stored by AT&T, and not by the government as in the N.S.A. program. It is queried for phone numbers of interest mainly using what are called “administrative subpoenas,” those issued not by a grand jury or a judge but by a federal agency, in this case the D.E.A. Administrative subpoena authorities allow executive branch agencies to issue a compulsory request for documents or testimony without prior approval from a grand jury, court, or other judicial entity. --- Planting AT&T employees and deeply embedding them within the government like that, utilizing "administrative subpoena's" that require no grand jury OR judge (just the DEA themselves) is, in my personal opinion, a breach of my 4th amendment right.
- rogers18445 4y agoThey apparently caught him because he logged into a wiretapped gmail with a VPN. It's not difficult to segment your network such that some software does not use a VPN tunnel. On Linux, it can even be made fool-proof with network namespaces. You can even render the default network namespace barren such that any accidentally launched software has no network of any kind.
- cmeacham98 4y agoI interpreted it differently - I'm assuming what "pen register" means in relation to GMail is that they get the metadata (i.e. who he is sending/receiving email from) and saw that he used his email to sign up for a VPN.
- Thorentis 4y agoIf true, is that actually a breach of bail conditions? How did they prove that he actually used the VPN rather than just, for the sake of argument, signing up to NordVPN to support his favourite YouTube creator?
- cmeacham98 4y agoIt is not a breach of bail conditions (at least not currently). The prosecution is arguing that VPN use makes SBF more of a flight risk, and is asking the court to make the bail conditions more strict because of it.
- panki27 4y agoUsing an anonymization software to access a service which directly identifies you... yeah, who would have guessed this is not a good idea.
- notch898a 4y ago"Your honor I shared my gmail password with someone else before the bail conditions were set."
- londons_explore 4y agoSo... let me get this straight... SBF is currently on bail... and the state and his lawyers are arguing about the exact bail terms that should apply... Shouldn't the terms of bail be set before bail is granted?
- londons_explore 4y agoAnd worse, they then asked the defence lawyers if it would be acceptable to add a 'no VPN' term... Those defence lawyers then presumably consulted their client before agreeing to it... So... SBF used a VPN, and was then asked "Heya, we're considering banning you from using VPN's because we can't track what you do on them, what do ya think??". And only later did a ban come into force... Giving plenty of time to use a VPN for whatever deeds he doesn't want the court to know about...
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> plenty of time to use a VPN for whatever deeds he doesn't want the court to know about This is why SBF’s counsel “represented that the defendant will not use a VPN in the interim.” Absent that representation, the government would have petitioned the court to revoke bail.
- louloulou 4y agoand then can just switch to tor next anyway
- everforward 4y agoMy understanding is that that's pretty normal, even for normal people. The prosecution asks the defense if they'll acquiesce to a particular term, and if the defense says no, the prosecution decides whether it's really worth it to push the issue. Defendants often agree to changes like this to score some brownie points with the judge and prosecutor that they can cash in later on when they want to change bail terms, or want to fight some other change in bail terms. It carries a bit more weight when the defense says "we think X is unreasonable" if they haven't said that every time the prosecution brings something up. > Giving plenty of time to use a VPN for whatever deeds he doesn't want the court to know about... That's pretty much going to happen regardless. If the prosecution doesn't ask the defense, then they'd go straight to filing a motion. A copy of that motion would have to be served to the defense, and the defense would be afforded adequate time to prepare arguments against it. Practically nothing happens instantaneously in the legal world, barring egregious acts.
- hesdeadjim 4y agoMaybe his strategy is to be such a fucking idiot that he can pretend there is no way he could mastermind such a big scam.
- mikestew 4y agoThat hypothesis comes up repeatedly, but I imagine it would hinge on whether or not judges would say to themselves, "he's too stupid to jail". IANAL, but I believe judgement is based on whether or not you did "it", whatever "it" might be. Then at sentencing a judge could use "stupid" as a mitigating factor. For example, "normally you'd get 20 years, but because you're stupid..." But I can not emphasize enough that IANAL, and this is just (as with most folks, I would guess) something I pulled out of my butt. Based on what little interaction I've had with the U. S. justice system, man, I sure wouldn't let the outcome rest on the judge's view of my intelligence, though.
- munk-a 4y agoI believe the above post was mostly in jest but just to clarify - to qualify for any sort of lighter sentencing you'd need to demonstrate a far more impactful intellectual disability. Idiots are everywhere in society - there are idiot billionaires, idiot crypto bros and idiots that you pass on the street everyday. Normal idiocy is not a defense - otherwise it probably would've been significantly easier for Elon Musk to back out of the acquisition of Twitter.
- cmeacham98 4y agoMy (albeit limited) understanding is that if SBF's lawyers can convince the jury that he was simply very incompetent that would be better (still a crime, but a less severe one) than if he intentionally defrauded customers. Similar to the difference between murder and manslaughter. I don't think he's actually trying to bolster his defense though, I think he's largely an idiot and used to getting away with almost anything with few/no consequences.
- 4y ago
- wombatpm 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dang 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34810681 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34810681 has a different document. Which is the more interesting/informative? and what should the title be? (I'm running out the door but will try to check this later)
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoLooks like [0] is the judge's order that SBF stop using VPN services until after Feb 24 and [1] seems to be some kind of appeal from SBF's counsel for a time extension "to make additional submissions to the Court" until Feb. 17 (apologies as I'm not familiar with what such a document would technically be called). I'd personally argue, considering the title, that the judge's order is more relevant since I figure it would probably not exist unless SBF actually used a VPN. [0] https://ia801508.us.archive.org/25/items/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940.68.0.pdf https://ia801508.us.archive.org/25/items/gov.uscourts.nysd.5... [1] https://ia801508.us.archive.org/25/items/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940.66.0.pdf https://ia801508.us.archive.org/25/items/gov.uscourts.nysd.5...
- sumeno 4y agoAt this point I'm convinced the only reason he's allowed out on bail is so that the prosecutors can run up the score on how many crimes he'll ultimately be charged with
- jdkee 4y agoHe needs to be locked up.
- yieldcrv 4y ago> Fifth, a VPN is a more secure and covert method of accessing the dark web. This is not accurate, unless they are considering Tor a VPN too? I guess using a VPN before accessing Tor could make it so your local router and ISP not know but its super insecure to give a VPN all your Tor traffic, and Tor Bridges also do that.
- dbuder 4y agoRevoke his bail! He has always been a major flight risk due to the possibility that he has squirreled away many millions via crypto. 250m of surety has not been provided and now due to the use of a VPN we cannot be assured he has not already made arrangements to flee and or tampered with witnesses.
- philippejara 4y agoI don't get what the issue is, do the bail terms prohibit one from using a VPN? if so it's a done deal but if it doesn't there's absolutely nothing wrong with him using it.
- breck 4y agoAgreed. Using a VPN is often the most ethical behavior (SciHub, for instance). It seems to me that using customer deposits that should have been safe guarded was wrong and a crime, but it's not clear that's what happened, and there's an obvious smear campaign against him just throwing mud against the wall to see what sticks. I'm still undecided on this one.
- 99112000 4y agoLet the man watch porn.
- breck 4y agoUsing a VPN is not a crime. Not only that, it's not unethical. In fact, to do many ethical things in this country, such as download scientific papers, one must often use a VPN.