3 ms·
> What is then the motivation for increased horror at animal cruelty? I'd imagine there are many, but one's probably the fact that we don't as regularly experi
by ceejayoz 4y ago
> What is then the motivation for increased horror at animal cruelty?
I'd imagine there are many, but one's probably the fact that we don't as regularly experience it as our ancestors did. We don't behead chickens for dinner, we don't fish the local streams to survive, we don't watch wolves kill baby lambs in our flock. Combine that with our capacity for empathy. Sentience isn't required; I feel bad when I throw away one of my houseplants.
> Can you actually make that claim clear and distinct without waving it away as self-evident?
I don't think anyone's got a perfect handle on what defines sentience. The debate will rage, and I've no doubt there'll be lots of cases in our future where the answer is "maybe?!" The edges of the problem will be hard to navigate.
That doesn't mean we can't say "x almost certainly isn't sentient". We do it with rocks, and houseplants. I'm very comfortable doing it with ChatGPT.
- californiadreem 4y agoIn short, you have no rational arguments, but ill-founded gut-feelings and an ignorance of many topics, including the history of jurisprudence concerning animal welfare. Yet, despite this now being demonstrable, you still feel confident enough to produce answers to prompts in which you have no actual expertise or knowledge of, confabulating dogmatic answers with implied explication. You're seemingly just as supposedly "non-sentient" as ChatGPT, but OpenAI at least programmed in a sense of socratic humility and disclaimers to its own answers.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe people with actual expertise largely seem quite comfortable saying ChatGPT isn't sentient. I'll defer to them. > the history of jurisprudence concerning animal welfare The fuck?
- californiadreem 4y agoI guess I'll talk to the people with "actual expertise" rather than their totally-sentient confabulating echo. Cheers.