5 ms·
The second an artist is trying to mass produce they are businessmen not artists anymore. The artist didn't make the ability to produce in large numbers and dis
by ThomPete 15y ago
The second an artist is trying to mass produce they are businessmen not artists anymore.
The artist didn't make the ability to produce in large numbers and distribute at zero cost, that is what technology did.
A technology that served the labels and musicians for one hundred years.
Now it is turning on them and they start to complain. Bo freaking ho.
People make music without making a single dime on it. Great music in fact fantastic music. The big artists are big because the record labels and IP laws make them big. Not because they through some fair game was the best of the crop.
- sequoia 15y agoAnd I suppose charging for a concert makes them a filthy businessman as well. Should I get to choose whether or not I must pay to see them play live?
- ThomPete 15y agoOf course not, that requires their physical presence and physical distribution. Very different.
- sequoia 15y agoTheir "physical distribution" by means of a complex technological infrastructure involving microphones, amplifiers, speakers, lighting, electricity etc. etc., which, as you point out, "the artist didn't make," but which the artist wishes to leverage in order to make a greater profit. The argument of "well you didn't invent TCP/IP so you can't expect to make money distributing digital copies of your music" is the slipperiest of slippery slopes, as none of us personally created all the technologies we use to make a living. I use a laptop, text editor, and web browser, none of which I created: have I forfeit my right to make a living as a web developer? It seems that the simplest, most generic expression of your argument (correct me if I'm wrong) is "No one can reasonably expect to make money on anything which can be reproduced digitally, and this is more or less fair." I disagree.
- ThomPete 15y agoYou keep confusing the two. If I take an microphone from you, you don't have an microphone. If I copy a song from you, you still have the song yourself. It might be that you don't see the difference but I do and therein is our disagreement.
- reinhardt 15y ago"If I take an microphone from you, you don't have an microphone." ..and so I have to buy a new one if we both want to have one at the same time. "If I copy a song from you, you still have the song yourself." Awesome, we can just buy one then and split the cost! But why stop there? Let's also give a copy to Tom, Dick and Harry so that each pays 20%! Now, what if we could somehow share the song and the cost with a hundred million people across the world..
- ThomPete 15y agoIf I buy a microphone I can borrow it and give it to whoever I want to. In fact I can chip in and share it with 200 friends if I want to. You see the difference?
- reinhardt 15y agoI do, do you? Microphone sharing (a) means only one person at a time can access it and (b) it is way more inconvenient. Microphone creators are not threatened by sharing, digital creators are.
- ThomPete 15y agoIf someone steals 20 microphones from the mic creator he has 20 microphones less. If someone downloads 20 songs from a song creator the creator of that song still has the song. That is the difference.
- peterhost 15y agoAnd say, with your wife and children ? Would you share it with them or make them pay too ? And when you listen to the music, streaming, with friends at a party you throw, do they all have to pay ?
- nkassis 15y agoAnd in most cases you pay for a unique concert, sure it's the same songs as the last show but musicians rarely play the music exactly the same way. The best concert include a lot more than just playing the songs. It's worth paying for. The best concert artist put on an act and improvise on stage. It's not easy and it takes talent and work.
- ThomPete 15y agoThe so called talent of many popular musicians is greatly overrated. It's not how things work.
- jiggy2011 15y agoThis is of course an opinion (one I generally share). Generally the more niche something is the less fans it will have but the more those fans will love it. A lot of pop music and modern moves + video games are designed specifically to appeal a bit to a large number of people. It's almost impossible to create something that appeals a lot to everyone. So the other option is to find a small niche following and concentrate on extracting the most amount of money from them. I imagine that without some form of copyright most of the music produced would either be stuff produced by musicians for other musicians or for the upper classes who would fund it's continued development. There would be a lot less "angry prole" music.
- gravitronic 15y agoPart of me hopes that your vision becomes reality and all financially backed art falls apart.. just so you, ThomPete, can live in a world that shitty and know that this is what you wanted. Enjoy your cat videos.
- ThomPete 15y agoDo you even know how much great great great music gets created without ever making a single dime.
- Czarnian 15y agoLeaving aside the rather obvious question of what makes you think your taste in music is superior to anyone else, how much MORE of that great, great, great music would get created if the artists didn't have to wash dishes for 10 hours a day to make rent and eat? Every hour you have to spend working a day job is an hour you can't spend creating.
- ThomPete 15y agoThis is getting silly. I am telling you that even with the music you like whatever that is there is plenty of great music that you never have heard of and never will. That's how it is in all genres of music.
- jiggy2011 15y agoLet's assume we are discussing modern music not Bach or something. There are of course good musicians who distribute their music monetarily free but how much of it is explicitly copyright free (i.e libre not gratis)? I know a number of aspiring musicians who if a large media company took their music and redistributed it under a different name with different people lip syncing to their vocals then boy would they be pissed.
- praptak 15y agoYeah, a totally shitty world with those crappy pre-copyright amateurs like Shakespeare and without the great art of Justin Bieber. The horror, the horror.
- troll24601 15y agoI assume that once you pitch designs to one of your clients, it's fine with you if they photograph it, copy it, and never pay you a dime? People love design, and do great design without making a single dime on it. The rich designers are rich because professional networking, big companies and IP laws make them big. Not because they were the best of the crop. Boo Freaking Hoo. Real designers do it for love. Only phonies want to get paid.
- ThomPete 15y agoFirst of all I have had plenty of my ideas, designs etc. copied. I don't care cause at the end of the day it doesn't matter. I don't know why you guys keep arguing the same misguided argument. Here is the difference. When I design for a client I put in the work and design specifically to to them. I am in other words a performing artist. I don't just send them a CD with the same design I did for all my other clients. Are you really telling me that you can't see the difference here? I am not saying artists shouldn't make money so there is no need to repeat the same tired claim. This is about whether it's a right to make money on mass-producing CDs?
- jiggy2011 15y agoPart of the reason you are paid so much as a designer who works "for hire" either employed or as a freelancer is that your client wants something unique. Let's assume that there is no copyright. You get a contract from a client to design them a logo , website and smartphone app to promote their business. However your client knows that if a competitor wishes to copy their entire website including logo and app etc they can do so with impunity so all that they will get from whatever sum they invest in your work is a slight first mover advantage and probably the better the work you do the more likely someone else is to copy it. How much do you think they are willing to pay you for your work now?
- ThomPete 15y agoA competitor can do that today. In fact that happens all the time, even among creatives. Do you know how many songs are stealing of each other? Should we tell musicians to pay for the licks and riffs they takes from someone else music and incorporate into his how?
- tatsuke95 15y agoI'm not sure why the down votes? Look, I'm as business-oriented as anyone here, but this is the truth. Art can be profitable for the artist, but whether it is or isn't, it's still happening. People will create sculptures to admire and music to dance to. The distribution stream was invented far, far later. Let's not conflate the creation of the art and the business of selling it.