2 ms·
> Do others have similar experiences with teachers or do I just have a bad selection My sixth grade science teacher called on me and asked “if the freezing poi
by rayiner 4y ago
> Do others have similar experiences with teachers or do I just have a bad selection
My sixth grade science teacher called on me and asked “if the freezing point of water is 0C and 32F, and the boiling point is 100C, what’s the boiling point in F?” I answered “212F” but she said “132F.” Then the class laughed at me which was very embarrassing.
Most teachers are very nice, very dedicated, but not intellectually gifted people. There’s lots of degrees and certifications, but it’s halfway between white collar work and blue collar work. Your HVAC technician might be better at math and science than your average elementary or middle school teacher.
I’m not opposed to working class people getting paid more money, I just don’t like how teachers are singled out as being especially underpaid because of empty credentialism. Why should having a piece of paper that frankly doesn’t signify much given the standards in the industry entitle teachers to higher pay than other people at the median?
- tptacek 4y agoYour HVAC technician might be better at math and science than your accountant, your estate lawyer, your real estate attorney, your corporate contract review attorney, and probably 2/3rds of everyone else that works in an office building. At least in major urban school districts, I don't generally think teachers are underpaid (every OPRF teacher makes 6 figures; the median CPS teacher makes something like 70k, and they all get defined benefit pension plans and large amounts of PTO). But calling them "not intellectually gifted" is mean spirited, reductive, and unhelpful.
- rayiner 4y ago> But calling them "not intellectually gifted" is mean spirited, reductive, and unhelpful. Only if you think there’s something wrong with being of average or modestly above average intelligence. I’m simply pointing out that—insofar as our society accords higher compensation to intellectually gifted people or intellectually demanding jobs—the credential inflation in teaching creates a false signal about the nature of the job and most of the people who work in it.
- tptacek 4y agoYou can't use math and science facility to establish that, because, like many high-status careers, math and science ability isn't the figure of merit for evaluating a practitioner. I'm sorry you had a bad experience in 6th grade, but in fact being an excellent 6th grade teacher isn't about how well you did in vector calc.
- rayiner 4y agoFigures of merit used to gate-keep high-status professions (SAT, LSAT, MCAT, etc.), correlate well with general intelligence. It's not that math/science reasoning ability is especially important in every job, but that it's especially revealing of general intelligence in a way that's hard to paper over with credentials. I agree being a teacher doesn't require someone to be smart. But why should we expect teachers, who are mostly quite average people, to make more money than the average person?
- tptacek 4y agoI don't agree that being a teacher doesn't require someone to be smart, just like I wouldn't agree that being weak in math means you're not smart. I probably know more smart people who are weak at math than people who are strong at math, and I work in part in a math-intensive subspecialty. Just a weird argument to make. Again: sorry you were humiliated by a 6th grade teacher. That's not OK.