3 ms·
It's just a comment on the title of the posting. The title assumes an intention that's possibly incorrect. If intention doesn't matter, then why is it in the ti
by robertlagrant 4y ago
It's just a comment on the title of the posting. The title assumes an intention that's possibly incorrect. If intention doesn't matter, then why is it in the title?
- horsawlarway 4y agoActions speak louder than words. The actions Apple has taken prohibit using self-written apps without paying Apple a relatively large yearly fee (and in many cases, also going through pointless store review). So at best - Apple does not care about hobby apps (written by owner, for owner) because they have taken no actions to mitigate this impact if it truly is just a side effect and not intended. At worst - Apple is actively hostile to this usage and the policy is working as intended. That distinction is mostly moot from the view of a user outside of the internal discussions at Apple regarding that policy. The impact of the policy clearly discourages hobby app usage. Because the policy exists, a reasonable interpretation is that Apple does not want you developing hobby apps.
- JohnFen 4y agoI'm not the author, so I don't know. But I would say the title is intended to be provocative and, in terms of what this looks like from the outside, isn't an unreasonable supposition. But, ultimately, it's not an important point either way.
- robertlagrant 4y agoI think intention is important, and in many ways more important than the end result, and it's worth highlighting potential mischaracterisation. If it's not important to you fair enough, but I don't understand the point of you both contributing to the discussion as well as saying the discussion isn't worth having.
- JohnFen 4y agoIntention is very important in many circumstances, yes! But in this sort of thing, where a user is being adversely affected, intention is of very little importance to that user. Regardless of the intent, the user is still adversely affected. > I don't understand the point of you both contributing to the discussion as well as saying the discussion isn't worth having. I didn't say the discussion isn't worth having. I think it is, because it's interesting.
- robertlagrant 4y agoThis isn't a comment on the magnitude of the effect, but on intention, though. The thesis is: Apple are not doing this to harm hobbyists. That may be a side effect, but it's not the main effect. For example: it's good to discuss the very real side-effects of drugs, but it would be silly to write an article called "Cancer Chemotherapy Drugs Exist To Induce Vomiting". I would equally push back on the misattribution of intention there.