6 ms·
Minimum compliance with this law is driving me nuts as a car owner. Tesla isn’t the only villian. The credit card payment systems are routinely broken — tap t
by hedora 4y ago
Minimum compliance with this law is driving me nuts as a car owner.
Tesla isn’t the only villian. The credit card payment systems are routinely broken — tap to pay, chip and swipe all fail in different ways (especially with EVgo)
This should be all or nothing — 99.9% uptime on compatibility with standard cars and payment methods, fleet wide, or you get zero dollars.
Unreliable is worse than unsupported, and the interoperability clauses of the law apparently don’t mandate reliability.
- snotrockets 4y agoSomething I just realized, is that Tesla chargers are broken 100% of the time for some people. Drivers with disabilities that prevent them from operating a gas pump by themselves can call an attendant at the station, but Tesla chargers has nobody on site.
- mlindner 4y agoTesla doesn't have this problem though so how are they the villain? Tesla created the first global charger network that now other companies are pleading for government help to compete with.
- hedora 4y agoThey are moving to a model where they get billions of dollars in government hand outs to support third party cars, but are not going to actually reliably allow third party cars to change. (Just like other networks are taking money to support standard payments, but don’t in practice.)
- mlindner 4y agoI'm not following. Who is moving to such a model? Yes Tesla should be paid if they're being forced to subsidize their competitors. The entire point of Tesla's charging system is that it's non-profit making. It's based on the idea that it's acts as a value-add to Tesla vehicles. If Tesla is going to allow access to competitors, then yes Tesla needs to be paid for that access, or charge differential rates between Tesla and non-Tesla vehicles.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- clouddrover 4y ago> Yes Tesla should be paid if they're being forced to subsidize their competitors The way Tesla gets paid is by users paying for the charge. It isn't complicated.
- mlindner 4y agoTesla prices are usually cheaper than any other EV charging station (or free). From my understanding they charge a little bit above local electricity rates enough to cover maintenance costs. Are you making the argument that non-Teslas should be charged more than Tesla users. I'm fine with that but I think that wouldn't be allowed under this new provision.
- clouddrover 4y agoI'm making the argument that all brands of EV charging network should charge all brands of EV. Anything less is backward, primitive, and simply dumb infrastructure. In Europe, Tesla charges Tesla drivers less for charging and other drivers more. Tesla also has membership pricing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Y33AArvMUQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Y33AArvMUQ Other charging networks also have brand specific deals and membership pricing.
- mlindner 4y ago> I'm making the argument that all brands of EV charging network should charge all brands of EV. Anything less is backward, primitive, and simply dumb infrastructure. Okay but this is a theoretical statement and doesn't really jive with the current existing environment. This is a goal, not a method to achieve it.
- clouddrover 4y agoThe method to achieve it is to put CCS on your car and charge on any charger. There is no mystery here. This is not theoretical. It's the practical reality: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4_WjeH3I8p8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4_WjeH3I8p8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPIhazPcY64 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPIhazPcY64 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gI5EnOo05BE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gI5EnOo05BE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=theiiFWydmo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=theiiFWydmo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0G30iqWzEe8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0G30iqWzEe8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BlUZfGMqv_g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BlUZfGMqv_g
- firmnoodle 4y agoI couldn't find that Tesla will receive "billions" anywhere. Only that the US Federal government is giving $5B to states and Tesla is applying for some of that money. Where do you see that Tesla won't reliably allow third party cars to charge?
- hedora 4y agoIt's in the title of the article. (The word "some")
- kwhitefoot 4y agoTesla chargers have been open to other cars in Norway since last year and I see many non-Teslas charging. They don't seem to have a problem doing it. You just need to install the Tesla app on your phone and register a credit card number with it.
- MagnumOpus 4y agoSnark: millions of petrol stations and vending machines manage to accept contactless or card payment without having to install the vendor’s app.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoTesla cars don't need the app. Only non-Teslas because the makers are so useless.
- vel0city 4y agoThere's an actually open (no patent pledge), non proprietary standard for signaling payment through charging infrastructure. Several non-Tesla manufacturers already sell cars with this standard, and there are a few non-Tesla charging networks which support it as well. Once again Tesla continues to push its proprietary systems instead of adopting the standards everyone else uses.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoSo which manufacturers and charging networks are they? All the owners of EVs that I know all bemoan the lack of any standardization. The only actual standard seems likely to be pushed through seems to be that in Germany (and I think Norway) all chargers will soon be required to accept card payments. Not sure how this will work with the low power AC chargers that already exist and that use NFC/RFID tags or a phone app, perhaps AC chargers will not have to follow that standard. And it will, presumably, require Tesla to retrofit some kind of user interface to the charging stall. That seems a bit stupid when every car that can connect has a screen that could easily do the job. And lastly, did this open system exist when Tesla started building their charging network?
- ericmay 4y agoBased on the OP I'm really not following this line of reasoning here. The billions of dollars that are available aren't only to Tesla. Tesla actually reliably accepts and processes credit card payments without issues, unlike the anecdotes provided by others here with other charging networks and there is no reason to think that Tesla would no longer reliably accept payments given that they intentionally accept payments from all major credit card processors. Why would they not allow 3rd-party cars to charge? They may have some prioritization scheme for Tesla vehicles, but other than that I'm just not following what you are saying here.
- vel0city 4y agoIf I were to go to a Tesla station in the US today with my non-Tesla car, it would not charge.
- natch 4y agoThat’s a choice you made. I do hope they open it up though because they will make a ton of money and use that to expand the network even more.
- ericmay 4y agoAnd why is that relevant to the conversation at hand?
- vel0city 4y ago> Why would they not allow 3rd-party cars to charge? Tesla isn't allowing my car to charge. They have a proprietary plug and a proprietary payment protocol. So if I drove my car to a Tesla stall in the US right now, it would not charge as it is not a Tesla. Why would they not, well, because for the past few years they've used their proprietary network as a marketing advantage.
- ericmay 4y agoSorry the conversation was referencing a future state not current state.
- cowmix 4y agoElectrify America's network is pretty bad, top to bottom. Payment processing is just the tip of the iceberg in how much it blows.
- hedora 4y agoYeah. My favorite part is that the payment processing state machine inevitably leads to the “not charging, locked in place” state, so I have to hang around for a few minutes until my car computer’s self defense logic kicks in, flips the bozo bit on the connector and releases the lock.
- bdcravens 4y agoI believe my Kia EV6 has an emergency release inside of the trunk area.
- oakwhiz 4y agoThis could have been avoided if the charging port had a manual disconnect switch next to it, rated to handle the arcing at full power. Auxiliary contacts can then release it and tell the computer that you manually killed the port. I dislike this "computer exclusively in the loop" design methodology.
- labcomputer 4y ago> rated to handle the arcing at full power. Sure… Except that that’s physically impossible. Search YouTube for “arc flash”.
- oakwhiz 4y ago500 amp breakers don't exist?
- martythemaniak 4y agoThere is no law that requires compliance here, only incentives. Tesla has chosen to respond to incentives.
- hedora 4y agoYes, and they should not be paid because they are half assing the compliance (as are many of the other charging networks).
- jackmott42 4y agoDon't let perfect be the enemy of good.
- frumper 4y agoWhat are they non-compliant about? It was announced today
- sliken 4y agoI've had a Tesla model 3, since 2019. Every time I used the car to get to a Tesla charger it worked, zero to a few times a month. Success rate at 3rd party chargers has been about 50%. Sure that's anecdotal, but I read a few (more than 1 each) reviews on the Harley Davidson Livewire, Ford Mach-E, and Ford f150 lightning. All had charging issues during their review. After owning a EV for years, my only range anxiety is caused by having to use non-Tesla chargers.
- hedora 4y agoI’ve had zero issues with charging my i3. The problem is getting it to accept payment via my amex/master card/visa. For example, the chip reader pins on the EVgo’s are corroded around here, so you need to wiggle the credit card in the reader and hope it manages to handshake with the embedded smart card. (If it is a Visa or Master Card.) If AMEX or Discover, they require you to swipe the mag strip, which would be useful if the mag strip reader didn’t spuriously decline payment. There is also an rfid reader labeled “present phone”, but it doesn’t work with apple pay, the EVgo app (android or ios) or the rfid tags in any of my credit cards.
- CrazyStat 4y agoIf you can't charge because the station won't accept payment, that's an issue charging. It sounds like you've had a lot of issues with charging your i3.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dagmx 4y agoI’ve definitely encountered some bad Tesla chargers. It used to be much worse before they added the data to the system about which stalls are encountering issues though. Now it’s much rarer to be directed to a broken charger.
- jackmott42 4y ago
- thrashh 4y agoI haven’t used an electric charger but it’s weird there’s payment issues There are established PoS vendors that have figured out payments completely. Did they roll their own?
- ehvatum 4y ago> Did they roll their own? For example, in the US, Francis Energy quickchargers require a Francis Energy RFID card or use of their app. Some gas station pump terminals will allow you to pump your debit card’s available balance and no more. No charger I have come across can do this, billing some arbitrary amount like $40 that is eventually replaced with the correct expense, if not outright requiring credit. Forget paying with cash, even for quick chargers located at gas stations.