13 ms·
Tesla to open some superchargers to other vehicles
- zzzeek 4y ago> Mr. Musk has criticized the new law, and said that federal funding for electric-vehicle charging is unnecessary. and yet this law is going to incentivize you to actually open up your chargers so that I can charge my Hyundai there. Works for me
- asynchronous 4y ago[flagged]
- Geeek 4y agoLol in what way is Hyundai a inferior manufacturer? Their EVs keep on getting top of the line rankings
- zzzeek 4y agowell you're going to see mine so I guess deal with it?
- bragr 4y agoHuh? Hyundai has the fastest charging vehicles on the market thanks to the much higher battery pack voltage. Tesla's battery is starting to look behind the times.
- NickM 4y agoHyundai is definitely doing well in terms of charging speed, but they're still a bit slower than Tesla (220 kW vs 250 kW). The marketing is confusing here, as Hyundai cars need a "350 kW charger" to achieve their max charging speed, and so they like to mention that 350 kW number, but they don't actually have the ability to draw anywhere near 350 kW of electricity.
- bragr 4y agoYou need to look at the charging curve vs the peak charging rate. Teslas quickly derate from their peak rate.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> Tesla offered wayyyy back to make their charging system the industry standard You neglected to mention the conditions. Tesla did not make any kind of serious offer, and as a result no manufacturers took them up on it, because it would have been a terrible business decision.
- dmitriid 4y ago> No, I don’t wanna see a Hyundai next to me at a supercharger station. Ma, look, a segregationist.
- NickM 4y agoNot to nitpick, but the law doesn't compel Tesla to open up their charging network. However, they need to open the network if they want access to the additional federal funding. Which, clearly they felt was a worthwhile trade.
- zzzeek 4y agocompel is the wrong word, i was trying not to use "force". guess "motivate" is all that's left
- revscat 4y agoPerhaps “incentivize” would be more accurate.
- zzzeek 4y agoooh that's it, why are online thesauruses so bad
- reaperducer 4y ago"My thesaurus is terrible. It's also terrible." — Siri's response when I asked her "Tell me a joke" last night.
- TOMDM 4y agoIt feels like all I talk about these days, but ChatGPT is the best thesaurus I've ever used.
- revscat 4y agoOne of Tesla‘s biggest market advantages is the quality and ubiquity of their charging network. There’s no other charging network that you can just drive up to, be 95% certain that it’s going to work, plug in, and start charging without having to download an app. Blink at least allows for contactless payments now, but their chargers are still all slow chargers, I believe. It’s no surprise that he is resistant. It needs to happen, though. Like you I’m glad and incentives are being provided.
- zzzeek 4y agoim fairly certain I'll have to download an app to use a tesla charger with my car. tesla cars already have "the app" inside them because the car / charger / billing is all integrated and owned by a single company. I'd rather not buy into a monolithic arrangement like that.
- revscat 4y agoWell, yes, but that’s going to be true regardless of the network. I meant after the initial download and account set up. I should’ve been more clear. Tesla is the only network I have used where I can just drive up, plug in, and start charging. I hope this is where everyone eventually goes.
- vel0city 4y agoI don't own a Tesla and have had many experiences of drive up, plug in, and start charging. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_15118 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_15118
- kjksf 4y agoWhat do you own and where are those magic EV chargers that don't require you to do SOMETHING other than plugging in, like swiping a credit card or some such?
- 4y ago
- mlindner 4y agoWell yes it makes sense to criticize the government effectively subsidizing your competitors when they failed to innovate. This reduces the willingness of companies to innovate like Tesla did because they know they can sit on the haunches and wait for the government to bail them out with tax payer's money.
- zzzeek 4y agoother car manufacturers aren't actually building charging stations. they rightfully see this as a separate endeavor. Tesla's hard-binding of their cars with their chargers is simply anticompetitive. I would like the government to help correct this.
- mwint 4y agoWho the heck was going to build chargers in 2011-2016 if not Tesla? They had to do it for their product to be usable. It’s not like they tried to corner the market, there just wasn’t a market at all.
- mlindner 4y agoThe CCS standard didn't exist when Tesla created their own charging connector, and there were many other connectors at the time. CCS is objectively worse than Tesla's standard in both form factor and ease of use. What the government is doing is anti-competitive, not Tesla.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoIf I've learned one thing in my life, it's that the friction caused by competing "standards" is always 1000% worse than any hypothetical pain you'll suffer from choosing the weaker one.
- mlindner 4y agoIn this case it's the government mandating the weaker one, through the lobbying of competitors trying to wreck the market leader. It's the _way_ that this happened that puts such a sour taste in my mouth personally.
- blitzar 4y ago> Mr. Musk has criticized the new law, and said that federal funding for electric-vehicle charging is unnecessary. He is free to repay all the government subsidies and funding he has received if they are unwanted.
- noslenwerdna 4y agoSuperchargers are convenient because Teslas are fast charging. When these slower charging cars get access, it'll be more convenient for the owners of other types of cars at the cost of Tesla owners waiting in long lines to charge.
- bink 4y agoTeslas aren't the fastest charging EVs anymore and haven't been for some time. Yes, there will be Leafs and Bolts and other slow charging cars, but there will be faster charging cars as well as long as Tesla's newer chargers support a faster standard.
- hedora 4y agoMinimum compliance with this law is driving me nuts as a car owner. Tesla isn’t the only villian. The credit card payment systems are routinely broken — tap to pay, chip and swipe all fail in different ways (especially with EVgo) This should be all or nothing — 99.9% uptime on compatibility with standard cars and payment methods, fleet wide, or you get zero dollars. Unreliable is worse than unsupported, and the interoperability clauses of the law apparently don’t mandate reliability.
- snotrockets 4y agoSomething I just realized, is that Tesla chargers are broken 100% of the time for some people. Drivers with disabilities that prevent them from operating a gas pump by themselves can call an attendant at the station, but Tesla chargers has nobody on site.
- mlindner 4y agoTesla doesn't have this problem though so how are they the villain? Tesla created the first global charger network that now other companies are pleading for government help to compete with.
- hedora 4y agoThey are moving to a model where they get billions of dollars in government hand outs to support third party cars, but are not going to actually reliably allow third party cars to change. (Just like other networks are taking money to support standard payments, but don’t in practice.)
- mlindner 4y agoI'm not following. Who is moving to such a model? Yes Tesla should be paid if they're being forced to subsidize their competitors. The entire point of Tesla's charging system is that it's non-profit making. It's based on the idea that it's acts as a value-add to Tesla vehicles. If Tesla is going to allow access to competitors, then yes Tesla needs to be paid for that access, or charge differential rates between Tesla and non-Tesla vehicles.
- bragr 4y ago[flagged]
- nxm 4y agoIt’s PR for the White House to all of the sudden transform the national charging network and make EV ownership easier.
- NickM 4y agoThe White House is doing PR for itself first and foremost here. Tesla did a good thing as a result of laws that have been recently passed that incentivize it, and the White House wants to make sure people know it.
- mlindner 4y agoThe current White House has been anti-Tesla since the beginning so I've got no clue what you're talking about.
- andsoitis 4y agoin what concrete way has the current WH been anti-Tesla? i’m aware of the WH not praising tesla while they praised ford (iirc), but, notwithstanding complaints by Elon’s mom that he isn’t appreciated, I’m not aware of any action against Tesla per se.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoStuff like this: https://electrek.co/2021/08/06/tesla-wasnt-invited-biden-ev-announcement-unions/ https://electrek.co/2021/08/06/tesla-wasnt-invited-biden-ev-... As well as claiming that GM/Mary Barra "electrified the nation".
- andsoitis 4y agoI mean, Tesla is already 100% electric so the emphasis is on incentivizing / forcing the other automakers to accelerate electrification. When we think about it, they sell way more cars than Tesla, so from a practical point of view you want to move them. Besides forcing (laws, emmissions standards) you can also praise them foe their work in order to get them more on the electrification agenda. Praising Tesla wouldn’t increase electrification, so doesn’t seem worth doing unless it would stoke sufficient envy to encourage other automakers. Sour grapes about not being praised seems more an ego thing.
- outlace 4y agoSeems like many superchargers are already overcrowded with Teslas alone in my experience, so this will reduce the appeal of Teslas. The biggest advantage Tesla has and the main reason I chose it is due to its dedicated charging infrastructure which is way better than other systems.
- poxrud 4y agoAgreed. I would love to switch to another electric car but the lack of a public country wide charging network (in Canada) leaves me with no alternatives.
- noodle 4y agoI agree with this point, though at least in theory this is a path for them to get more $ and therefore expand the network further/faster, also potentially increasing the size of the moat. We'll see if they actually do that, though, I guess.
- rtkwe 4y agoYou still get the way better integration between chargers and car. One of the big benefits I've seen on in the "we took a road trip in these N different electric cars" genre of videos is that Tesla's navigation knows how many cars are there and the status of the chargers where other cars can get nearly stranded if you try to stretch to reach a charging point only to find it's broken with no indication it wouldn't work before you get there.
- vel0city 4y agoIts OK, originally Tesla said they were going to open their chargers up by the end of 2022, then end of 2023, and now its end of 2024. It'll be a long time before any CCS cars are charging at Superchargers at this rate.
- cowmix 4y agoAs a Model Y owner I just rented a Polestar to do a 72 hrs, 800 mile trip -- just to evaluate the experience. I missed my Y for many reasons however the trip went well overall but the Electrify America charging infrastructure leaves much to be desired. HOWEVER, their rate pre kwh can be 30% cheaper at peak times so I just bought the CCS adapter so I can optionally use those chargers -- even when cross country driving in my Tesla.
- robterrell 4y agoWhat company rents Polestars?
- t3rabytes 4y agoHertz
- haliskerbas 4y agoHow many times did you stop to charge? I avoided renting an EV because I didn't want a 30m+ stop during an otherwise uninterrupted road trip.
- sliken 4y agoMy longest trip in my Tesla was just west of Sacramento to just past Denver, 1150 miles. The car charges at between 600 and 1000 miles per hour when it's nearly empty. Our stops were in the 15 minute range, often as the last person returned after a snack or bathroom break we had enough to drive enough 50-75% of range (180 to 270 miles). Not bad for driving since the stops were every 3 to 4.5 hours. Charging often is most time efficient to charge fairly often since charging is much faster when the battery is in the bottom 50% than the top 50%. Keep in mind charging is much nicer than filling. No pulling out a credit card, no typing in your zip code, no skipping the car wash, no selecting a fuel type, no "delays" while watching a loud ad, no trying to find the mute button, no getting sprayed with stinky gas tinged air (not all states reclaim the vapor), no hitting a mute button again because it timed out, etc. Just grab charger, hit button to open the charge port, and plug in.
- wlesieutre 4y agoThe final NEVI charger rules are available here: https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/nevi/resources/ev_charging_min_std_rule_fr.pdf https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/nevi/resources/ev_charg... Among other things, it requires 97% uptime, CCS connectors, 150 kW minimum for every plug (power sharing allowed for capacity above that), payment via contactless credit/debit payment and either toll free phone number or SMS short code, must have a customer service system to report charger outages.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoDoes this mean that non-Tesla drivers won't have to install the Tesla app to use the new Tesla chargers? If so, this is even bigger news.
- mlindner 4y agoThere's nothing that says you won't also need a phone app just that you can't mandate payment through the phone app. It just says that there's no membership requirement and downloading an app is not a membership. BTW, Tesla has already created the technology they'll use for charging. It's called "Magic Dock" which is believed to a system where through the phone app you either unlock a connector that has CCS on the end of it, or you unlock the inner Tesla connector. By default it's the Tesla connector and you use the Tesla app to tell it that a non-Tesla car has arrived. Here's some industry speculation: https://www.autoevolution.com/news/here-s-how-tesla-s-magic-dock-intelligent-ccs-adapter-might-work-in-real-world-210270.html https://www.autoevolution.com/news/here-s-how-tesla-s-magic-...
- mlindner 4y agoI believe the CCS connector rule will eventually be changed. The momentum Tesla has with their own connector is simply too great. Keep in mind for European posters: this is not the European CCS. It's CCS type 1, which is quite a lot worse than CCS type 2 in Europe.
- hedora 4y agoTesla’s market share is plummeting. They were at > 75% a year or so ago. Market consensus has them at 11% by end of 2024. Also, dongles to plug Teslas into CCS exist, and come with new Teslas, so there is no reason to build any more Tesla-only charging station wires.
- shever73 4y agohttps://archive.ph/Htc1m https://archive.ph/Htc1m This is already happening in the UK and Europe. Using the Tesla app, you can see which superchargers are now public.
- steveBK123 4y agoWill be interesting to see how this rolls out. Former Tesla, current CCS charging EV owner myself. Most assume it will basically be accomplished by exclusively building out new locations with the new "magic dock" CCS adapter. Even this is fine with me given that Tesla not only has far more stations than CCS competition in US, but they are also building out new stations more rapidly too.. so the lead only grows. Also note that every Tesla location is 8+ stalls, often up to 16 stalls, and I'd say the average location is now 12 stalls.. and they all work 99.9% of the time. EA/evGo/etc CCS networks tend to install pathetic 4 stall stations that have perpetually 1 or more stalls out of service. 3500 chargers / 12 charger average location = under 300 locations, vs total existing ~1700 current locations. For those complaining about Tesla gaming this or something, I'd point more of a finger at the CCS networks who are installing the minimally compliant (4 stall) locations at an alarmingly slow rate. They are leaving money on the table, and giving customers a bad experience. Happy to see Tesla come in and give them a run for the money.
- vel0city 4y ago> given that Tesla not only has far more stations than CCS competition in US Given you've said "stations" separately from "stalls", this is not true. https://afdc.energy.gov/fuels/electricity_locations.html#/find/nearest?fuel=ELEC&ev_levels=dc_fast&ev_connectors=J1772COMBO https://afdc.energy.gov/fuels/electricity_locations.html#/fi... 6,134 results for DC Fast CCS chargers, 1,841 results for DC Fast Tesla. There are more Tesla stalls, but there are fewer locations.
- steveBK123 4y agoOK I probably am putting on blinders and mixing some words up.. But the problem with CCS is a lot of these stats count BS unnetworked, poorly maintained, single-stalls 50kW stations sitting in car dealer parking lots only usable 9a-5p, and stuff like that. Checking the ones on the map near me, and it includes a bunch of CCS stations I've never seen actually working, stuff in government parking lots not available to public, and lots and lots of dealer special chargers which are of limited access.. If you were able to filter on "150kW+ L3 charging" the 6k number would probably drop to 2-3k maybe best case. Which would result in something like 2.5k stations x 4 stalls => 10k CCS stalls, vs 1.8k Tesla stations x 12 stalls = 22k stalls.
- nkotov 4y agoI wish more chargers would follow similar model to charging to how Superchargers work - high amperage, plug-and-go. I used a non-Tesla charger for my Model Y yesterday at a parking garage. Let me tell you the experience: 1. Came up, no directions on what app I should use to pay for charging, a couple feet away found that I should download PlugShare. Downloaded PlugShare, setup my info, allows for Apple Pay, nice. Says it needs to do a $30 pre-auth in order to get started. Fine. 2. Plugged my car in, I barely get 30A from the plug, whatever. Leave it plugged in for 4 hours. Come back, unplug. No way to stop the charging or my session in the app. I just leave it there thinking perhaps it'll reset session. A couple minutes later, someone else starts using my session... 3. 9 hours later, I get a notification that charging has finally stopped and I was charged for the amount. :(
- slenk 4y agoI don't think most electrical grids can spare that much high amperage all the time. You know they aren't getting priority on the grid.
- nkotov 4y agoIf we can't spare that much amperage, why force everyone into EVs?
- slenk 4y agoPersonally I don't think we should. Sorry if I implied that. As long as coal is powering the electricity in the cars, what exactly is helping the environment?
- vel0city 4y agoAbout 30% of the energy that goes to power my car comes from renewable sources such as wind and solar. Another 10% comes from nuclear. A little over 40% comes from mostly combined cycle natural gas plants. Slightly less than 20% comes from coal. On top of that, because of the efficiency of my car and the plants running, I get the equivalent energy usage of about 100MPG for an ICE. The break even emissions on my car including manufacturing given this kind of mix is within a few years. If I drive the car for 5+ years (most likely), it'll be way lower emissions than my ICE driving for 5+ years. Meanwhile in the next 5+ years, chances are the mix of renewables will increase. Maybe even nuclear. Chances are the coal plants will close soon though.
- ec109685 4y agoFeels unfortunate the less popular and larger CCS standard is the one mandated: https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/11/23453587/tesla-connector-north-american-standard-ccs-combo https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/11/23453587/tesla-connector...
- sschueller 4y agoThey should have mandated CCS2 like Europe.
- ec109685 4y agoWhat advantages over the Tesla plug does CCS2 present?
- sschueller 4y agoCCS2 Supports 3 phase AC as well as built-in automatic locking which the CCS1 does not. https://i.imgur.com/6iC38UK.png https://i.imgur.com/6iC38UK.png
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.ph/Htc1m https://archive.ph/Htc1m
- jedberg 4y agoThis isn't the first time they are doing it. It's already happening in test markets in Europe, and in fact there are three Tesla chargers available today in the Bay Area for non-tesla cars. But they are all in private parking lots. I can't wait till the open up, because right now when we go to our local target, there are four non-tesla chargers, always full (sometimes with Teslas!) and 20-30 Tesla chargers that are mostly empty.
- maherbeg 4y agoI've been a model 3 owner for 4+ years and have cross country road tripped multiple times. The charging infrastructure for Tesla is just consistently reliable and continually getting better. Sometimes we ran into a charger stall not working, but most stations had lots of stalls that we could retry at a different one. The consistency of non-Tesla chargers is pretty poor and really puts a damper in the potential growth of the EV market. We went through an annoying charging fiasco at a chargepoint station that I'm not sure how non-technical people would get past. Additionally, the next day the EA station we needed to goto ended up being completely down!
- maherbeg 4y agoAlso, the Tesla connector is just so much better than the CCS connectors in North America. It feels so seamless to get it connected to the car and feel like you have a solid connection.
- panick21_ 4y agoTesla made a big mistake by not making its charger open standard and open source. They could potentially have set the standard, that would have been good for everybody.
- nicd 4y agoAs a consumer, the Tesla charging network is a significant selling point over other electric vehicles. It's unclear to me that standardizing the charger would benefit their business position (although I agree it would benefit society!).
- panick21_ 4y agoJust because you have the same charger, doesn't mean that you allow other vehicles to charge at Tesla Superchargers. Those are 2 different questions.
- kwhitefoot 4y ago
- kwhitefoot 4y agoQuite a few Tesla charging stations have been open to other brands since last year here in Norway and several other countries in Europe. The Wall Street Journal seems to be unaware that other countries exist.
- TrainedMonkey 4y ago> but in the U.S. they aren’t available to other types of vehicles. They have a short note in the article, but I agree a better callout that this is about U.S. chargers would enhance clarity.
- christkv 4y agoThe charging infrastructure they are building will become a big earner in the long run I think. It’s building and owning the gas stations.
- thexumaker 4y agothank god, the charging network outside of tesla's supercharger network is terrible. But last time I went on a roadtrip on a popular route up and down i-5 there weren't enough chargers. I can't imagine these supercharger networks getting any better unless they build 100 mile lots for charging
- kposehn 4y agoSpeaking as a non-tesla EV owner I've not been that unhappy with Electrify America. After several road trips and >16,000mi I've only had a few negative experiences. That said, I'm an outlier - plenty of others have had many issues and it needs fixing. Tesla opening Superchargers is a good step, but EA and other networks need some serious pressure to improve, now.
- kube-system 4y agoImagine if Ford has their own gas pumps with a different shaped connector and you could only fill Fords at their gas stations. I applaud Tesla for building the network to support their cars, but just like gas stations are critical transportation infrastructure, so are vehicle chargers. They shouldn't be legal to be used as anticompetitive leverage.
- snotrockets 4y agoEuropean regulators forced Tesla to play nice. US regulators were asleep at the wheel.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoI think Tesla shipped before regulators started waking up (to use your analogy)
- arlcode 4y agoInitially Tesla used different connectors in Germany as well. Early Model S were not CCS if I recall correctly.
- brianwawok 4y agoImagine if Ford paid billions of dollars to build their gas pump network. Why should Toyota get to use it?
- mrguyorama 4y agoBecause there are finite resources on earth and we should strive for efficient uses of them, not for maximum Ford profit. Corporations only exist at society's pleasure, thanks the the support of society's government and the property law that government applies using it's monopoly on violence. There is no right to profit.
- arsome 4y ago
- JoshTko 4y agoIt’s a trap