10 ms·
Sea life bounced back fast after the ‘mother of mass extinctions’
- timst4 4y agoCool. They’ll bounce back fast after this mass extinction that’s happening right now. That is, unless humans succeed in terraforming Earth into a Mars clone. Then all life is screwed.
- willio58 4y agoTo preface what I'm about to say, I'm anti-mass extinction and I definitely agree that as a planetary society we need to continue pushing to slow down and eventually reverse climate change. But I really think the "all life is screwed" mantra is damaging to us, especially our youth. There needs to be a balanced take on this, because saying that all life is screwed gives no hope or even purpose to the kids growing up now who will inevitably need to fix what we're leaving them. I'm mid-20's and I grew up with some level of media telling me that the world was ending, but it was pretty muted and didn't make me feel like there was no way we could fix things. I'm not saying people won't die or people won't have to massively change how they live to adapt to climate change in the future, but we need to stop basically saying that every single human dying is an inevitability with climate change. As a thought experiment: Let's say in ~50 years 10% of humans die in a 5 year span due to catastrophic climate change (~800 million based on current pop.). What is the incentive at that point for governments to NOT force radical regulation legislation to go through? Money? In the past few years we've gotten to the point where renewable energy is simply cheaper than the alternative. Now imagine we have better batteries years down the line. Exactly who is profiting at that point? The oil companies? They can just invest in renewables and save the money they'd lose fighting uprisings from the people in their countries who have lost, in this thought experiment, 800 million fellow humans. All this to say, climate change is a BIG DEAL. But let's stop wallowing in that fact, and let's focus all that energy in pushing for governments to force companies to do the right thing.
- amilios 4y agoI think the issue is feedback loops. You're right that eventually governments will be "forced" to do the "right thing", but the problem is that it is likely going to be too little too late, and the climate feedback loops already set in motion may indeed "finish the job" and make the planet too inhospitable for any humans to feasibly live on.
- kulahan 4y agoI don't think I've seen many (any?) studies which predict that we're going to scorch the Earth into an unlivable hellhole. That's what people are complaining about. There will be mass starvations, mass migrations, mass extinctions, and more, but that doesn't mean life will cease for humans. We will see worse storms, and a generally less livable planet, but if we can have both Eskimos and Bedouin thriving on the same planet, it's weird to think we'd suddenly lose our extreme adaptability.
- amilios 4y agoOK sure life won't cease as a whole for humans, but living standards for the vast majority of us will enter freefall and stabilize at a MUCH much lower level than we're used to.
- djtango 4y ago2000 years ago leaving the Middle East/Europe to go to America would have been as insurmountable as moving to the Moon today. Humanity has gone through cycles of famine, war, exploration in the past. Feels like this could be the 21st Century parallel maybe... Probably would also help to have a single figure who can unite us to share more and all take personal responsibility for the collective good.
- willio58 4y ago> Probably would also help to have a single figure who can unite us to share more and all take personal responsibility for the collective good. Part of me feels like climate change is this single figure. Instead of a single person rising up and saying "We need change and this is how we do it", it's the planet that we all share that's forcing our hand. I think that's great in a certain respect, it's reality smacking us and screaming into our faces. Of course it will mean a lot of death, but sometimes it seems we need to experience loss to stimulate progress.
- RegularOpossum 4y agoOceans as an ecosystem are fascinating. This is simplified but on land the food chain is usually something like Plant-Herbivore-Predator but in the ocean the food chain is much longer, algae-Zooplankton--Predator-Predator-Predator-Predator-Predator-Predator-Predator. There's so much opportunities in the predator niche in the oceans that land animals keep going back to the ocean, because the evolutionary challenges were regularly worth it. This truly is a blue planet.
- HPsquared 4y agoI suppose in economic terms there is a lot of "liquidity" (pardon the pun). Species can move around very freely and find their ideal niche.
- deepsun 4y agoI can argue the other way. When I dived in different oceans, I was surprised to see the same fish (most popular ones). It's hard to imagine the same on land. Finding a niche is much easier on land, especially in mountains.
- cwkoss 4y agoOceans are like very deep markets - lots of participants but harder to outcompete the others. SPY is like the pacific - interacting with many other markets, constant yet chaotic. Mountains are like smaller caps - there is a lot more alpha, higher volatility but opportunity size is only a fraction. Would be cool to make a procedural rendering of the financial markets as a landscape/globe map. "Got a cold front blowing across the tech sector today"
- mrtweetyhack 4y agothat's hardly a fair comparison. land is separated by waters that cannot be traversed. Oceans are not separated by land so seeing a particular fish in different oceans does not seem too odd.
- 4y ago
- dpflan 4y agoIn 1 million years.
- bell-cot 4y agoAt least with palaeontologists, you can ~always adjust the adjectives in one direction. Vs. with astronomers, physicists, and such...a phrase like "extremely bright" could mean "the comet will be visible with binoculars, if you know exactly where to look". Or, it could mean "if there were any Earth-like planets in that galaxy...well, there aren't now".
- hw-guy 4y agoIs that all? That makes me feel a lot better about the next climate-related mass extinction.
- wwwpatdelcom 4y agoWhew...relax guys, with the current ocean acidification going on[1], we will only have to wait about a million years for recovery, not ten million like you were probably thinking. [1] https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/ocean-acidification https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-co...
- xwdv 4y agoWhen you’re dead a million years pass by very quickly.
- wwwpatdelcom 4y agoI know that before I was born, the million years previous went by like nothing from my perspective.
- hardlianotion 4y agoBold claim
- FireBeyond 4y ago
- bannedbybros 4y ago[dead]
- GalenErso 4y agoSea life may bounce back, but gigantic aquatic fauna seems to be on a permanent decline. Megalodon, mosasaurus, liopleurodon, and dunkleosteus are extinct and... nothing like them is evolving again? All the above animals evolved after the Tr-J mass extinction event. So why are we not seeing similarly large animals evolve today? Blue whales and Carcharodon Carcharias are cool, for sure, but they're just not the same.
- 988747 4y agoI wonder if the fact that we have much lower oxygen content now than 100-50 millions years ago might be a factor here. Also, the fact that despite "climate change" we are living in one of the coolest periods in Earth's history: https://www.climate.gov/media/11332 https://www.climate.gov/media/11332
- mistrial9 4y agothis is "cold comfort" .. plenty of long geological eras were highly poisonous or unstable. It is annoying-or-worse to see a one-liner that implies that rapid increase in overall temperatures is OK or even "normal"
- sgtnoodle 4y agoI suspect it has to do with a decline in atmospheric pressure. The pressure is lower now, and it makes the physics of large living creatures more difficult.
- TSiege 4y agoThe blue whale is the largest known animal to have ever existed on this planet not just today. We had plenty of very large (larger than extant) land animals until the holocene extinctions began. The Paraceratherium (a extinct animal like a rhino) was head to toe 24feet! (7.4m). (perhaps higher oxygen levels as others might have pointed out played a role too in sheer size.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paraceratherium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paraceratherium
- mistrial9 4y agoalso not all water is healthy water https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anoxic_waters https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anoxic_waters https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioaccumulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioaccumulation rediscovering ancient sea states, this Blue Planet went through extreme anti-fertile stages. "recovery" necessarily includes devolving to those states as a possible outcome
- photochemsyn 4y agoNice image of a fish fossil from this discovery here: https://www.sci.news/paleontology/guiyang-biota-11644.html https://www.sci.news/paleontology/guiyang-biota-11644.html Also see the related (linked) discussion of the cause of the Permian extinction: > "The team’s findings showed that volcanic eruptions in Siberian Traps released immense amounts of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. This release lasted several millennia and led to a strong greenhouse effect on the late Permian world, causing extreme warming and acidification of the ocean." > "Dramatic changes in chemical weathering on land altered productivity and nutrient cycling in the ocean, and ultimately led to vast de-oxygenation of the ocean. The resulting multiple environmental stressors combined to wipe out a wide variety of animal and plant groups." It's worth noting that current fossil fuel emission rates of CO2 to the atmosphere are as much as 14X the rates during the Permian extinction, although humans have only really been at it for 150 years or so, compared to thousands of years during the Permian era.
- toss1 4y ago>> current fossil fuel emission rates of CO2 to the atmosphere are as much as 14X the rates during the Permian extinction, although humans have only really been at it for 150 years or so, compared to thousands of years during the Permian era. And a rate of 14x times 150 years yields the equivalent of 2100 years of Siberian Traps pollution. Current knowledge is that this activity preceded the Permian extinction for 250K years [0]. That might seem like "Oh, we're only around 1% there". But, critically, the authors of the paper point out: “We don’t know if a little erupted for 250,000 years, and right before the extinction, boom, a vast amount did, or if it was more slow and steady, where the atmosphere reaches a tipping point, and across that point you have mass extinction, but before that you just have critically stressed biospheres,” We are creating serious danger here with this massive uncontrolled experiment on the climate. Once the food web breaks, we're fooked, with no way to recover in time. [0] https://news.mit.edu/2015/siberian-traps-end-permian-extinction-0916 https://news.mit.edu/2015/siberian-traps-end-permian-extinct...
- soperj 4y ago> And a rate of 14x times 150 years yields There's a vast difference between what we were releasing 150 years ago, or even 50 years ago compared to now.
- jbottoms 4y agoIs there a chart or charts for the time vs evolution velocities?
- lkrubner 4y agoIn his book Metazoa, Peter Godfrey-Smith mentions that life in the ocean was more diverse than life on land, until a 130 million years ago, when diversity on land became exceptional, mostly driven by a feedback loop between insects and plants, as plant diversity allowed insect specialization and insect diversity allowed plant specialization. (Until finally we arrived at a situation where every species of fig tree had a specialized species of wasp responsible for pollinating that species of fig tree.) https://www.amazon.com/Metazoa-Animal-Life-Birth-Mind-ebook/dp/B084M1MGGM/ https://www.amazon.com/Metazoa-Animal-Life-Birth-Mind-ebook/...
- idatum 4y agoFor those that took 'mother of mass extinctions' as click-bait, it refers to 'Permian–Triassic mass extinction'. It's amazing how resilient life is once it takes hold.
- olliej 4y ago"Bounced back": the only actual relevant time frame I can find in the article is a one million year gap, so an order of magnitude longer the recorded human history. A recovery of the carbon cycle I think I read somewhere in the past alone is 10 or 20 thousand years.