4 ms·
I draw a somewhat different conclusion from all this. Folks who go to Harvard Law are mostly the children of elites (major or minor) who are destined to pull th
by rayiner 4y ago
I draw a somewhat different conclusion from all this. Folks who go to Harvard Law are mostly the children of elites (major or minor) who are destined to pull the oars of the ship that is corporate America. That’s Harvard Law’s social and economic function, just as it was in 1950 or for that matter 1850.
However these kids are socialized in at least superficially left wing undergraduate environments. So the kids destined to work for a big law firm defending tobacco corporations for trying to get kids hooked on cigarettes can’t embrace their role and function in society. That’s how you get, as the article observes, 50% of first year students saying they want to work in public interest law.
But of course by 3L the reality sets in. There are few jobs in public interest law and none pay off the debt of a Harvard Law education. Meanwhile corporate America can always use bodies. So you end up with only 2% actually going into public interest law. But law students are smart kids, they knew what they were signing up to do.
The operation of this cognitive dissonance is very interesting to me as a foreigner. As far as I can tell, most Americans are loathe to believe in social and economic roles. “I’m not a cog in a machine with a specific function and purpose, I’m an individual with agency who can change the world.” What does that belief system do to someone who literally functions as a cog in the machine? (Don’t feel bad for them, they make a lot of money doing it.)
- MichaelZuo 4y ago> “I’m not a cog in a machine with a specific function and purpose, I’m an individual with agency who can change the world.” By that standard the vast vast majority of people are 'cogs' since very few people have any observable effect on the direction of mankind.
- strikelaserclaw 4y agoit's just a numbers game, for every 1000 kids that grow up with the "change the world", "do good" mantra, one might actually have the conviction and talent required to do it. As opposed to in other parts of the world, where idealism is mocked, all 1000 kids will pretty much become cogs in the machine. I know what kind of society i'd like to live in.