3 ms·
Annotated review of WHO draft agreements [1][2] to expand their powers over all countries globally. Note that the IHR amendments that will be voted upon in May
by walterbell 4y ago
Annotated review of WHO draft agreements [1][2] to expand their powers over all countries globally. Note that the IHR amendments that will be voted upon in May 2023 only require the consent of 50% of countries to take effect, https://brownstone.org/articles/amendments-who-ihr-annotated-guide/ https://brownstone.org/articles/amendments-who-ihr-annotated...
> The WHO proposes that the term ‘with full respect for the dignity, human rights and fundamental freedoms of persons’ be deleted from the text, replacing them with ‘equity, coherence, inclusivity,’ ... The underlying equality of individuals is removed, and rights become subject to a status determined by others based on a set of criteria that they define. This entirely upends the prior understanding of the relationship of all individuals with authority, at least in non-totalitarian states. It is a totalitarian approach to society, within which individuals may act only on the sufferance of others who wield power outside of legal sanction; specifically a feudal relationship, or one of monarch-subject without an intervening constitution.
[1] 2023 draft of 2023 IHR amendments, https://apps.who.int/gb/wgihr/index.html https://apps.who.int/gb/wgihr/index.html
[2] 2023 draft of 2025 treaty, https://docs.reclaimthenet.org/who-zero-draft-international-pandemic-treaty-february-2023.pdf https://docs.reclaimthenet.org/who-zero-draft-international-...
The best references are the primary WHO source documents. A better source of analysis than Brownstone is needed. An older (May 2022) analysis was published by an EU law journal, https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-far-reaching-us-proposals-to-amend-the-international-health-regulations-at-the-upcoming-75th-world-health-assembly-a-call-for-attention/ https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-far-reaching-us-proposals-to-am...
> ..amendments to Article 12 IHR will both considerably extend the executive powers of the WHO Director-General to declare global emergency-like situations and centralise this power further by removing the need to consult and find agreement with the respective state party ... if WHO’s powers are extended in this way, is there a need to also answer the question quis custodiet ipsos custodes (who guards the guards?), and to thus set up mechanisms ensuring that WHO complies with its obligations under the IHR and its Constitution, as well as its responsibilities for human rights deriving from customary international human rights law?
HN ranking for this story, https://hnrankings.info/34795036/ https://hnrankings.info/34795036/
- ethbr0 4y agoThere is no effective pandemic response that respects individual rights, as we currently expect them. Too many people, too interconnected of a world. Better to go ahead and admit that if the shit hits the fan (SARS-CoV-2 being far from how bad a novel pathogen could get) then world organizations will need to be pretty totalitarian to effectively manage public health. If this concerns us, we should meet reality and focus on criteria and processes by which those powers will be guaranteed to be rolled back when the situation allows. The alternative to having such agreements in place is an procession of ineffectual response, fear, death, ceding power to authorities from fear, and then having no structures in place by which that power can be subsequently reclaimed.
- walterbell 4y ago> criteria and processes by which those powers will be guaranteed to be rolled back when the situation allows. What's a good historical example of a national or global institution voluntarily giving up totalitarian powers on the basis of subjective criteria?
- pvg 4y agoJust about every industrialized democracy that has the concept of emergency powers and uses them in emergencies? This happens all the time in small and big ways, there are plenty of US examples alone. For instance the US currently does not have rationing or near-universal consumer goods price controls, the National Guard doesn't run New Orleans, etc, etc.
- walterbell 4y agoYes, nation-state-unique emergency powers exist and were used widely over the last few years. > world organizations will need to be pretty totalitarian to effectively manage public health. What's being proposed for May 2023 majority vote goes way beyond existing powers, e.g. asking all countries to strike "human rights" from the international health treaty and their local response to health emergencies.