4 ms·
Why can't Tesla owners plug in their car at home because Tesla's online stuff is broken? Do their cars really need internet access to charge?
by jeroenhd 4y ago
Why can't Tesla owners plug in their car at home because Tesla's online stuff is broken? Do their cars really need internet access to charge?
- kurthr 4y agoYou can, you just can't do billing on SuperChargers. Home charging works... cars work, but it's like credit cards didn't work at the gas station and there was nobody there to take cash.
- ThunderSizzle 4y agoTypically if a gas station isn't accepting payment, I can drive to the one next door. I've done that before, but it's very rare unless if Visa or Mastercard is having issues (which is pretty rare, but affects much more than just gas).
- clouddrover 4y ago> Typically if a gas station isn't accepting payment, I can drive to the one next door. You can do the same in Europe with EVs. Europe standardised on CCS Type 2 Combo for EV charging so you're not locked into one charging network. All brands of DC fast charger can charge all brands of EV, exactly as it should be.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoThat's some wild theory. In my experience as an BEV owner (Skoda Enyaq iv80) it is highly selective and having same plug means nothing if there are incompatible software stacks inside. Some chargers are working fine. Ionity, BP (ironic) Some will not initiate charging because registration email/login/payment in their app does not work. (Freshmile in France, some Swedish one in Greece whose name I forget did not sent an activation email) Some chargers just straight out doesn't like your car, because reasons. "Find another charger" you will be told. (Fortiza) Some chargers are just broken, but you can't tell until you arrive. (Another Freshmile in France)
- clouddrover 4y ago> Some chargers are working fine. Yes, there are better and worse ones. Spend your money at the better ones. > BP (ironic) Why is BP ironic? They're in the energy business. So is Shell.
- pcdevils 4y agoIn the old days when the card machine went down they'd pull out the manual machine that used carbon paper to pick up the embossed numbers on the card and you signed for it. Of course there were lots of cases of fraud linked to those too.
- dmonitor 4y agoThey still do that where I live. Happens very rarely
- ars 4y agoThey really do? My new credit card is no longer embossed - I assumed that this no longer existed anywhere.
- Danny_Dan4 4y agoYup! My semi-local Micro Center did exactly this back when there was a major internet outage in their area; it was a mess, but incredibly neat!
- filoleg 4y agoThey can at home (and third-party chargers), but not at Tesla superchargers. The internet access is needed not for charging, but for making a supercharger transaction. Though I would have personally expected Tesla to set up supercharges in a way that would instead provide free charging when the supercharging internet access is down. The monetary loss from that would probably cost far less than this negative PR. And this is literally the first time I hear about their network going down in a way that supercharging is unavailable (maybe it happened before, but I haven't been paying much attention until 2019), so it isn't like they would be losing tons of money by providing that charging for free. And especially since filling up from around 20% to 90% at a supercharger typically costs me way less (somewhere between $16-26 total) than it would for a gas car.
- helf 4y agoWait wait wait. You expected Tesla to have pre-emptively done something to avoid negative PR? When have they ever done that?
- filoleg 4y agoIt is less about having to do something pre-emptively, and more about having good default configs for fail-safes. Approving charging when there is no connection vs. blocking charging when there is no connection is just a bitflip.
- Turskarama 4y agoKnowing Tesla I expect it's an exception that falls out of the whole charger handshake process.
- LinuxBender 4y agoI agree with everything you said but if I put my Elon hat on, aside from the itching sensation I can imagine their security team pointed out that people would find ways to DoS the terminal into being free. I'm not saying that would be logical, just probably how they were thinking. I'm taking that hat off now.