3 ms·
It certainly sounds stupid, but in the spirit of completeness this is forming a conclusion with insufficient evidence and part of a typical emotional response t
by roenxi 4y ago
It certainly sounds stupid, but in the spirit of completeness this is forming a conclusion with insufficient evidence and part of a typical emotional response that makes people do stupid things.
We don't live forever, and sustained mass homelessness is arguably pretty bad too. If Turkey can't afford indestructible houses then maybe Erdogan made the right decision and it just happens that all the outcomes sucked. Although given the evidence in the article it does look like a catastrophe (20k dead for 350k housed sounds is a bad deal, albeit we can't possibly know that all 20k were from zoning issues) the news right after a disaster is usually highly misleading.
- seydor 4y agoWhat are you talking about? This isnt the first earthquake in the region, it s a story that goes back thousands of years of written history. Most countries in the area have changed their codes and now build houses that are very resistant to earthquakes. Earthquakes happen all the time, (arguably not as big) but rarely you hear about such damages. Turkey has a problem of bad building, like what happened with the Izmir earthquake in 2020
- roenxi 4y agoWhich presumably is no secret and which would have been considered in the decision making - indeed, everyone involved would have known that the next earthquake would have worse consequences. The issue I have - and it is in your comment as well as elsewhere - is you are using an argument that this situation was predictable. That isn't enough. You have to argue that the costs in this disaster outweighed the benefits of a lighter building code. My guess would be that they probably do, the death count is quite high. But that is no excuse for sloppy, knee-jerk thinking. We need less of that.
- seydor 4y agoIt's not knee jerk thinking. Even turkey has nominally strict building codes because of all the previous earthquakes. And it s not like it s running out of land to build. Nobody in this region thinks it could possibly be a good thing to skirt building codes. Earthquakes are frequent enough to be constant reminders of it
- roenxi 4y agoErdogan has previously appeared in videos where he proudly boasted about how he allowed people to skirt building codes. I think there are a lot of people who think it could possibly be a good thing. Otherwise he wouldn't have been giving speeches about it. He's possibly misjudged the cost-benefits; it'd hardly be the first time people have made big mistakes. But we should at least have solid evidence of that before jumping to conclusions.
- jacquesm 4y agoTurkey was doing just fine until Erdogan rolled along, they were really moving in the right direction, becoming a much stronger player economically on the world stage and quality of life was improving. Since then it's been one long series of setbacks, the guy has been a complete disaster for Turkey and a benefit to a very small subset of Turkey.
- kyriakos 4y agoOne could argue that turkey started doing well with Erdogan, at least initially. He then somehow decided that he wants to become an emperor.
- munk-a 4y agoWe're not talking about a zero-sum game where there's X dollars for housing and either you house some people safely or house everyone. Turkey has been expanding it's military spending significantly since Erdogan came to power - it's not unrealistic to imagine some of that revenue could have been redirected to subsidized housing projects and the like.
- roenxi 4y agoTurkey is very close to Russia and is in NATO. The two largest nuclear powers are fighting a war that shares a sea border with them. It may well turn out to be suicidal not to beef up their military. It is unrealistic to redirect some of that revenue to general projects.
- simonh 4y agoI'm sure all the people now left homeless after their homes collapsed will be very understanding of how these amnesties helped solve homelessness. Oh, and it's looking more like 33k killed by the latest count, and over 90k injured.
- gameman144 4y agoYour point that sometimes it's better to shoot for a mediocre solution to remedy a problem is valid; perfect being the enemy of the good and all. In this case, though, it seems incredibly evident in hindsight that the trade-off here was not, in fact, the right call. The thing about bypassing safety valves is that you need to be really sure that you're not just creating a bomb that's going to blow up down the line. In the case of earthquake regulations that were passed in response to a history of earthquakes, it's pretty hard to reasonably assume that the trade-off would be worth it in the long term, hence the outrage.
- roenxi 4y agoBut if you act based on what seems incredibly evident in the month following a disaster, it is common to take action on facts that later turn out to be wrong. There is a reason that courts and engineering reports take a long time - figuring out what actually happened vs. what seems to have just happened is a big step up in difficulty.