4 ms·
And the artists don't have a god given right to produce it once and sell it many times.
by ThomPete 15y ago
And the artists don't have a god given right to produce it once and sell it many times.
- technoslut 15y agoYes they do because they created it. As much as they have ownership over their music, you have the god given right not to buy it.
- ThomPete 15y agoWell then they have a god given right to not digitalize it.
- technoslut 15y agoYou're right but do you really want to return to the 90s when CDs cost $20 each and you had to carry around a 100 CDs instead of an mp3 player? Or to the 80s when we used lo-fi tapes instead? The labels would love this. It shouldn't be required of just the RIAA to use technology properly but everyone. If someone makes music you like, and they're not attempting to rob, respect them. $1 is not much for a song you enjoy.
- ThomPete 15y agoI don't care what the labels do. If they fell they cant make money that way then they should probably stay out of the digital business model. But the truth of course is that they saw huge benefits throughout the years as it became cheaper and cheaper for them to produce and distribute the music. Where is your sympathy for all the truckers, records store people etc. that lost their jobs because of digitalization? I personally have more sympathy for them, the musicians will always have the music. Whether they will be able to live from it is another thing. The smart ones will.
- technoslut 15y agoI'm trying to understand your point. Are you for digital music being available or not? >Where is your sympathy for all the truckers, records store people etc. that lost their jobs because of digitalization? Of course I do have sympathy for them but humanity has to move forward. We are living in a disruptive age – much like those in the beginning of the Industrial Age. Humanity will need to adjust. This really is another subject for another story and doesn't hold relevance to the topic of piracy. >I personally have more sympathy for them, the musicians will always have the music. Whether they will be able to live from it is another thing. This makes no sense. You are condemning musicians to the same fate as those you mentioned. The only difference is that potential future truckers and HS/college students at record stores won't suffer because there will be new jobs created but the artist always will. The world does not need more starving artists.
- ThomPete 15y agoSo basically what you are saying is that the truckers should get with the times but the artist shouldn't? We live as you say in a disruptive age and this applies in no small part to artists. As with regards to the starving artists. Let me remind you that the kind of artists that actually have spent many years becoming good have always been struggling and always needed to do live gigs. They are very different than those the labels push to become big stars today. What i mean with they will alway have art is this. The trucker will loose their job and that's pretty much it. The artists will always be able to do art whether they get paid for it or not.
- technoslut 15y ago>So basically what you are saying is that the truckers should get with the times but the artist shouldn't? You're playing a game that has nobody's interests at hand. Yes I'm saying this because 'truckers' are going to get left behind. You still haven't answered the question of whether we should live in the digital age or not. >Let me remind you that the kind of artists that actually have spent many years becoming good have always been struggling and always needed to do live gigs. You're playing a game against my argument. All artists struggle but do you want them to become eternally poor? >Let me remind you that the kind of artists that actually have spent many years becoming good have always been struggling and always needed to do live gigs. Do you or many know the difference? Are most making the distinction and buying indie products? I can already tell that they are not.
- muuh-gnu 15y ago> Yes they do because Who gave it to them? I dont think that we ever, as a society, ever fundamentally _agreed_ to the existence of such exclusivity rights. Yes they are in the constitution, yes they are in the lawbooks, but the people at large never fundamentally agreed that such rights should be in there. The decision process was always top-down, never bottom-up. They are not a result of peoples morality, but of a interest-driven, behind-closed-doors development process. Those laws dont map the will of the people, of your fellow citizens, but of a few, but influential stake holders. Such rights are not democratically backed. If you would ever have a referendum on copyright policy, you would probably lose them.
- route66 15y agoI see that you are the maker of FinalTouch. Where do you offer the free downloads?
- ThomPete 15y agoWhy should i? People pay for it. Did I ever say that you shouldn't be allowed to make money? Of corse not. I said its not a right but an opportunity.
- urbanjunkie 15y agoI certainly intend to find and distribute pirate versions of FinalTouch. You're ok with that, right?
- ThomPete 15y agoYes of course. If you really want to go through the trouble. Be my guest. It's not going to mean anything.