> sports clubs are run by outside groups and happen after school on their own resources I'm sorry, I don't get your argument here... in your first sentence you

> sports clubs are run by outside groups and happen after school on their own resources I'm sorry, I don't get your argument here... in your first sentence you say school sports harms equity, but then you advocate for private sports clubs - which in my poor district would mean a whole lot of kids not able to participate without the publicly-provided funding of those public school activities. School sports, music, theater, etc is the equity that wouldn't be otherwise available if we all moved to privatized education, clubs, etc. Which is not to say if those clubs are available in your community and you can afford them, good for you and your kids.