4 ms·
If a union protects people who are not doing their job from being made to do it, that is an argument for chosing a different union not against unions in general
by vidarh 4y ago
If a union protects people who are not doing their job from being made to do it, that is an argument for chosing a different union not against unions in general.
- Robotbeat 4y agoIn the US, you don’t really have the luxury of picking a different union. This is one reason unions suck in the US.
- vidarh 4y agoYou do, sort of (though I get what you mean) even as an individual, even though it's less common and affects the benefits you get from being a member, and you may risk still paying dues to the recognised union (if there is one, and your state allows agency fees). At the larger scale, your choice is to try to convince your co-workers. The downside of joining a minority union / members only union is not that different in the US as elsewhere, in that you generally have no legal right to be treated as a bargaining agent or in the case of some such unions they explicitly don't even try get recognition. But even the US has examples of minority unions being voluntarily given some degree of representation: https://eu.freep.com/story/money/cars/2014/11/12/uaw-volkswagen-organizing-policy-representation/18901197/ https://eu.freep.com/story/money/cars/2014/11/12/uaw-volkswa...
- Robotbeat 4y agoSo in other words… we have effective union monopolization in the US.
- vidarh 4y agoNot all that much more so than in a substantial proportion of other countries with far more powerful unions, and which often have multiple unions represented in the same companies. Most places have thresholds to be met before an employer can be forced to recognise a given union. It's not unusual for that threshold to be 50% per unit and for people to still opt to stay members in a minority union, which you can in the US too. The main way the US distinguishes itself in terms of unionisation is by low union membership, and as such the lack of significant minority union locals in the US is more a factor of few people joining a union unless they'd be paying agency fees anyway.
- trashtester 4y agoA lot of years ago, before entering college, my father was working in an aluminium melting plant in western Norway for a year. Being young and fit, he was able to work quite fast. Shortly after starting, he was approached by the local Union bosses, and sternly told to slow down. Not only did he make everone else look bad, if people worked that much, that would lead to layoffs. Not wanting trouble with the Union, he and his pal switched to only working about 4 hours each night (it was usually night shifts) and then sleep the remaining 4 hours of the shift.
- vidarh 4y agoIt's not clear to me whether you see this as an argument for being part of that union or for picking another one. Protecting the workforce against expectations that might be unreasonable for many workers is an essential part of the functions unions serve. Your dad might have been happy to have worked faster and longer when he was young, but if he'd remained in that job he'd soon be happy the performance expectations were not set so high that he'd start struggling to meet them. Having grown up in Norway and now living in the UK, I massively prefer the work-life balance and workers protections high union participation has created in Norway over the UK (and the US is far worse than the UK in this respect).
- trashtester 4y agoPretty sure Jern og Metall (Metallurgy union) would not have accepted competition at that workplace at that time. :) > I massively prefer the work-life balance and workers protections high union participation has created in Norway over the UK Sure, though it comes at a pretty significant cost in terms of efficiency and of the ability of the more productive part of the workforce to generate income for themselves. Over time, this kind of setup tends to lead to loss of competitiveness, often resulting in fewer jobs / layoffs, lower salaries or to requiring the rest of society to pay subsidies, trade barriers and/or for consumers to pay more for their products. Case in point would be Norwegian agricultural unions. And maybe worst of all, a society dominated by unions may cause some of the most productive citizens to seek better opportunities abroad ;)