4 ms·
Just abolish copyright. I'm not joking. There are many ways to earn money from films, music, art, books, etc., without needing copyright. The only reason D is
by WalterBright 4y ago
Just abolish copyright. I'm not joking.
There are many ways to earn money from films, music, art, books, etc., without needing copyright.
The only reason D is released under the Boost License is because public domain has no legal standing in many countries. The Boost License is the most permissive one in wide use that we could find.
- yodon 4y ago>Just abolish copyright Copyright is called out in the constitution. It's not a trivial thing to "just abolish," at least in the US.
- smcameron 4y agoCouldn't congress set the "limited Times" mentioned in the constitution to an absurdly short value by merely passing a law if it wanted to, and wouldn't that have the same effect as abolishing copyright?
- thereisnospork 4y agoThat would be about as constitutional as limiting the exercise of free speech to those times when no one is around to hear you.
- pessimizer 4y agoPretty sure that's constitutional. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_speech_zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_speech_zone
- shagie 4y agoCopyright durations are honored by all the signatories of the Berne Convention. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_Convention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_Convention > The Berne Convention requires its parties to recognize the protection of works of authors from other parties to the convention at least as well as those of its own nationals. For example, French copyright law applies to anything published, distributed, performed, or in any other way accessible in France, regardless of where it was originally created, if the country of origin of that work is in the Berne Union. > In addition to establishing a system of equal treatment that harmonised copyright amongst parties, the agreement also required member states to provide strong minimum standards for copyright law. > ... > The Berne Convention states that all works except photographic and cinematographic shall be protected for at least 50 years after the author's death, but parties are free to provide longer terms, as the European Union did with the 1993 Directive on harmonising the term of copyright protection. For photography, the Berne Convention sets a minimum term of 25 years from the year the photograph was created, and for cinematography the minimum is 50 years after first showing, or 50 years after creation if it has not been shown within 50 years after the creation.
- ronsor 4y agoThen let's make it 5-10 years.
- shagie 4y agoBernie Convention, Article 7 https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text/283698 https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text/283698 (1) The term of protection granted by this Convention shall be the life of the author and fifty years after his death. (2) However, in the case of cinematographic works, the countries of the Union may provide that the term of protection shall expire fifty years after the work has been made available to the public with the consent of the author, or, failing such an event within fifty years from the making of such a work, fifty years after the making. --- ... unless you're also proposing leaving the Bernie convention or changing an international treaty.
- smlavine 4y agoThe Constitution merely says that "The Congress shall have Power...To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries;" not that Congress is /required/ to do so. The real problem would be the Berne Convention.
- pbj1968 4y agoMay want to freshen up your understanding of the word “shall.”
- pessimizer 4y agoDon't get hung up on the word "just." "Just" is relative, so arguing about its value can lead to nothing but pointless discussion.
- swatcoder 4y agoI love that we’re in an age where folk art is resurgent and that you can raise enough money to commit time to your art and get it seen. But copyright is what enables some of the big cultural spectacles that a lot of us enjoy, like bookstores and galleries and professional editors/finishers and blockbusters and broadway shows, etc etc. Without copyright, these industries aren’t sustainable and grand art becomes dependent entirely on arbitrary patronage by the aristocracy and government. For what ills there are to capitalism, these billion dollar art industries have their upsides.
- WalterBright 4y agoReally? What effect would no copyright have on broadway shows, which are live performances? I expect no effect at all. After all, musicians perform Beethoven all the time. Somehow, that works.
- SeanLuke 4y ago> Just abolish copyright. I'm not joking. You are proposing eliminating viral licenses. > There are many ways to earn money from films, music, art, books, etc., without needing copyright. This an extraordinary claim, and extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. I think you don't have it. I suspect that, realistically, the only way to earn money from "films, music, art, books, etc.," without copyright is a patronage system. That's far from good.
- WalterBright 4y ago> This an extraordinary claim, and extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. I think you don't have it. I don't? Germany in the 1800s did not have copyright protection, and it was boom time for them. Musicians make tons of money from live performances. CDs serve as advertisements for their live concerts. Wealthy people love to buy original paintings for $$$$ when the images of them are free all over the intertoobs. Academics don't make much of anything from books. The books serve to boost their professional reputations, which they turn into money. Celebrity authors make money by being celebrities. The free software industry is thriving. Patronage is not a bad system. I don't know why you think it is. Just look at all the incredible medieval art resulting from it.
- SeanLuke 4y ago> Germany in the 1800s did not have copyright protection, and it was boom time for them Because England's book publishers had a cartel. Eckhard Höffner's argument is absurd on the face of it (he basically says: England had copyright, Germany did not, Germany published more books, therefore not having a copyright causes you to publish more books). He also didn't bother to look to other places, like the US. > Musicians make tons of money from live performances A vanishingly small number of musicians make tons of money from live performances. Music is probably the defining example of the need for copyright. > Patronage is not a bad system. I don't know why you think it is. Just look at all the incredible medieval art resulting from it. Yes, check out all that medieval art of things unintersting to wealthy people and the Church. Patronage was, and is, a horrible system. It is art feudalism and serfdom. You're basically arguing that Elon Musk gets to determine what art is made. > The free software industry is thriving. I'm sure Canonical is raking in the money compared to Microsoft. But let's get back to the item you ignored: by eliminating copyright, you are effectively destroying viral licenses and the free software movement that goes with them.
- caconym_ 4y ago> There are many ways to earn money from films, music, art, books, etc., without needing copyright. I see this opinion all over the place, but it never seems to be coming from actual working artists, and I am curious why people who don't have any skin in the game are comfortable speaking for those who do. As somebody who's published code under relatively permissive FOSS licenses, I don't think that perspective is very relevant given the different incentives involved.
- WalterBright 4y agoI (along with the rest of the D community) give away the D language compiler & tools for free. If that ain't skin in the game, I don't know what is.
- caconym_ 4y agoSee, this is exactly the part that software people don't get. You give your code away for free, which means you have decided up front that you don't stand to benefit from retaining any rights for yourself (except perhaps minor ones like attribution, or whatever the license(s) you use call for). That is the exact opposite of having skin in the game---your skin is somewhere else, in another game. As I said: different incentives. Why don't novelists all release their full manuscripts under highly permissive free licenses at the same time as their published volumes hit the store shelves? Is it because they're all stupid and vain, wringing their hands over a non-issue? Or could it be that all things are not equal, and that their living depends on the protections afforded them by copyright law in a way yours doesn't?
- WalterBright 4y agoI make money from the secondary effects. > Why don't novelists all release their full manuscripts under highly permissive free licenses at the same time as their published volumes hit the store shelves? They're likely afraid to try. I'm not afraid. Novelists don't make much money. Giving the novels away is a way to get fame, and fame can be turned into money. > their living depends on the protections afforded them by copyright law Does it? It's really hard to make a living writing novels.
- elif 4y agoThe us economy is 77% service-based. If you delete intellectual property value, what do you expect to happen? Let's go back to joking.
- WalterBright 4y ago> If you delete intellectual property value, what do you expect to happen? Ever noticed the boom in free software?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bdowling 4y ago> There are many ways to earn money from films, music, art, books, etc., without needing copyright. For any of those ways, it will always be cheaper to copy someone else's films, music, art, books, etc. rather than spend time and effort to produce them yourself. This is more true where only some works are popular (e.g., where a publisher publishes 50 books for every hit), because a copier can just copy the popular works and skip the unpopular ones.
- jongjong 4y agoExactly, we will end up with a handful of 'attention monopolists' who will just take people's best works and reap 100% of profits by acting as centralized publishers and gatekeepers for the world's content... Kind of like what we have in the software industry with open source.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhat gatekeepers are there with open source? I don't recall asking anybody for permission to develop the D programming language and give it away for free.
- jongjong 4y agoSure, anyone can create a project, but what's the point if nobody will hear about it and nobody will use it regardless of how good it is? This is the reality for many projects; they may have added massive value but we don't know that they exist. It doesn't make sense to compare modern open source projects with projects from a previous era. More new open source projects are created each day than used to be created each year but we hardly ever hear about any of these new projects. We only hear about corporate sponsored 'open source' projects... Which, for the most part are terrible; people would realize how terrible they are if only they could see what else is out there, but they don't. Even with my skeptical mindset (actively trying to find indie/underdog projects), I only know about a tiny fraction of open source projects which would interest me (if I could know about their existence). I can't even dream of using indie projects during my day job... Every single employer has been brainwashed into using only 'approved' big-tech OSS projects and this effect is getting worse each year.