3 ms·
I wrote this sentiment earlier[1], but I'll repeat it here. If a dev wants money for his work, he should license his work as appropriate and demand payments. I
by Dalewyn 4y ago
I wrote this sentiment earlier[1], but I'll repeat it here.
If a dev wants money for his work, he should license his work as appropriate and demand payments. If a dev releases his work free-as-in-libre and/or free-as-in-beer, they don't get to complain if the donations are "insufficient".
Or to put it another: Of course a company won't pay up if they don't have to.
This guy seems to be considering making his work into a commercial product, so at least he has the correct idea. Speaking objectively I hope it works out for him.
[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34759316 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34759316
- zztop44 4y agoAnd to echo the top reply to your original comment, nope you don’t get to decide to for everyone. I personally think that releasing free software and then complaining that the multibillionaire (trillionaire?) companies that rely on it refuse to fund you even after you’ve expressly asked for it is perfectly justified.
- green_on_black 4y agoOkay, and now half the devs simply decide to not deal with the issue of licensing and just business source everything. Congrats, that's definitely the better world to code in, right?
- linkdd 4y ago> If a dev releases his work free-as-in-libre and/or free-as-in-beer, they don't get to complain if the donations are "insufficient". Of course they get to complain. Complaining and doing nothing to change the situation is what's problematic. Doing work without reward, even if you did not expect any in the first place, can be soul-sucking, and it is totally normal to complain about it. You don't do FOSS for the recognition/glory, but complaining about the hatred, hypocrisy, and complete lack of respect of the industry towards FOSS is normal. The backlash he got after he "dared" ask for help was completely uncalled for. I'd even say this, it's the user who does not get to complain, let's remind everyone of what most FOSS licenses include: THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE. You get a message during `npm install` from the dev asking for funding and a job? Tough shit, you don't get to complain because you're not paying him.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Dalewyn 4y ago>Of course they get to complain. No, they don't. They specifically waived any compensation by licensing their work for free-as-in-libre and/or free-as-in-beer. If they want to have social and legal standing to complain, they should have demanded compensation upfront. >You don't do FOSS for the recognition/glory, but complaining about the hatred, hypocrisy, and complete lack of respect of the industry towards FOSS is normal. FOSS doesn't ask for money. -> Users proceed to pay no money, because why would they? -> FOSS is pissed they don't get money. This whole saga is hypocritical on FOSS's part. If devs want money they should demand money with appropriate licensing. It really isn't hard, it's dead simple. Users and companies are happy to pay up if you can get them to sign the contract. >I'd even say this, it's the user who does not get to complain, ... You get a message during `npm install` from the dev asking for funding and a job? Tough shit, you don't get to complain because you're not paying him. Absolutely. Users don't get to complain about something they got for free.
- kodt 4y agoSurely you can complain about receiving hate mail and unsolicited vitriol.
- Dalewyn 4y agoAbsolutely, that bullshit is 300% unwarranted regardless the circumstances. I'm arguing that complaining about lack of compensation is stupid and hypocritical after you have explicitly waived such compensations.
- nextaccountic 4y ago> If a dev wants money for his work, he should license his work as appropriate and demand payments. If a dev releases his work free-as-in-libre and/or free-as-in-beer, they don't get to complain if the donations are "insufficient". The author might still do it (it's one of his options) but please note that proprietary core libraries (and proprietary software in general) are immensely less useful than open source software. The value proposition of core-js is that it's a basic piece of infrastructure that other open source projects build upon, and if it were proprietary, no OSS could depend on it.
- wpietri 4y agoYeah, I saw that victim-blaming take last time and I still say it's bunk. They do get to complain. It would be a better world if this guy could just be building his extremely useful package and making a modest living. We are not in that world yet, but we will never get there if people can't talk about problems. I understand this can be a shock to free-market fundamentalists, but not every issue is best solved through capitalism. Forcing an excellent developer to become a probably-mediocre startup CEO is not a clear step forward here. So I'm grateful to him speaking up. If you don't want to hear it, maybe exercise your freedom to stop reading articles like this.
- dools 4y agoThe problem is that as soon as he turns this into a billable enterprise solution it will artificially inflate the price. He’s giving all the people who depend on this project a chance to get it at a discount.
- Dalewyn 4y agoSo long as compensations are optional (note: donations are voluntary, aka optional), most users/companies are not going to give monies. That's just how society rolls, to say nothing of the professional business world subset.