9 ms·
> But setting that aside, is life today (in a rich western country) more "enjoyable" or "fulfilling" now than it was, say, 500 years ago? Wander a graveyard fr
by ceejayoz 4y ago
> But setting that aside, is life today (in a rich western country) more "enjoyable" or "fulfilling" now than it was, say, 500 years ago?
Wander a graveyard from the 1800s and see how many very young children are listed on the headstones below their parents. How do we account for "a bunch of your kids are likely to die" in this metric?
It's easy to look with rose-hued glasses at the past and imagine an idylic pastoral lifestyle. The reality was quite a bit more complicated.
- glomgril 4y agoRight -- medical advances are the major exception to this line of thinking, as I noted.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThere are a lot of exceptions. Strawberries in winter. Ice cream in summer. Contact with relatives on the other side of the world in an instant. Travel to Europe in hours. Unlimited fresh water. Indoor plumbing. Universal access to education. YouTube videos to learn how to use and fix a tool. etc. etc. etc.
- Amezarak 4y agoAll those things are great, or at least you and I think they are. But that's not the question. The question is do those things make for greater human thriving and fulfillment? Increasing things that people find pleasurable does not necessarily have this effect. As a simple and extreme example, consider heroin. I read a lot of old stuff, with a focus on anything I can find from regular people. I used to think like you do. I'm much less convinced nowadays that we've really made people's lives better in a meaningful, non-material way, excepting a very few examples that GP already alluded to (e.g., reduction in infant mortality, which accounts for virtually the entire life expectancy increase since 1850.)
- glomgril 4y agoYeah this is pretty much my line of thinking. Not making any grand claims, just questioning the conventional wisdom. No doubt that the material conditions, health, and conveniences of today are unparalleled in history, that's just not what I'm talking about right now.
- tuatoru 4y agoI think you are talking about "meaning" in life, the sense of being part of something larger than yourself, that isn't just accumulation for accumulation's sake. There is a debate there, no doubt. The scientists and engineers that work insane hours at SpaceX are probably looking for something like that. But in the past, for most people, life was merely a struggle to survive, that they lost sooner rather than later.
- arp242 4y ago"Struggle to survive" gives meaning to life though. And one of the best ways to form deep connections with people is shared hardship. It's really hard to say what's "better" in any sort of objective and quantifiable way; but it seems to me that by making the basics of life very easy we've sort of lost something along the way. After all, playing a game that's so easy that it doesn't provide any challenge isn't much fun either, right?
- throwaway675309 4y agoThe "Struggle to survive" gives meaning to life though. No, it doesn't, this is just one of those banal transcendental platitudes that gets repeated enough to where it sounds like it's some sort of objective truth. Like the one about how "life only has meaning because it is short and ephemeral". By that logic an aborted fetus has had the richest life of all. Life's meaning is ultimately in the eyes of the beholder. We all derive meaning differently, there is no universal solvent.
- Isinlor 4y agoYou are free to make your life as difficult as you want. You can move to Alaska and try to survive there from manual work. There is a very good reason why people want to go from poor countries to rich and not the other way around. Poverty is not fun.