3 ms·
I don't think IFS is any less objective than social science academia, which is dominated by people who take "rights" and "autonomy" as essential ends in themsel
by rayiner 4y ago
I don't think IFS is any less objective than social science academia, which is dominated by people who take "rights" and "autonomy" as essential ends in themselves. Indeed, I'm not sure it's even possible to be objective in this space. The underlying phenomenal are complex and multi-faceted, while the broader principles are quasi religious in nature. That said, the underlying survey is from Yougov/Deseret, and it says what it says.
Also, it's not an isolated finding. The finding that conservatives are happier is consistently replicated (and long before 2022).
- elil17 4y agoRegardless of how objective the IFS is, the specific page you linked to is not high quality research. It uses data from a survey commissioned by the Mormon church and does not account for any confounding factors.
- rayiner 4y agoThe study is conducted by the Center for the Study of Elections and Democracy at BYU, Deseret News, and Yougov.
- tptacek 4y agoYes, the "Mormon Church" thing here seems like a super cheap shot.
- elil17 4y agoDeseret News is a wholly owned subsidiary of the LDS church. BYU is part of the Church Education System, which is part of the LDS church, and the president of the church directly controls BYU via his chairmanship of the BYU board. Yougov is a surveys for hire company. So, yeah, it’s a survey run by the Mormon church. But, more importantly, the conclusions drawn from it by IFS are simply not academically rigorous.
- tptacek 4y agoIf you look again, you'll notice that I didn't incorporate any social science academia into my point. I'm not violently allergic to that research, but it's not something I keep tabs on, so you can usually assume I'm not trying to take down an argument you're making with "The University of California, Berkeley Center For Comparative Family Welfare says...". Unlike the sibling comment here, I'm not trying to disqualify the underlying survey, just to point out that it's framing in the article you cited is heavily motivated; countervailing results or analysis presumably would not be allowed to run on the IFS website.
- rayiner 4y ago> Unlike the sibling comment here, I'm not trying to disqualify the underlying survey, just to point out that it's framing in the article you cited is heavily motivated; countervailing results or analysis presumably would not be allowed to run on the IFS website IFS is "heavily motivated" compared to who exactly? Would New America or whoever NPR and the NYT turn to for analysis ever run with a similar story? The notion that increased autonomy and reduced social restriction is an unalloyed good is almost axiomatic among the folks who run every mainstream intellectual institution that isn't expressly conservative. It's the closest a lot of these folks have to a religion. They're highly motivated not to publish contrary evidence.
- tptacek 4y agoI mean: IFS is much, much more motivated than NYT is, but if your point is that NYT is not, on its own, entirely trustworthy about subjective evaluations of research: sure. That's true. But: I didn't cite the NYT. For what it's worth, most of my conservative friends would strongly disagree with you about the importance of individual autonomy!