4 ms·
It’s clear that there’s been a long term decline in mental well-being over the past few decades. In another example, men have far fewer friends today than even
by rayiner 4y ago
It’s clear that there’s been a long term decline in mental well-being over the past few decades. In another example, men have far fewer friends today than even 30 years ago: https://www.americansurveycenter.org/why-mens-social-circles-are-shrinking/ https://www.americansurveycenter.org/why-mens-social-circles...
You can blame technology to a degree, but even then technology probably just serves to amplify existing negative trends. Kids today are far more likely than in the past to move around and have divorced parents. They’re less likely to live in inter-generational households. They’re less likely to have a job or go to church or interact with society at large in meaningful ways.
Meanwhile what fills that vacuum of civil society is other children, through age-segregated schooling and, these days, social media. That strikes me as a huge problem, because children are antisocial semi-humans without fully developed brains. Having children spend most of their time around other children, without strong socializing forces, is a perverse arrangement.
- rektide 4y agoBeing with mostly the same 20-750 kids (depending on school size) in your grade for most of your growing up seems cruel. You're going to change a lot, but the social dynamics can only evolve so much. The lack of ability to reinvent yourself, to re-find place is starkly different than the rest of the world, where that activity & the newness of other people is perpetual. I've been so thankful that at my high school there was a great open lunch, & quite a few areas where different school grades mixed together. I got access to a diverse range of smart & creative folk.
- lastofus 4y agoI don't think it was that long ago that communities of humans were quite small, and the number of peers your age around you would easily fall into the 20-750 range.
- dotnet00 4y agoThose communities did still suffer from the social ills being described. Personally I agree, having the freedom to 'reset' my group of peers every 3-4 years through to uni ended up being pretty valuable in making me a better, more open minded and more creative person than I might've been otherwise.
- was_a_dev 4y agoIn the UK, you attend highscool between 11-16 with it being common to then spend 16-18 at what we call sixth-form at the same school. This is just an additional two grades surrounded by the same kids and teachers. Luckily for me, my highschool has no sixth-form. Therefore I went to a dedicated sixth-form college. A large college of 2000 students over two year groups. I really enjoyed this time. I shedded all associations except for my closest friends and made new friend circles. It refined my character. And when I started university, the whole process was much easier.
- tablespoon 4y ago> Being with mostly the same 20-750 kids (depending on school size) in your grade for most of your growing up seems cruel. You're going to change a lot, but the social dynamics can only evolve so much. The lack of ability to reinvent yourself, to re-find place is starkly different than the rest of the world, where that activity & the newness of other people is perpetual. It is also cruel to do the opposite, perhaps more cruel. Honestly, I think "reinvention" is overvalued/oversold in contemporary culture, and I'd reckon most kids (and adults) would be better served by maintaining their existing friendships and social patterns instead of forcing a change for change's sake.
- xiphias2 4y agoThere have been a long list of technological development to separate having sex from marriage / having children (from contraceptives in the 70s to loud electric/house music where personalities are not important to Facebook that allows global matchmaking to Tinder that allows global matchmaking in parallel execution). Globally everybody is getting less than what media (and social media) peomised them, but we have to live long enough to understand the destruction it causes in our own lives.