3 ms·
> Air and noise pollution are regulated for a good reason Regulated, yes, but that doesn't mean "I consented to [...]". Even a single person driving a car poll
by arp242 4y ago
> Air and noise pollution are regulated for a good reason
Regulated, yes, but that doesn't mean "I consented to [...]". Even a single person driving a car pollutes the air and noise, and none of the people who involuntarily come in contact with that car consented to that, much less explicitly consented to it. This applies to almost all motorized forms of transportation to at least some degree.
But that doesn't mean these are unreasonable things to do, or that explicit consent needs to be given. The basic rule for public life is "do what you will, unless you unreasonably inconvenience others". Although there is wide disagreement on what exactly "unreasonably inconvenience others", almost everyone across the ideological spectrum mostly agrees on that basic principle. Generally speaking, if you don't unreasonably inconvenience others then it's accepted that consent doesn't need to be given. "Unreasonable" is key here, because many things can (and do) inconvenience others, but that doesn't mean it's unreasonable because we all got to live our lives.
> You may feel like such telemetry doesn't need explicit consent
I never actually said that; I mostly wanted to comment on "I think consent is far more complex than what you're saying".
I don't actually know what I think of this. Mostly I'd like to move towards a future where "consent" is de-emphasized because if something is considered bad by the overwhelming majority of the population no one should be doing that at all in the first place.
Once the invasive tracking stops (i.e. becomes regulated) there probably isn't much need to worry about fairly innocent telemetry as this mostly seems to be a matter of trust ("I don't know what you will do with this data").
I don't really know what that would concretely look like in practice (e.g. what the exact laws should look like, how to enforce it, etc.)