10 ms·
Loyal to the Company
- cratermoon 4y agoScott Adams almost getting it.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoAlmost?
- cwmma 4y agoMy reaction was, I wonder who writes Dilbert these days, because it doesn't seem like it's Scott Adams.
- hn_user82179 4y agoI feel like his tone has changed over the years. A lot of his earlier work felt more jokey or ridiculous and his newer, recent work just feels like not-very-funny topical one-liners.
- anonu 4y agoIts 100% scott adams. I think he outsources his coloring only.
- buster 4y agoBut please don't mistake this with a general "no company is loyal to its employees". Maybe rare, but not non-existent.
- freitzkriesler2 4y agoIn my experience, it's typically the smaller the company the more loyal they are to good employees. Big companies with plenty of institutional inertia have zero loyalty and would replace their entire workforce with chatgpt of given the opportunity.
- masterof0 4y agoI have yet to see a company where the "loyal" employees are paid more than those who leave for a better salary, or are exempt from laid off. I feel like "Company Loyalty" is one of those nonsensical ideas boomers left to the younger generation.
- FredPret 4y agoIt's a business relationship and should be treated as such by the employees. Employee loyalty is ridiculous because it's clearly only one-way loyalty.
- qup 4y agoOnly if you believe loyalty can only be bought with loyalty. Companies provide some value for employees that they don't get back from them, and vice versa.
- masterof0 4y agoWhat value besides money? A company paying a employee to be "loyal" is nothing more than a business transaction, and "loyal" really is "please, don't go to another company, we will pay you to stay here". I'm assuming the employee is not also the owner.
- qup 4y agoI agree. I think what most people seek in a company is the weathering of risk, the establishment of an opportunity, and the reliability of income. Employers can "demand" loyalty, but as you say, it's basically a request. There's no legal basis for it or anything. I think it's fine to have a culture of loyalty. It probably means you have a pretty good company. Demanding it doesn't work, and if it's not real loyalty, we don't have to be mad about it being one-sided.
- mcculley 4y agoDo you have good examples of companies loyal to employees? I have been pretty loyal to my employees, but I have had to make hard decisions when the health of the company was higher priority than loyalty to an employee.
- wahnfrieden 4y agocan it be called loyalty when it only appears to exist when it's not an inconvenience to the business or an owner's profit?
- mcculley 4y agoThis is why I am asking. I did not say that I made decisions against employees when it was an inconvenience to the business or to my profit. I made hard decisions when employees jeopardized the company.
- AlbertCory 4y agoIn fact, my next article on Maps will talk about the Zagat acquisition. Tim and Nina Zagat were getting on in years, and wanted to protect their employees against getting acquired by some ruthless private equity owners. So they sold to Google. Oh well. Zagat was eventually spun out again. I don't know what happened to those long-time employees.
- runjake 4y agoI don't see anything wrong with that. Similarly, employees have to make hard decisions when the health of their families is a higher priority than loyalty to the company. Maybe we should stop using the term "loyalty" because it unfairly implies absolutes -- at least in the minds of westerners.
- zacherates 4y agoMake no mistake, all companies are one leveraged buy-out away from full private equity ruthlessness. Even if the current owners are great – people get older, they'll want to retire... and we all die. Eventually the ownership can pass to someone who really wants to turn the screws.
- kerkeslager 4y agoNo company is loyal to its employees. People are capable of loyalty, but companies are simply not capable of loyalty. One of my neighbors a few years back worked at a lumber mill for 30+ years, including some serious downturns in demand for lumber when the owner of the company took little or no pay to make sure he could keep on his employees. The owner of the company? Super loyal. The owner died, and his daughter, who inherited the company, didn't want to run it, so she sold it to a local investor who took one look at the books and laid off almost all the staff including my neighbor, replacing them with minimum-wage-ish workers. I don't think the daughter intended this to happen, she just didn't have the business knowledge to prevent it. Luckily my ex-neighbor had less than a year left on his mortgage when this happened, and was able to pay off his house before unemployment ran out, but he wasn't able to find work (probably in part due to ageism). Last I heard (just before the pandemic) his attempt at starting a knife-sharpening business out of his home had failed and he was trying to sell the business, with still a few more years before he could collect social security (and give up full social security benefits by doing so).
- brundolf 4y ago> No company is loyal to its employees. People are capable of loyalty, but companies are simply not capable of loyalty. The smaller the company, the less distinction there is between "the company" and "the people who own it". So it's possible to have something like loyalty/trust with the company if you have loyalty/trust with the people in charge But there's always a difference, and it can always change in the time it takes to sell, or IPO, or take new investment
- kerkeslager 4y ago> The smaller the company, the less distinction there is between "the company" and "the people who own it". So it's possible to have something like loyalty/trust with the company if you have loyalty/trust with the people in charge I understand what you're getting at, and this is why I support small businesses both with my money and politically, and when I can, by working for them. If someone has to look you in the eye when they screw you over, they're less likely to screw you over. And on the flipside, this is why I generally despise large corporations. More often than not, "scale" is achieved by creating enough distance between those in charge and those not in charge, and then mercilessly exploiting those not in charge. But ultimately, the distinction between business and business owner will always be there at any size company, and loyalty, if it exists, will always be a trait of the business owner, not the business.
- vuln 4y agoEmployee loyalty is usually the priority that comes last, _just one more big push and then we can breath_ except the breath never happens and now management expects the next project to finish quicker with less people.
- showdeddd 4y agoThat breath has been "two weeks away" for about five years now.
- aliqot 4y agoI totally forgot about two weeks to flatten the curve. edit: In my area, ER's are no longer over capacity. Is this true where you are? I'm curious if we can determine a date for this milestone, because it'd be good to know statistically speaking for if an event on this level ever happens again.
- soundsgoodtome 4y agoOlder I get, more I realize that this game is brutal as shit. Is what it is though. Kill or be killed.
- evan_ 4y agoI didn't realize Dilbert stopped wearing a tie; according to Wikipedia the dress code changed in October 2014: https://dilbert.com/strip/2014-10-13 https://dilbert.com/strip/2014-10-13
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago[flagged]
- DoctorOW 4y agoDo you actually find it funny? This is the same joke that's repeated over and over. I can't imagine enjoying it the 500th time. It's more of just a veil for certain beliefs.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoYes I do.
- alex64 4y agoI think this is the real joke
- hn_user82179 4y agoI personally find it funny at face-value but the joke does get ruined for me because, as you say, it's just a veil for certain beliefs. I used to enjoy a lot more of Aronson's work until I realized he was just strawmanning the views he disagreed with. I had previously thought it was just good-natured ribbing. For an actual funny (and not so "blah blah SJWs ruining everything") version of this joke, the tv show Atlanta does a much more entertaining version of it, you can find it if you search "transracial".
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoIt's ruined because you don't like Scott Adams but the Atlanta clip (which is good, thanks for sharing) is funny because you like Donald Glover? I like both spins on the joke as well as both comedians.
- hn_user82179 4y agoI actually don’t know Donald Glover’s political views, but I do know Scott Adams’s political views because he’s very outspoken about them and he keeps complaining about “cancel culture”. In general, I’m pretty tired of comedians making low-effort jokes and then going on about how they’re going to be cancelled because they’re “so edgy” - it’s just trying to get a rise out of people. That’s what Adams seems to be trying to do here. He also posted a bunch of tweets about how he was going to get cancelled for that strip and it just made me roll my eyes.
- cm2012 4y agoThis is such classic HN thought. That doesn't make it any less true though.
- AlbertCory 4y agoMy Dad worked for Swift & Co. for 45 years. Nonetheless, when I quit my first job, he said to me, approvingly, "They're not loyal to you, so why should you be loyal to them?" There are companies loyal to their employees. They tend to be small and family-owned, though, and when the family retires or loses control, the new owners tend to be markedly less loyal.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoMy grandfather owned rice plantations as a young man... up until the bank which held the mortgages on the properties decided that it wanted to sell the land to a refinery. He then went to work for Shell for the next 25 years. My godfather worked for Shell for 30 years. So did my father. And when my dad ended his career there, they were about to start dismantling the global data warehousing implementation team, so he offered up his own job to receive severance. He received 2 years of pay, all 16 weeks of accrued vacation time, and of course got to keep his pension and his 401K. I think that one of the reasons that the area is so patriarchal and right-wing is because that's the career experience of a lot of people over there. They work forever at one place, maybe survive a few layoffs, and are generally well taken care of. This deludes people into believing that it's how it is for everyone: that you can simply roll out of bed after high school and get a life-long career which will afford you a middle class lifestyle.
- lisper 4y agoIt's called "survivorship bias", and it's not just for people who "roll out of bed and get a life-long career." It applies equally well to pretty much everyone, including ultra-successful company founders. "Hey, if I can do it, anyone can do it, and the ones who don't are obviously just not willing to work hard enough or take enough risks."
- AlbertCory 4y agoIt's not called "survivorship bias." That's a term for looking at, e.g. mutual funds' 5-year records, where the only ones you see are the ones who've been around for 5 years, and not the ones that failed. Company "loyalty" is sometimes a valid concept, but the probability goes down the bigger the company gets.
- zac23or 4y agoDilbert is a documentary!
- Aloha 4y agoMy boss actually gave me similar advice when I took another job. He also welcomed me back to my old role when that job didnt suit me.
- bluedino 4y agoSmaller, family-owned companies can be loyal to a fault. Long-time employees can be hard to get rid of. One good deed, closing one big deal, sticking with the company during tough times, being buddies with the right people... A lot of owners can be sympathetic to certain people as well. Keeping employees that miss work for any excuse, moochers that get raises for no reason, bad performers, it can be tough for other employers that won't realize that there isn't anything they can do themselves about this, and to just focus on their own work. On the other hand, I've seen people go through family crisis, health issues, etc and still receive a paycheck for months at a time when missing lots of work. That's a loyal company.
- avgcorrection 4y agoHN, sticking up for Corporate Man even on a Dilbert comic.
- roarcher 4y agoI wonder if you've ever had the pleasure of working for a small company full of the owner's incompetent friends and family. Loyalty is nice within reason, but it can be pathological.
- avgcorrection 4y agoI wonder what possessed you to think that I was sticking up for small companies. Or any kind of company.
- roarcher 4y agoI didn't think that, quite the contrary. Since you seem to have trouble with comprehension, let me break this comment thread down for you: - GP says that loyalty isn't always always a good thing because it causes small companies to keep incompetent or lazy employees. - You make an ideological remark about how GP is "sticking up for Corporate Man" by saying that. - I respond that yes, in fact, small companies often do employ useless people out of misplaced loyalty, perhaps you just haven't personally experienced it. - You somehow misinterpret my comment as accusing YOU of sticking up for companies. I did not. Don't worry, I fully understand that your entire philosophy boils down to "companies bad". - You are here. Does that clear things up, or are you still lost?
- msla 4y agoI think the online zeitgeist (in my bubble at least) has been away from blind loyalty and towards self-care. Work? Eh, the bubble-mates I have vary from "transactional business arrangement" to "kill the bosses and feast on their corpses" so the Overton window is pretty far from the "thirty years of devotion capped off with a pension" mindset. Religion? Americans in general are losing their religion, and the people I'm with are on the forefront of that trend.^1 Hard to feel anything positive towards the GOP's Junior Auxiliary. Family? People I'm around are all about cutting toxic family members out of their lives. "You have to stick with your family no matter what!" sounds like Evil Space Alien Talk. 1 https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/09/atheism-fastest-growing-religion-us/598843/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/09/atheism-fa... https://archive.is/DObne https://archive.is/DObne
- favourable 4y agoReminds me of the saying: 'Instead of being fired by my employer, I fired my employer and they are no longer allowed to work with me, so I left'.
- circlefavshape 4y agoA company is a legal fiction, and cannot be loyal. People can be loyal, and often are
- pkkm 4y agoWhy is this on the front page? This website is supposed to be for topics that gratify intellectual curiosity, not a second Reddit.
- el_don_almighty 4y agoYour 'political capital' = company loyalty in difficult times and this is why you should invest and cultivate in this intangible asset over time. Successful project completion is necessary for growing your political capital (PC) but not sufficient. Unfortunately, PC requires a complex mix of social engagement, tribal acceptance, and cross-organizational support that unfortunately comes down to memorable likeability. "I refuse to suck up or become a schmoozer," I hear you say. That certainly is a common choice and it comes with certain daily freedoms and potentially some long-term negatives. These social constructs are true for all groups of humans and have been for thousands of years. It's not unique to the business environment. This is also why today's HN discussion examples of betrayal to the social norms reflect our sense of moral offense. Arbitrarily firing people feels wrong because it IS wrong. Growing your political capital by expanding your social engagement and service network doesn't guarantee safety in a crisis, but it certainly increases the odds of remaining in the herd of survivors.