3 ms·
> Residents and some local legislators argue that the industry’s footprint in the region is expanding too much, too fast and in the wrong places, posing potenti
by mschuster91 4y ago
> Residents and some local legislators argue that the industry’s footprint in the region is expanding too much, too fast and in the wrong places, posing potential risks to the surrounding environment — and, in some cases, creating noise from cooling fans that disrupt neighborhoods such as Browne’s.
Sounds to me like a case of plain bad zoning. Here in Germany, no way that would slide for new zoning - you can't zone noise-generating industry next to residential or mixed zone areas, you need a buffer (usually either undeveloped land or offices) between them.
> But the ordinance exempts air conditioners, which are what the data center cooling systems and exhaust fans technically are.
And that one a case of plain bad noise emissions regulations.
As usual, regulation is widely seen as "why do we need it"... until it affects people personally and all of a sudden they see why regulation is needed. Or to put it bluntly: Who would have thought that a face-eating leopard eats faces?
- xyst 4y agoThese are only symptoms ("bad zoning", " bad noise emissions regulations", ...) of the underlying cause: car centric designed American cities
- mschuster91 4y agoWhile there definitely are issues related to zoning and (from an European POV) utterly brain-dead car centrism - the issue at hand doesn't have to do anything with car centrism, data centers these days are (in-)famous for barely requiring any employment that needs presence of employees and associated car traffic.
- dpkirchner 4y agoI think it's a symptom of the same problem. We've already devalued quality of life by embracing car centrism, so we may as well let noisy DCs set up anywhere.
- linuxftw 4y agoProperty rights could solve this without 'regulation.'
- rsynnott 4y agoCan you detail how this would work?
- linuxftw 4y agoHere's a quick summary: [1]. Or for a longer treatise [2]. Basically, property owners enjoyed certain rights prior to the new data center construction that the data center is infringing upon. 1: https://mises.org/wire/when-pollution-violation-property-rights https://mises.org/wire/when-pollution-violation-property-rig... 2: https://mises.org/library/law-property-rights-and-air-pollution https://mises.org/library/law-property-rights-and-air-pollut...
- tzs 4y agoSo I have a factory and want to emit a lot of air pollution but I'm in a place that uses Mises/Rothbard style property rights to deal with pollution. What do I do? Simple. I make my smokestacks really tall so the pollution is emitted very high into the air and has dispersed massively before some of it reaches any particular property. All the other factory owners do that too both locally and far away. Someone comes after me for violating their property rights by polluting their air...and I get off because they can't prove causality. Yes, my factory emitted pollutant X, but so did hundreds of other factories both near mine and hundreds of miles away and everywhere in between. They can't prove that any detectable amount of my pollution actually ended up in their air.
- tzs 4y agoExempting air conditioners was not necessarily bad regulation for a residential area. Most of the time your air conditioner is not going to bother your neighbors despite being louder than what is normally allowed because most of the time when you need your air condition the neighbors won't hear it because they are also using their air conditioners. What they missed was that business air conditioning needs are different and they might run air conditioners at times when no residents would be doing so and that businesses might a lot of air conditioners.