14 ms·
As always, these discussions get brigaded by trolls so it's no wonder lots of comments were hidden. However, several hidden comments were, as far as I could te
by jeroenhd 4y ago
As always, these discussions get brigaded by trolls so it's no wonder lots of comments were hidden.
However, several hidden comments were, as far as I could tell, made with good intent. That does create an impression that certain opinions are not welcome. The argument for hiding these comments seems to be that they've already been used in other discussions (i.e. "opt-out is illegal under GDPR" being used in a discussion about opt-in/opt-out design despite not being mentioned in that thread before).
When I read the comments by the Go people, it looks like the implementation of opt-out telemetry has already been decided on. Objections like "have you checked if that's even legal" are ignored with a simple "I'm not a lawyer". As rsc puts it, "This is a technical discussion, not a negotiation.".
The discussion is clearly set up wrong and I doubt it will matter in the end, now. The Github discussion is focused on technical implementation, with the moral discussion already having been decided upon; that way, people with arguments against telemetry have no place to voice their concerns. Maybe the moderators simply couldn't imagine being anti-telemetry or maybe they don't consider the position relevant, but this approach was going to stress out the moderators and cause unproductive discussion from the very start.
Personally, I'm somewhat disappointed (but not surprised in the least) that this is being suggested, but I suppose this is what one should expect when running any kind of program from Google (or Microsoft, for that matter). You simply can't trust these companies and the open source developers that work for them to respect your privacy.
I have to say, though, the proposal doesn't seem to take the risk of bad data injection seriously. I myself would definitely run the theoretical AdNauseam style fork of Go if the team behind the tool choose to go through with an opt-out mechanism.