4 ms·
> There were definitely comments that got quite heated and probably fell outside good discourse practices, largely because people are very passionate about priv
by arp242 4y ago
> There were definitely comments that got quite heated and probably fell outside good discourse practices, largely because people are very passionate about privacy and also tend to get very upset when they feel betrayed.
We're supposed to be adults, not 13 year olds. I'm not perfect either and a jerk at times – most people are – and that's okay, but I'm not making excuses for it. Have some standards.
Most of the hidden comments were hugely disrespectful and provided no argument or anything of value. If you start comparing opt-out telemetry to rape then you're simply a jerk (yes, really: https://i.imgur.com/eLVs9ev.png https://i.imgur.com/eLVs9ev.png) I don't care about "yeah but people have strong feelings". I'm tired of excuses for jerkery; I find this enabling of it even more egregious than the jerkery itself. I have strong feelings about a lot of things, but I also manage to keep them in check most of the time on account of being an adult with some standards. Nowhere is this as easy as in online discussions, because you can literally step away from the computer at any time and come back to it an hour or day later.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jeroenhd 4y agoPersonally, I found the link between sexual assault and tracking to be expected: they're the two scenarios in which consent even gets mentioned or discussed in daily life. When it comes to sex, it's critical and mentioned all the time in media and internet posts; in tracking, it's in the forms of "I consent" buttons on every other badly designed web page. In how many other places will you find a consent form? Medical procedures, perhaps? Obviously, Google's data hunger is worlds less harmful than sexual assault, but I think the difference in how consent is treated is actually relevant for the discussion. When it comes to sex, it has taken many decades (or even centuries) of hard work, but at this point society is finally starting to get the message across: you don't have consent if it's not given explicitly. Society is still in the process of getting everyone on the same page here (sadly) but progress is being made. While compiler data collection isn't as important, the idea that consent means "you haven't tried saying no enough" is completely absurd. This means is no good comparison for consent because every comparison where a normal person deals with consent will make the suggestion opt-out seem horrible. Most actions happening to a person without consent are or should be illegal, with perhaps lawful arrests and the judicial system being the exception. If we, as a society, really do value explicit consent, we shouldn't mix and match what is and isn't consent based on what serves us. Consent is important in software too, even if some companies or developers don't see it that way. Google devs especially should know this. People I know have felt a real sense of violation when they found out how intensely Google tracks its users. I've seen people get creeped and grossed out by their phones because they were asked to review a restaurant they were near, realising that Google knew exactly where they were and how long, and that the tracking had gone on for much longer before that. I, myself, felt a little violated when I found out how much data Microsoft's dotnet tool has been sending out after getting "consent" during an automated install and first use, despite knowing the data can't track me down as a person. The impact may be incomparable, but developers seem to severely underestimate the emotional impact their blatant disregard for other people's privacy can really have just because they don't feel the same way. Perhaps another way the comparison is more apt than it would seem at first glance.
- arp242 4y agoPeople can choose to use Go or they can choose not to use Go. They can choose to disable telemetry if they do use Go. Nothing is forced upon anyone. Rape is. You do not choose to not get raped. The entire premise of rape is that any choice is taken away. You can write long philosophical stories about it and none of that matters anyway. The accusation is pretty clear, and it should be pretty obvious to everyone that going off on a rant about "this is as dirty as rape!" is unconstructive and inappropriate. Furthermore there are countless things that happen to everyone every day without their explicit consent and it's far less valued than you think it is. It would be unworkable if we did. Did I consent to air pollution? Noise pollution? Billboards next to the road? The laws of my society? Having a passport of the country where I happened to have been born? You replying to my comment? People emailing me? In practice consent is often either implied and assumed, or doesn't operate at the individual level (e.g. it operates via voting).
- jeroenhd 4y agoI don't think the accusation is "this is as dirty as rape" is made at all. It's easy to overreact when someone brings up a topic like sexual assault because nobody in their right mind likes to be associated with such horrendous behaviour. However, the framework society has set up around consent is still useful. Consent is implied (or assumed) in most day to day events. However, privacy law in the EU has brought the topic of consent into the internet and onto computers, whether you want it or not. That's because digital privacy and all manner of things it accompanies has been regulated because the industry has failed to implement the necessary safeguard by itself. You may feel like such telemetry doesn't need explicit consent, like you or me commenting on posts here, and that's a valid opinion to have. Others viscerally disagree. I personally think digital consent is a field of computer ethics that has been ignored for way too long. I'm very happy with the GDPR and only wish government would start enforcing privacy laws more often. You're free to disagree with me and I can understand your position if you do. For those that do consider software tracking something that requires consent, there is a real emotional impact to seeing your privacy be violated by software and devices you otherwise trust. Ignoring that because you disagree with the underlying notion can only lead to misunderstanding and exaggerated flame wars. It'll also generate distrust and friction within your community. To all of the points you have listed where consent is usually implied or assumed, there are groups that disagree. Air and noise pollution are regulated for a good reason; laws around those are often vague because these topics are extremely situational. I do actually think most billboards should be banned from public spaces for both ethical and safety reasons. There are large groups that consider the laws in the places they've been born in to be unjust and are angry that they're subjected under them, and demand (usually through a misinterpreted or made up legal basis) that they and their peers never agreed to any of those rules. There are even laws in place about who is allowed to email you, because you did not express a desire to receive ads from random companies, though enforcement is usually completely absent. For what it's worth, I 100% believe that the author behind this proposal is well-intentioned. The proposed methodology has been carefully constructed to respect privacy as much as possible. I also completely understand the wish for opt-out as most people simply won't choose to act on requests for opting in. However, a project like Go isn't run by a single person, and the company that does run it cannot be trusted when it comes to privacy concerns.