3 ms·
'Making aware' does not require withholding service. I tend to think any line of reasoning that begins, "this is such a fundamental threat to our survival that
by gojomo 15y ago
'Making aware' does not require withholding service.
I tend to think any line of reasoning that begins, "this is such a fundamental threat to our survival that normal practice must be discarded" is a signifier of panicked groupthink, most common in war and campaign season, but that's just me.
As of today, Wikipedia is an always-on information utility. As of Thursday, it will be also understood as an occasional lobbyist/information-withholding-disciplinarian.
And I hadn't thought about the effect on medical/safety reference during the blackout period until earlier today. Given the large numbers of professionals and laypeople who rely on Wikipedia (far more than they should!), it's possible someone somewhere will die because of the blackout.
updated to add:
The health risk applies via the Reddit blackout, too. For some people, this is the support community from which they get urgent life guidance. See for example: http://www.reddit.com/r/bestof/comments/nzfow/my_life_was_saved_this_morning_by_reddit/?limit=500 http://www.reddit.com/r/bestof/comments/nzfow/my_life_was_sa...
- lnguyen 15y ago"It's possible someone somewhere will die" That's a bit extreme isn't it? But if Wikipedia (or any other site) is that important of a resource, imagine what would happen if it disappeared as a result of being blacklisted by SOPA/PIPA or an equivalent piece of legislation. They're perfectly in their right to advocate against a misguided effort that could threaten and impair their ability to function/exist.
- gojomo 15y agoYou're presenting a 'false dilemma': http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma (link may be broken due to political protest) The only people currently taking Wikipedia offline are Wikipedians themselves. Anything else is hypothetical and unlikely.
- lnguyen 15y agoHypothetical and unlikely? You're talking about legislation that is supported (if not written by) groups that don't exactly have a sparkling track record of being reasonable and not abusing any bit of power that they're given or feel that they're entitled to. Take the Universal/Megaupload fiasco for example. The Wikipedians are taking action so that "unlikely" isn't even a possibility. And while Wikipedia may be a central resource, it's not the only or primary source of information (see all the citations). At most it'll be an inconvenience but one that will prove a point.
- gillygize 15y agoThat is a good point, and I agree with your argument that this boycott is a significant turning point for Wikipedia and other websites. If we think about the reason that the boycott exists, however, which is the danger that this legislation will allow Wikipedia to be taken offline without adequate recourse, then suggesting that "it is possible that someone somewhere" will die because of the blackout could similarly lead to an argument like, "if SOPA is passed, it is possible that someone somewhere will die" due to the Wikipedia (or some other website) being taken offline.
- gojomo 15y agoYou're right, but the chain of events for SOPA to kill someone requires it to pass (mixed probability), to survive an inevitable court challenge (unlikely in my opinion), and be enforced against a Wikipedia-like site (also unlikely in my opinion). For the blackout to do harm, one of the many thousands of people searching for reliable info tomorrow just has to miss crucial information they would have otherwise quickly found. And it won't be Representative Lamar Smith, the MPAA, or the Attorney General blocking readers from getting that info – it will be Wikipedia itself. I personally am most impressed by those who keep providing the services that they think are right, without regard to the edicts of misguided lawmakers, until the moment men with guns show up and give you no other choice. "You can have my Internet when you pry the servers from my cold, dead hands." Not, "Oh, yeah? We'll show you, we're taking our toys and going home today. Nyah-nyah."
- jacalata 15y agoI personally am most impressed by those who see the possiblity of people arriving with guns (or whatever hyperbolic event you wish to imagine) and then work to avoid it /today/, rather than pretending that the future is out of their hands.
- icebraining 15y agoOr they can just use a mirror, like http://encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/ http://encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/
- gojomo 15y agoI hope Google promotes such Wikipedia mirrors during the blackout as a fallback. (Google usually seems to downrank them.)