4 ms·
It's still a racket. For decades, New York State had state-run kosher food inspection. But in 2000, there was a lawsuit by one group of kosher butchers against
by Animats 4y ago
It's still a racket. For decades, New York State had state-run kosher food inspection. But in 2000, there was a lawsuit by one group of kosher butchers against another group of kosher butchers over which one got to define what was kosher. This went to Federal court, and the ruling was that the US courts could not decide the issue, because to do so either way would literally be an establishment of religion.[1] Now the state just has a labeling requirement and keeps a database of who says their label indicates kosher.
Israel has a whole "my label is more kosher than your label" thing going, mostly in Jerusalem.[2] This pushed the price of kosher meat way up. There was a reform plan to standardize kosher regulation, and it got to within two weeks of going live. But as part of the coalition agreement Netanyahu negotiated to take power, it's been put off for six months and is probably dead until Israel gets a new prime minister.[3]
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2000/08/04/nyregion/judge-voids-law-certifying-kosher-food.html https://www.nytimes.com/2000/08/04/nyregion/judge-voids-law-...
[2] https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/what-israelis-want-kosher-food-at-affordable-prices/ https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/what-israelis-want-kosher-fo...
[3] https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/shas-minister-signs-order-canceling-kashrut-reform-law-passed-by-knesset/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/shas-minister-s...
- cik 4y ago> Israel has a whole "my label is more kosher than your label" thing going, mostly in Jerusalem. This is at best an over-simplification. Many of us use a specific certification due to legitimate differences in tradition (מסורת) as opposed to "blue stampy is better than red stampy". I find it increasingly frustrating that frequently, we're seen as a monoculture, when we're not. I say this living in Israel, and not Jerusalem, not that it matters.
- skissane 4y agoGoing on a bit of a tangent - in the context of what you are saying, does מסורת (masoret, “tradition”) mean the same thing as מנהג (minhag, “custom”) - or would the latter be the wrong word to use here?
- cik 4y agoNo, they're different - apologies if I'm not clear, or making assumptions in the following! Amongst most Sepharadim we have the מסורת that Swordfish is kosher - there is a discussion about the relative Kashruth (Kosherness) in the Shulchan Aruch. But only amongst (some) Moroccans, and Yemenites, is there an actual מנהג of eating Swordfish. Syrians, Libyans, Egyptians, etc don't. There are other examples, but I always like this one.
- skissane 4y agoThanks, I think I understand what you are saying. Some things you believe are acceptable in theory but you wouldn’t actually do them in practice, other things you actually do in practice. About your example, what happens if a Yemenite Jew invites a Syrian Jew to dinner, and serves swordfish? Is the Syrian allowed to eat it?
- cik 4y agoThis is an excellent example.. and my life ;). There are all sorts of things that I don't serve Ashkenazim (Europeans) that are kosher for us North Africans. In particular, I'm fond of Arak (and Bouja). I have Arak from Turkey (Raki), it's made with crushed grape seeds; I have Arak from Lebanon which includes non-wine based grape alcohol. These are not Kosher for Ashkenazi, but are kosher for (most) North African and Middle Eastern Jews. From a Jewish Law (halachic) point of view, that person isn't allowed to consume these things. But moreover (and logically), I actually can't serve it to them. So, there are multiple layers to these things.
- skissane 4y agoIt sounds like while the difference between מסורת and מנהג is important in theory, it is less so in practice - whether you have a מסורת that you don’t eat it or just a מנהג that you don’t eat it, either way you don’t eat it. I was kind of guessing that maybe a מנהג might allow greater exceptions than a מסורת, but now I’m guessing I guessed wrong. But what happens when a couple get married from different communities which have different מסורת or מנהג - can one spouse adopt those of the other? Must they each continue to follow their respective inheritances? And what is inherited by their children? Sorry, I hope you don’t mind me asking all these questions-it is just a topic which fires my curiosity.