2 ms·
> China doesn't have the industrial ability to build a navy strong enough to counter the US Navy . . . and, yet, . . . As China Expands Its Fleets, US Analyst
by defrost 4y ago
> China doesn't have the industrial ability to build a navy strong enough to counter the US Navy . . .
and, yet, . . .
As China Expands Its Fleets, US Analysts Call for Catch-up Efforts
The disparity has prompted U.S. maritime experts to call for a "Ships Act" comparable to the recently enacted "Chips Act" that supports the return of chip manufacturing to the United States.
..
Bryan McGrath, managing director at The FerryBridge Group, told VOA Mandarin that the shipbuilding bases of the U.S. and China are simply not comparable.
"The Chinese industrial base is a behemoth, and the U.S. shipbuilding industrial base is freakishly undersized as a function of the size of America's economy and its influence in the world," McGrath said.
As of 2020, the U.S. Navy had 297 battle force ships, according to a report by the Congressional Research Service. China surpassed the U.S. as the world's largest navy with an inventory of about 355 vessels, according to a U.S. Defense Department report released in 2021. The Office of Naval Intelligence (ONI) projects that China will have 400 battle force ships by 2025 and 425 by 2030.
https://www.voanews.com/a/as-china-expands-its-fleets-us-analysts-call-for-catch-up-efforts-/6746352.html https://www.voanews.com/a/as-china-expands-its-fleets-us-ana...
- doodlebugging 4y agoThis is true and I actually read that report so I obviously forgot about all that. The one thing that is not covered well there is the type of ships in the Chinese versus US Navy. Even with fewer ships we have more tonnage. A large part of the Chinese Navy consists of coastal defense assets which are smaller vessels. With that said they do have excellent anti-ship defenses and are gaming to be able to manage a conflict where we bring our carriers and air assets to bear. https://www.defenceprocurementinternational.com/features/maritime/china-now-boats-the-largest-navy-in-the-world https://www.defenceprocurementinternational.com/features/mar... This is the reason that we have inked defense agreements in the region. Spreading the costs of defending the free passage of goods through the South China Sea with other nations allows us an opportunity to build a larger, more modern navy and buys time. We should be investing in naval assets too since some of the most recent programs ended up with us buying fewer vessels than originally contracted and with those vessels being ill suited for the original task they were designed to handle. As the VOA article mentions, we will likely run into problems mobilizing for a ship-building effort since it already is hard enough to find skilled workers (welders, etc) for industries that employ most of them today like the pipeline and oil and gas industry. A return to teaching trades in high school would be a great start that would pay dividends nearly immediately as the first class graduates into the work force. Feel free to double check everything I posted. I could be totally wrong about any or all of it. Thanks.
- defrost 4y agoNo drama. I'm Australian and aware that China buys from our state alone (Western Australia) 16x more iron ore per annum than the US has ever managed to produce in a year .. this figure alone undercuts many arguments about China's perceived industrial capacity. They are easily capable (for example) of producing 14x more shit steel than the max US steel capacity .. while at the same time producing 2x the max US quality steel capacity. Any China-US naval engagement could very well see a new strategic inflection in any case. Theres's been ironclad supremacy, an age of battleships, and a time of carriers as king. China has put up (and taken down) several videos of highly coordinated unmanned drone swarms, in the air, on water, under water. Very large swarms of drones that are nothing but sensors, engines and explosives that can react and maneuver are very asymmetric in cost.