5 ms·
Your right to free speech ends where their right to free and fair elections begins. There is nothing fair about a state vote corrupted by voices outside of the
by Dalewyn 4y ago
Your right to free speech ends where their right to free and fair elections begins.
There is nothing fair about a state vote corrupted by voices outside of the state, let alone outside of the country.
- djbusby 4y agoA voice isn't corruption is it? If I talk to my uncle in NH about this bill am I subverting democracy or engaging in it?
- Dalewyn 4y agoIf you're just discussing it with him, that's fine. If he specifically asks for your opinion, you're fine to give it to him. But under no circumstances should you try to unilaterally influence or coerce him in some way. That's overstepping the line.
- cmurf 4y agoThat would be true regardless of residency. A NH resident doesn't gain the right to harass NH residents into voting a certain way. What line?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- manuelmoreale 4y ago> But under no circumstances should you try to unilaterally influence Why do you believe that to be true? I'm asking as an outside observer, I don't live in the US so I have no real interest in all this. But, since things are interconnected, and a state isn't just some lonely abstract entity, isn't in your interest to try push for things that are good overall? Why shouldn't I try to convince people that a certain change is a good thing, even if that change doesn't influence me directly?
- Dalewyn 4y ago>But, since things are interconnected, and a state isn't just some lonely abstract entity, isn't in your interest to try push for things that are good overall? States are separate for a reason, the people of each state want to do things their own way. For the things we can all agree nationally there is the federal government, but for everything else it's separated at the state level so we step on as few toes as possible. Spamming a New Hampshire state representative when you aren't in New Hampshire, let alone not in the US, subverts democracy by violating state and possibly country lines.
- manuelmoreale 4y agoAgain, I personally couldn’t care less about the US politics and I certainly won’t bother spamming your politicians. Still, to push your reasoning, what if I’m not in NH but I plan to move there in the near future from a neighboring state? What if I’m planning to move there from another country? What if the move is not certain but I’m just considering the possibility? Also, what if I simply think something is a good thing and I want to help promote it?
- htag 4y agoAre you aware of how common this type of behavior is? Where are you purposing to draw the line? Should we not even discuss local and state elections on the internet to prevent outside voices from swaying the views of voters? Should we not report on these elections? A free and fair election is about ensuring that eligible voters are informed, that they have access to the ballot box, and that those ballots are accurately counted.
- Dalewyn 4y agoIt's fine to discuss others' affairs, but actually going as far as to contact state representatives (read: spam them) when you aren't their constituent over stuff like this is a subversion of democracy. You may or may not like what's going on in New Hampshire, but if you aren't a New Hampshire resident with voting rights you don't get to have any say in their affairs.
- leereeves 4y agoI'd support that principle if outside corporations like Microsoft and Adobe weren't allowed to lobby either.
- AnthonyMouse 4y ago"Speech is corruption" is a bad take.
- t0suj4 4y agoI remember my mother telling me a story of how she was dragged for interrogation after undercover cops overheard her and her friend talking about political situation in communist Poland. It's a dangerous territory you're trying to propose.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- whateveracct 4y agoThis feels more like an identity-politics-adjacent opinion. I don't think it's as unarguable as you're acting like to say that such a thing is corrupt. It's at worst an open question.
- walterbell 4y agoDo New Hampshire residents read HN?
- Dalewyn 4y agoMaybe, maybe not. Wouldn't surprise me if there are at least a few. What OP and the article are asking is for someone in, say, Belgium or Canada or Texas to go and contact a New Hampshire state representative about a strictly New Hampshire state affair. Talk about making unnecessary and inappropriate noise for New Hampshire's democracy.
- soco 4y agoDemocracy by obscurity, a new concept.