4 ms·
>Your help is needed. With all due respect, speaking as someone not in New Hampshire, your (and the article's) request to me and others like myself is a subver
by Dalewyn 4y ago
>Your help is needed.
With all due respect, speaking as someone not in New Hampshire, your (and the article's) request to me and others like myself is a subversion of democracy.
This New Hampshire state bill is being deliberated in the New Hampshire state legislature, to be eventually voted on by New Hampshire state legislators voted in by and representing the people of the state of New Hampshire.
As a strictly state matter, any influence from outside the state of New Hampshire is a subversion of democracy in the state.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway892238 4y agoSometimes democracy gets things wrong. States have historically liked to do fucked up shit and then hide behind "states' rights".
- Dalewyn 4y ago[flagged]
- tb84 4y agojesus dude get a grip
- steve_mcdougall 4y ago[flagged]
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoThe people of New Hampshire and the United States have voted to protect free speech including by people who live outside of the state and the union. Corporations from other states and countries who don't like this bill make use of that. Proponents can too.
- Dalewyn 4y agoYour right to free speech ends where their right to free and fair elections begins. There is nothing fair about a state vote corrupted by voices outside of the state, let alone outside of the country.
- djbusby 4y agoA voice isn't corruption is it? If I talk to my uncle in NH about this bill am I subverting democracy or engaging in it?
- Dalewyn 4y agoIf you're just discussing it with him, that's fine. If he specifically asks for your opinion, you're fine to give it to him. But under no circumstances should you try to unilaterally influence or coerce him in some way. That's overstepping the line.
- cmurf 4y agoThat would be true regardless of residency. A NH resident doesn't gain the right to harass NH residents into voting a certain way. What line?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- manuelmoreale 4y ago> But under no circumstances should you try to unilaterally influence Why do you believe that to be true? I'm asking as an outside observer, I don't live in the US so I have no real interest in all this. But, since things are interconnected, and a state isn't just some lonely abstract entity, isn't in your interest to try push for things that are good overall? Why shouldn't I try to convince people that a certain change is a good thing, even if that change doesn't influence me directly?
- 4y ago
- gameman144 4y agoIt's not asking us to falsify votes or commit fraud or anything, just asking for people to sing the virtues of this approach. As an analogy, say Colorado passed a law that New Hampshire is also considering passing. In that case would you consider it interference for people from Colorado to speak in New Hampshire saying "You guys shouldn't pass this, it worked out poorly for us in Colorado"?
- Dalewyn 4y ago>would you consider it interference Generally speaking: Yes.
- gameman144 4y agoInteresting. I'm curious what you'd say the boundary here is? Should people not be allowed to read those opinions, or should writers outside the state not be allowed to write them? Likewise, what scale of input on elections is considered too small to ban? Is criticizing the policies or politics of other states allowed at all? I could not disagree with your view more, but I'm genuinely curious how you're thinking about this issue and what you'd want to see in practice.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoTrade groups in the US routinely try to influence state legislation outside the state where they are domiciled, and sometimes outside the country. For example, the Business Software Alliance (BSA), founded by Microsoft, operates in over 30 countries. It engages in both lobbying and litigation, around the US and around the world. Individual companies engage in lobbying outside of trade groups as well. https://www.computerweekly.com/news/2240234078/Government-open-standards-the-curious-case-of-Microsoft-and-the-minister https://www.computerweekly.com/news/2240234078/Government-op... The irony of the parent comment is that "tech" companies, the ones that disseminate proprietary software, have done and continue to do more to "subvert democracy" than any individual in history has ever done, and they do this more or less free from civil liability or criminal prosecution. This bill is interesting because, as it currently reads, it does not force the state to use non-proprietary software. It is not stopping the state from purchasing Microsoft software licenses, for example. Instead it prohibits the state from forcing the residents of NH to use proprietary software in order to interact with the state agencies: "21-W:1 Mandatory Use of Proprietary Software Prohibited. No person in the state of New Hampshire shall be required to use proprietary software for any interaction with the government, including, but not limited to: the filing or payment of taxes, remote appearance for court proceedings, the taking of standardized tests or the completion of coursework by school students, applying for or receiving unemployment benefits, or other similar benefits, unless the government agency has determined that the proprietary software is the only means available for the required interaction. In such cases of proprietary software use, the agency shall post a notice of its determination and the use of proprietary software on the agency's website." This is a topic that comes up on HN with moderate frequency. For example, a website tries to force the user to use a specific client, which is effectively proprietary software under the control of a "tech" company. The client might be a Big Tech advertising-sponsored web browser that no one except Big Tech employees ever audits, modifies or compiles, regardless of whether the source code is available. It might be a closed mobile app that pins TLS certificates to stop anyone from observing what data it records about its user and sends to the "tech" company, sometimes called "phoning home" to the "mothership". The website might use something like Cloudflare in the name of "protection" primarily to restrict clients to a certain browsers controlled by Big Tech that can be leveraged against users (ad targets) for data collection, surveillance and advertising. https://www.cloudflare.com/solutions/protect-websites-applications/ https://www.cloudflare.com/solutions/protect-websites-applic...