4 ms·
> The study included 2,998 children in kindergarten through third grade at 47 New York City schools. The schools—which serve a racially diverse group of student
by neilv 4y ago
> The study included 2,998 children in kindergarten through third grade at 47 New York City schools. The schools—which serve a racially diverse group of students, most of whom are from low-income families—were randomized to receive either the simple or complex treatment.
Was this selection because some low-income families need this kind of treatment more than affluent ones? Or represent a diversity of racial backgrounds against which the treatment can be better tested?
Was it a factor that they were cheap subjects? Or maybe unlikely to know any lawyers?
As a kid, our (modest, Catholic) grade school participated in a lengthy toothpaste study. The incentive, AFAIK, was you got free toothpaste for your family (and I seem to recall some free toothbrushes).
As an adult now, aware of some history and societal dynamics, if I ever have kids, and they came home with an experiment subject consent form, one of the questions on my mind would be "Are the children of the wealthy and connected also in this subject cohort?"
- PaulHoule 4y agoI am sure there is some study somewhere that samples rich people rather than others.
- jonahbenton 4y agoI don't know anything about this study, but am a lifelong NYC resident whose kids have gone through the public school system and who also has been directly involved as a "parent leader" in some DOE programs. With some confidence I posit the answers to the questions are a) very much yes b) yes c) n/a d) no. NYC DOE is an incredible organization that serves both the extremely wealthy and the extremely needy. There are schools where the majority of families are millionaires and the quality of the education and attention is competitive with $50k/year private schools. But there is much, much more pervasive need. Some estimates put 1/10 of the total attending population as homeless. 70% of the attending population are on some form of financial assistance. The range of services the DOE offers are astonishing. For various reasons they do NOT include anything that constitutes medical care, but they will regularly run studies that involve making medical resources available or provide some medical intervention. The needs in some areas are so great. As an efficient deliverer of in person services, there is no better organization than the DOE. It is very likely that most of the students in this study have never been- and never would otherwise be- to a dentist. They very likely get 1-2 meals a day from their school year round. They in many cases spend more waking hours in their school than at home. High poverty classrooms can be chaotic, but they often are much less chaotic than whatever home is. Consent was collected, to be sure- DOE is extremely careful about this. DOE legal is extremely aggressive because they are often sued- mostly by students of means but also by advocacy organizations, of which there are many. Very likely NYU was offered the option of where to do the study. They could have picked the Upper East Side or Tribeca- wealthy neighborhoods where kids will regularly attend boutique dental practices- but then what would they learn? The kids there are already getting sealants and so forth.
- throwayyy479087 4y agoSecond us. One of the most amazing things about New York is that it has a functioning school system unlike places on the West Coast. Stuy, ps101, bx science are some of the best schools in the country
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThis is a bit of a silly take in my opinion. This bit, "The schools—which serve a racially diverse group of students, most of whom are from low-income families", sounds just like editorializing to me. That is, it was just a test in NY public schools, not like they specifically sought out low income or underperforming schools, it's just that public schools in NYC have a much higher rate of low income families.
- Spivak 4y agoI don’t think it’s editorializing, there are plenty of school systems, public and private, that don’t fit this mold. My HS class had maybe 20 of 250 students whose families’ weren’t firmly middle class or above with a good 50 who came from the rich feeder school who were “new Mercedes for 16th birthday rich.” Realizing my family was lower-middle class was a bit of a shell shock for 13 year old me.
- harvey9 4y agoThere's a long history of unethical research on people who are not well-equipped to do their own cost/benefit analysis, nevermind the famous cases where people were not even asked if they wanted to take part.