4 ms·
Any group who becomes part of the system will then act to protect the system. I mean, judges are supposed to grant warrants for things already, yet we continual
by giantg2 4y ago
Any group who becomes part of the system will then act to protect the system. I mean, judges are supposed to grant warrants for things already, yet we continually see stories of them just rubber stamping requests, or police lying to obtain them. I assume that system would suffer similar issues.
- ethbr0 4y agoThat's why you have limited terms of service and randomly turn over membership.
- teddyh 4y agoLike politicians?
- ethbr0 4y agoAt least in Congress and many executive positions, they are neither term-limited nor randomly selected.
- giantg2 4y agoSure, term limits can be good in many ways, and random selection can reduce the people chosing it for the wrong reasons. But who is going to give up their career to be a citizen watcher for just a few years? Likewise, random selection may not yield a cohort with the correct capacity to properly administer the system. I'd almost think the better solution is to use mini-juries to evaluate warrants so the judges aren't just rubber stamping. At least then the judge has to explain the situation and points of law, and aren't the only one making the decision.
- ethbr0 4y ago> But who is going to give up their career to be a citizen watcher for just a few years? A Citizen. Rights and responsibilities, etc. > Likewise, random selection may not yield a cohort with the correct capacity to properly administer the system. Of course. That's the downside of random cohorts. But compared to the alternatives (that we actively gripe about), occasional lack of ability is the lesser of two evils. This would also be lessened if there weren't a way to get out of it. Don't want to serve when your number is called? Feel free to be a citizen of another country.
- giantg2 4y ago"A Citizen. Rights and responsibilities, etc." Haha OK. Why not do that for police and judge positions too? Then you'd eliminate the need for this. "That's the downside of random cohorts. But compared to the alternatives (that we actively gripe about), occasional lack of ability is the lesser of two evils." That's one opinion. "This would also be lessened if there weren't a way to get out of it." In one way I agree. In practice I don't. Forced incompetence is generally going to lead to really poor outcomes. By theway, how are Putin's conscripts doing?
- ethbr0 4y ago> Why not do that for police and judge positions too? Because police and judge positions require specialized skill sets and training, and both have access to the force of government, which would seem to merit a higher minimum bar of professionalism. Oversight's "feature" is that there are fewer negative consequences when it's inappropriately applied. > By theway, how are Putin's conscripts doing? You're arguing Putin's conscripts are an example of when a country's best and brightest aren't allowed to excuse themselves from random selection?
- landemva 4y ago> mini-juries to evaluate warrant Typically this is a 'grand jury' in USA.
- giantg2 4y agoThat's just for filing charges, getting an arrest, right? This would be for search warrants.
- wpietri 4y agoEvery system suffers abuse issues. Which is why I think we should look for systems that minimize that.
- deely3 4y agoSeriously, do we have any idea how such systems will work? Is it even possible to build such system?
- wpietri 4y agoOf course we do. Corruption and anti-corruption are well-studied topics. There are wide differentials in corruption levels across space and time. E.g.: https://risk-indexes.com/global-corruption-index/ https://risk-indexes.com/global-corruption-index/ Incorruptible systems aren't possible, but there's a wide library of patterns that make corruption easier and harder, and there are surely more to discover.
- mistermann 4y ago> Any group who becomes part of the system will then act to protect the system. As a True/False binary, sure, but the magnitude of the phenomenon is a function of the quality of the system. As flaws are realized, the system can be improved. Consider how many known flaws there are in our various systems, and then observe (in an as unbiased as possible frame of mind as possible) how we (everyone (including us here on HN), but especially those with various forms of power) respond to realizations of these flaws: do we fix them, or do we engage in rhetoric, propaganda, post-hoc rationalization/justification, etc? > I mean, judges are supposed to grant warrants for things already, yet we continually see stories of them just rubber stamping requests, or police lying to obtain them. If this displeases us, shall we blame ourselves or Mother Nature? Or, not even think about it? > I assume that system would suffer similar issues. You may be right. Alternatively, you may not. There's only one way to (possibly) find out, but it is certainly not mandatory that we find such things out.....well, unless we desire certain outcomes, then it might be.
- giantg2 4y ago"As flaws are realized, the system can be improved." One man's "flaw" is another man's "tool". The people in power exploiting the flaw are unlikely to fix it.
- mistermann 4y agoUnder all approaches tried so far perhaps, but there are LOTS of approaches that we haven't tried. Heck, very few people can even get their mind to even consider alternative approaches, and actually trying things is a lot harder than that relatively simple task.