7 ms·
Leonardo noted link between gravity and acceleration centuries before Einstein
- technocratius 4y agoGreat article, thanks for sharing. This was also interesting to read: 'One of the sketches showed an isosceles right triangle with "Equatione di Moti" written along the hypotenuse. Gharib was curious about the meaning of the phrase, but it was in old Italian and also written backward in Leonardo's trademark "mirror writing." ' According to Wikipedia[0], one of the hypotheses for his motivation to write like this was to have better recall of the material. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_writing#Notable_examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_writing#Notable_example...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xgstation 4y agoMany great mathematicians and physicists had used time as 4th dimension, but none developed it out into special relativity, even Lorentz has his name on the Lorentz's transformation, but he didn't see a brand new space-time relationship. There is a huge gap between linking something together to writing it down with a mind boggling and fundamentally new theory to reshape how human beings see the universe. That said, all people's work are built on top of predecessors. Without generations work on mathematics before 20 century, Einstein wouldn't have developed GR as well.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoI think it’s safe to say without 5000+ years of mathematically research Einstein wouldn’t have developed GR.
- mr_mitm 4y agoIt's also remarkable that the mathematical tools required for GR were developed just in the few decades before Einstein wrote down his equations.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoYeah there’s definitely some singularity like stuff happening. While we don’t see visibly dramatic evolutions like GR happening, we are making incredible strides on unsolved problems and extravagantly complex discoveries at a blistering pace, so much so that they’re not noteworthy any more.
- sockaddr 4y agoVery true. From the perspective of something like a Tardigrade we are definitely well into a “singularity”. From the perspective of a rock the Tardigrade itself is matter experiencing a “singularity”.
- bognition 4y agoOne way to view things is that GR was obvious to a smart person with good enough tools and that if Einstein wouldn't have discovered it someone else would have soon after.
- mr_mitm 4y agoHmmm, when I studied GR, the consensus was that it came out of nowhere and if it wasn't for Einstein's genius, it would have taken at least a long time until someone else had discovered it. But you make a good point. Ultimately it's an unanswerable question, I guess.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mjthrowaway1 4y agoWhen I studied GR my professor said that Maxwell was close and had he not died young it would’ve been him.
- wnevets 4y ago> Without generations work on mathematics before 20 century, Einstein wouldn't have developed GR as well. "If I have seen further, it is by standing on the shoulders of giants" - Newton I'm sure Einstein would have no problem with applying such a quote to himself.
- jhoechtl 4y agoHe was infamous at being bad at math with hi wife doing some of the math for him. He never recognized her in doing so.
- SantalBlush 4y agoHe wasn't bad at math, but his wife was better at math than he was, and there is a lot of historical evidence suggesting they collaborated on his "miracle year" papers.
- rubyn00bie 4y agoThat’s false he wasn’t bad at math. It’s a (false) myth that’s perpetuated. Before he was years 15 old he’d mastered differential and integral calculus: https://content.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1936731_1936743_1936758,00.html https://content.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28...
- lstodd 4y agoTbh I was taught both in school at about the same age. This doesn't prevent me from kicking the kubernetes can down the road instead of coming up with more general relativity. Maybe it's the lust that's insufficient.
- 8note 4y agoThe low hanging fruit on physics discoveries using current technology is also all taken. The right person at the right place at the right time -- the time is maybe the biggest one. It's not just Einstein who revolutionized physics, his contemporaries did too
- dandanua 4y agoTo make such a significant breakthrough like relativity theory it's not enough to see connections between seemingly unrelated things. You have to have a sufficiently open and free mind to be able to discard beliefs of generations of scientists. Including your own, implanted through instincts.
- loufe 4y agoGreat point and you said it well. Darwin was much the same, many of the ideas he discusses were already out there, but he brought them together in a novel, united, coherent, and compelling way that really made the idea of evolution stand on its own feet.
- zmgsabst 4y agoMost great theories connect existing concepts: Darwin connected the specialization of finches to two bodies of existing work — animal husbandry and the nest hierarchy of biology, by explaining they’re both outcomes of reproductive selection. Einstein connected the idea of Galilean relativity to Maxwell’s equations to explain why Michelson-Morley behaves how it does.
- evv555 4y ago>nest hierarchy of biology Which itself is a derivative of the "great chain of being" ontology which tried to explain the continuous gradation of structures in the world. Ideas like "missing link" appear within this worldview before Darwin's theory[1]. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_chain_of_being#Scala_Naturae_in_evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_chain_of_being#Scala_Nat...
- zinclozenge 4y agoThat's true about Lorentz, although for completeness I just want to point out that the geometric spacetime extension was done by Minkowski.
- scotty79 4y agoWhen I read about special relativity I notice how many equations and concepts had names of other people. It seemed like Einstein combine various observations and ideas into a single coherent framework.
- credit_guy 4y agoWhy centuries before Einstein and not one century before Galileo?
- sdenton4 4y agoOr, for that matter, Newton....
- credit_guy 4y agoI would say that Newton had an insight unprecedented in the history of science: that phenomena as seemingly unrelated as the fall of an apple from a tree and the motion of the moon and planets are caused by the same physical laws. Leonardo does not show any hint of even thinking about this.
- prox 4y agoNot yet anyway. Who know what else is in those notebooks. Slightly /s, but it’s interesting that we still find new observations in his notebooks.
- panda-giddiness 4y agoThe equivalence of gravity and acceleration is one of the major ideas of general relativity. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle
- Trombone12 4y agoBut that is certainly not what is being claimed here. What TFA says is that they think Leonardo correctly realised that falling things accelerate, as opposed to fall with a constant speed as (the ancient) Aristotelian physics prescribed. To go all the way to the (Einsteinian) equivalence principle from that is huffing great man hopium in the extreme: Leonardo is certainly not as user of reference frames, and the equivalence principle simply does not exist without them. Another problem is that he didn't know of inertia, what with being of the Aristotelian school.
- swayvil 4y agoBy "link" they mean "it looks similar". This has been noted since the first goatherd swung a bucket of milk. Right?
- Karellen 4y agoI wonder why the choice to refer to him as "Leonardo", rather than "da Vinci"? Given that the latter appears to be the more common way of referring to him as the author of many of his other works? They don't refer to Einstein as "Albert".
- CamperBob2 4y ago"da Vinci" just means "from (edited, thanks) a town called Vinci." It doesn't actually identify him (even though everyone knows who you're talking about.) It's a cool article but as the comments point out, it's one heck of a stretch to compare these early notes to anything done by Einstein, or even Newton.
- ithkuil 4y agoDa Vinci means "from Vinci" which is a small town near Florence
- bonzini 4y agoNote that "da Vinci" means "from Vinci", a small town outside Florence and roughly 300 km away from Venice.
- robertlagrant 4y agoNote that Leonardo means "lion-like strength" in Italian.
- bromuro 4y agoItalians would recognize “Leo-” as “Lion”. The “-hart” suffix is germanic and few in Italy would know what it literally means.
- Karellen 4y ago> It doesn't actually identify him (even though everyone knows who you're talking about.) Surely if it means that everyone knows who you're talking about, it does actually identify him. Probably more so than "Leonardo" does. There are plenty of famous people called "Leonardo", but only one who is known as "da Vinci".
- cft 4y agoDemocritus and epicureans correctly conjectured atoms 2400 years ago. But it takes mathematics to build a nuclear reactor.
- jacquesm 4y agoNo, it only takes a critical amount of fissible material in a small enough space that the chain reaction will begin. They even occur in nature: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_nuclear_fission_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_nuclear_fission_reacto...
- cft 4y agoThe key was the verb "to build", human-built nuclear reactors. Clearly, the Sun is a thermonuclear reactor, and it exists independently of humans.
- jacquesm 4y agoIt doesn't even take people to build a nuclear reactor, let alone mathematics.
- cft 4y agoI am not sure what exactly "bouwen" means in Dutch, but the verb "to build" in English usually means the process of constructing something by humans or animals [1] [2]: 1. https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/build https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/build 2. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/build https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/build (As opposed to say "Valley created by glacier", or "The Sun was formed through the gravitational attraction of cosmic dust particles")
- jacquesm 4y agoEven for humans it does not take math to build a nuclear reactor, you could pile a bunch of fissile material in a heap and it would happily do its thing. I really don't know what you are trying to get at here, unless you want to keep playing definition games which isn't all that interesting, regardless of what my native language is.
- paulpauper 4y agoThere is a huge difference between merely observing something or describing a phenomena vs. writing down the theory that describes it.
- TheRealPomax 4y agoThere is, but historical context matters: it's very hard to have your works typeset in LaTeX if you lived before LaTeX was been invented; in the exact same way it's impossible to write out the theory when the notation for writing out theories hasn't been invented yet. Instead, as modern day investigators, we need to go through the material and figure out whether the writing was "just notes" or whether it was an "actual attempt at some kind of formal description using whatever system of formalization was available to the author at the time". You can't frame historical science in terms of modern science practices. Or even science practices from a mere 100 years after an author's death.
- lamontcg 4y agoHe's really probing high school physics here, not General Relativity. He's anticipating Galileo and Newton at best. This isn't the Equivalence Principle.