5 ms·
I often wonder what would have happened if Sun hadn't been bought by Oracle and innovation had continued. They were very far ahead. They invented things like co
by wkat4242 4y ago
I often wonder what would have happened if Sun hadn't been bought by Oracle and innovation had continued. They were very far ahead. They invented things like containers in Solaris way before Kubernetes and Docker popularised them on Linux.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tambourine_man 4y agoAnd Dtrace, NFS, ZFS… truly a shame.
- ajross 4y ago> They were very far ahead. They weren't, though, not really. The tech industry just moves too fast for that kind of pronouncement. It's absolutely true that a Sun-3/75 in 1986 was a revelation[1], but every one of those features was cloned as free software and running on sub-$1000 hardware by 1994. They likewise had a brief moment with SPARC in the early 90's where their machines were the fastest you could buy, but Intel demolished those hopes too[4]. Their swan song was the early dot com boom, where they still held onto the reputation as "The Best Unix" and sold a ton of web server hardware to the more conservative outfits. But we could all see the writing on the wall even then. I mean, it's true they had some great stuff toward the end. But not that great, and generally not marketed in a way that would help them. Containers are actually a good example. Solaris Zones were... just a weird circus act[2]. I don't know any major players who made bets on the technology. And, again, within 2-3 years Linux had cgroups and LXC running[3] in a more performant (and much cheaper to deploy) environment and that's what Docker picked. [1] Faster than a VAX, which was still the reference Unix box. Megapixel framebuffer with windowing and competent terminal emulation. Every box was on the Internet. Every box could see the rest of its network over NFS (and most were deployed diskless). FWIW: anyone know where I can get one? Would love one for the collection, but most seem to have disappeared (government and university equipment tends not to end up on eBay...) [2] Edit because this was misunderstood: I'm saying it was an oddity with minimal uptake, not that it was chaotic or bad as a matter of design. [3] This too got misunderstood, though I don't see how. I'm really not interested in a flame war about whose container technology is better. I'm just saying that to Sun in the early/mid 00's, it wasn't much of a competetive advantage (as evidenced by the fact that it lost to Docker). [4] Ooph, this one too. I'm saying that in the early 90's SPARC was dancing with MIPS for the fastest CPUs on the planet, but by the release of the P6 core that was over and Intel had essentially won (though DEC kept the dance going a while longer with Alpha). I'm just amazed at the propensity for folks here to jump in to argue stuff that in my mind was settled decades ago.
- eduction 4y ago> every one of those features was cloned as free software and running on sub-$100k hardware by 1994 ? Zones weren’t released until nearly 10 years after 1994. Same for dtrace and zfs. Solaris was embryonic in 1994. Linux existed but wouldn’t take over servers until c2000-1 (as evidenced by Sun’s massive profits through the end of 1999). What features are you referring to?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shrubble 4y agoSolaris Zones are still far superior to LXC. It's hardly a circus act and SmartOS is being heavily used in many places. Solaris 10 vs contemporary Linux 2.6-era kernels handled memory-pressure situations so much better, that you essentially needed more RAM on the Linux system just to avoid low-memory situations to begin with. Been there, done that :) Linux won because it was a) free and b) aligned (simply because so many had and were using Linux) with Intel x86, and Intel's fabrication technology is/was world-leading. SPARC CPUs on the same fabrication node would still be amazing - but it isn't on the same node...
- ayewo 4y agoWhen you say: > Solaris Zones were... just a weird circus act. I don't know any major players who made bets on the technology. Joyent [1] readily comes to mind. IIRC, that kind of isolation was one of the selling points of their hosting service before they eventually shut it down. (Of course I'm fully aware that one of Joyent's founders was ex-Sun and comments around here too :) ) 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joyent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joyent
- bcantrill 4y agoPresuming that you are referring to me, I am definitely not a founder of Joyent! That said, my rationale for coming to Joyent was not at all unrelated to some of the parallels I saw in Sun[0] -- and it is probably worth reading my own farewell to Sun as well[1]. (Also, because I can't resist completing the arc into the present, see becoming an ex-Joyeur[2] and starting Oxide[3].) [0] http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2010/07/30/hello-joyent/ http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2010/07/30/hello-joyent/ [1] http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2010/07/25/good-bye-sun/ http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2010/07/25/good-bye-sun/ [2] http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2019/07/31/ex-joyeur/ http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2019/07/31/ex-joyeur/ [3] http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2019/12/02/the-soul-of-a-new-computer-company/ http://dtrace.org/blogs/bmc/2019/12/02/the-soul-of-a-new-com...
- pinewurst 4y agoThey were bought by Oracle for salvage as an imploding shambles. If not Oracle, they would have ended up as SGI - merely a name for some white box vendor. The problem here is the confusion between the wonder of late 80s workstation computing and the harsh realities after the Internet Boom.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoOracle's primary interest was suing Google over Java in that acquisition
- pjmlp 4y agoRegardless, Android Java should never had existed in first place, now we have Kotlin as Google's C#. Sun did not sue as they were already out of cash after Google screwed them over. Not only did Google contribute to Sun's downfall, they didn't even bother to buy Sun afterwards. They only have themselves to thank for the lawsuit.
- mardifoufs 4y agoWhat innovation was still happening at Sun by the time Oracle stepped in?
- pjmlp 4y agoGraalVM was known at the time as MaximeVM on Sun Research Labs, for example.
- matt_heimer 4y agoWhat would have happened is the company would have folded. Sun's problem's happened long before they were purchased. Their number one problem is that they were a hardware company and never figured out how to be a software company. It was Linux and cheap Intel hardware combined Sun's lackluster support for x86 Solaris that doomed them.
- jabl 4y agoYeah. Sometimes I wonder how everything would have turned out had they gone all-in on x86 starting with the Sun386i in 1988 and never developed SPARC.
- ghaff 4y agoOr someone like Motorola could have done RISC sooner. (They did eventually with the 88K but Sun, IBM, etc. had all gone with their own RISC chips by then.)
- kjs3 4y agoSomeone did do RISC sooner; for example, MIPS shipped R2000 in 1985 and Clipper shipped C100 in 1986. SPARC and 88k were introduced within a year of each other as I recall (87/88).
- ghaff 4y agoYeah, MIPS is probably the best example and did get some uptake. But the big vendors mostly went their own way. Although I was involved in that history to a degree, I'm not entirely sure why history played out the way it did.
- kjs3 4y agoWell...any history will attract a torrent of nitpicking, so this is my extremely reductist take. Motorola, IBM & Apple decided to join up on a common HW platform called "PReP" which was POWER/PPC based, so Motorola dumped 88k to play ball with that. PReP was a flash in the pan, but PPC briefly shone as Apples processor, and is still around in various forms (mostly embedded now, but POWER still ships in volume). Similar trajectory with MIPS. Clipper was never going to be a big player; it was a niche within a niche. SPARC, HPPA & Alpha got steamrolled by much cheaper, performance competitive x86 derived processors. In the end, most volume customers said "can it run my software fast and cheap" and by sometime in the 90s that was clearly an x86 (unless your name was "Apple", but that's a different history).
- pjmlp 4y agoThey would have gone under, Java would have been fossilized at version 6, GraalVM would never have happened, CLR would be left as the only high end polyglot runtime with top GC and JIT compilation algorithms.
- icedchai 4y agoSun was a innovator throughout the 90's. Many colleges, universities, and startups used Sun hardware. By the mid 2000's, they were on the way out. The market was flooded with barely used Sun hardware after the dot-com collapse. At the same time, Linux was now "good enough" that less-and-less people needed Solaris. Of course, some enterprises still needed it. The only thing Sun was hanging on to - Java - was freely available.
- sn1de 4y agoThey were already doomed at that point. I was involved in several major purchase decisions during that period and Sun were totally out of touch. If they were quoting hardware that had an x86 equivalent, then they were overpriced. If it was something that didn't have an x86 equivalent, like they had for a while with 64 bit, the prices were atrocious. Then Lintel moved to 64 bit and it was all over. The price/performance equation was broken, but Sun, for whatever reason, kept on like nothing had happened. I, and I'm sure many others, tried to show them that they were uncompetitive, but you were dealing with reps working from a price sheet and citing the same old mantra that Sun was inherently superior. For years when I would tell peers that the Sun equipment was just throwing away money they wouldn't believe me because they hadn't done the benchmarking. Really, if people did proper benchmarking and didn't just 'buy what they know' without questioning, it all would have unwound even more quickly. They certainly had some good tech, and were not wrong about the advantages of containerization, which came full circle with linux containerization and docker, but IBM mainframes had similar virtualization capabilities in place long before Solaris zones, so it wasn't something that was a game changer. Ironically, it worked against them because even though they were right, it was seen by some as Sun touting their way of doing it because they didn't have a viable solution for the prevailing VM direction of hardware virtualization. Basically, they began by offering the best price/performance and innovation, but then died trying to be a 'premium provider' without the goods to back it up, and market forces then do what market forces do.
- jasoneckert 4y agoI agree that they were doomed by that point as well primarily due to Linux on faster and cheaper x86 hardware. My UltraSPARC-III-based Blade 1500 that was an incredibly overpriced workstation that only ran Solaris well, and wasn't on par with the performance of x86 at the time. However, I do remember buying an Opteron-based Ultra 20 because it was cheaper from Sun than anyone else and had 100% Linux support, which everyone seemed to be migrating to from Solaris. By that time, I'm sure there was no clear market direction for Sun software- or hardware-wise, and everything was too little too late.
- blantonl 4y agoSun's sales guys were killing it right up until their last breath. I can clearly remember thinking to myself "why does this Sun/Solaris node cost $32k when this equivalent Intel costs $10K?" One day it was the in-thing, the next pooof Solaris was GONE.
- ghaff 4y agoBefore Docker came along though, containers were mostly just a more lightweight partitioning techniques than VMs which they had largely lost out to. See also Virtuozzo, BSD jails, and some of the early container work on Linux. But Docker followed by Kubernetes really made containers into a different cloud-native development and deployment model rather than just a lighter form of VM..