3 ms·
That article – but it's more of a rant than article – is written in such bad faith and laced with personal insults and accusations – some of which are extremely
by arp242 4y ago
That article – but it's more of a rant than article – is written in such bad faith and laced with personal insults and accusations – some of which are extremely tenuous – that any real information it may contain are lost to all but everyone who already agreed with it.
Going off on rants about "whistleblower" in scare-quotes, "manufactured controversy", "right wing talking points" and "anti-trans scree" is not helpful, it's part of the problem.
- chownie 4y agoFor anyone else reading along taking the parent comment to heart, having read the article I couldn't disagree more and would suggest you read it for yourself rather than take this commenters review at face value. The write-up is comprehensive, goes through all Jamie Reed's points and discusses why she isn't a reliable narrator. It doesn't read as a rant at all to me.
- ghqst 4y agoBut... what if that's what this is? Being aware of the biases and position of an author is always helpful to more clearly evaluate.
- arp242 4y agoThey're suspected biases, suspected positions, and suspected motives, gleaned from vague hints. I think little is more corrosive to constructive discourse than trying to guess at people's motives and "true positions".