3 ms·
The conference versus journal issue is orthogonal to professional society versus for-profit entity, since the ACM and IEEE have journals. This means that archa
by scott_s 15y ago
The conference versus journal issue is orthogonal to professional society versus for-profit entity, since the ACM and IEEE have journals.
This means that archaic tenure review committees evaluating on where you publish instead of what you publish will ascribe little weight to your conference papers.
Not in CS, in my experience. People in CS know which are the highly selective (what I have always heard called "top tier") conferences. In my experience in industry and academia, conferences are our primary consideration and journals are an afterthought. (Sometimes not even a thought.) The CRA memo is from 1999. I think most people have caught on by now.
- jedbrown 15y agoThat is specific to CS. I have one foot in CS, but the other two feet are in applied mathematics and natural sciences where conferences are not especially attractive publications venues.
- scott_s 15y agoYes, I agree, it is specific to CS - if you re-read my posts, I think you'll find that I prefaced everything with that qualifier. I have friends in the hard sciences, and we sometimes talk about how the publishing models are quite different.