5 ms·
Google employees criticize CEO for ‘rushed, botched’ announcement of Bard
- sebastien_b 4y ago>The meme featured a photo of actor Nicolas Cage smiling and said “Firing 12k people rises the stock by 3%, one rushed AI presentation drops it by 8%.” I wonder if there was one with Nelson Muntz pointing, with the caption “Ah-ha! Your AI doesn’t even know what telescope took what picture!”
- camillomiller 4y agoIf anything, I think Sundar Pichai will have to face more consequences for botching this launch than firing 12k people in the stupidest way possible. Boards are a fun thing to have to respond to.
- mc32 4y agoIf the board get upset over this, the board is the problem. They are probably the ones who pushed Pichai to rush it anyhow.
- CharlesW 4y ago> If the board get upset over this, the board is the problem. Are you saying that boards shouldn't get upset at botched product launches, especially ones involving tech inflection points?
- mc32 4y agoBecause they are the very ones who made this urgent, yes. Getting it out this week or this month isn't going to make a difference in the long run.
- CharlesW 4y ago> Because they are the very ones who made this urgent, yes. If the board did do that, Sundar is the directly responsible individual who said "yes". If the board suggests "jump" and Sundar reflexively response "how high?", in my view Google has bigger problems.
- enos_feedler 4y agoSince when do the largest companies capitalize on tech inflection points early? If this is a goal its a new and ambitious one in the history of large business
- CharlesW 4y agoIs it early? LLMs have been around for a long time, and BERT was 2018.
- cfiggers 4y agoYes, better to let small, scrappy startups like Microsoft blaze the trail
- mc32 4y agoWhat have MS got to lose? They were not making a dent in search. Google has to be measured. They rushed it unnecessarily. It's not like an overnight coup --where it's done and over. Google has lots of time to respond.
- aaomidi 4y agoBing is making a ton of money because they actually have a usable search API for Bing.
- enos_feedler 4y agoExactly! When it comes to search they are a small scrappy startup lol
- rhaway84773 4y agoGoogle is one of the leaders in this. Their competitor, whom they’re responding to, is Microsoft, which has been one of the largest companies for much longer than Google has even existed.
- danielrpa 4y agoPichai makes over 100M per year. I think we can expect him to deliver a presentation on a tight schedule, otherwise how is he special?
- thinking4real 4y ago[dead]
- firecall 4y agoWhen the CEO is finally asked to do something, to actually take some action, he stumbles and falls flat on his face. Mr Pichai,you have been weighed, you have been measured and you have been found wanting. What is Eric Schmidt up to these days? ;-)
- meindnoch 4y agoMene, mene, tekel, upharsin
- quantified 4y agoVery nice!
- Fatnino 4y agoLiteral writing on the wall
- danielrpa 4y agoSundar Pichai is still busy taking full responsibility for the layoffs.
- dietr1ch 4y agoIt'd be easier if he wasn't so thoughtful.
- ecf 4y agoFrom an outsider perspective Pichai really does seem to be the worst CEO of the big tech bunch. Can’t remember the last time Google came out with something remotely close to a success.
- vsskanth 4y agoSo what's the big blocker for Google to let the public try it out ? It can't be for lack of capability or resources
- cma 4y agoStability.ai is currently being sued for like $150,000 per image it was trained on. There's probably some concern. Microsoft is able to shift potential liability onto OpenAI.
- winddude 4y agoTerrible name too
- roydivision 4y agoYup, this has been bugging me too. A bard is a composer of songs and music. I don’t see the relevance. Out of all the names they could have chosen.
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoEh, we all know ChatGPT can make these same kinds of errors. The only difference between Microsoft and Google is Microsoft did a better job of proofing their marketing materials. It's genuinely amazing watching Google taking a shellacking on this when all of these LLMs have the exact same problems. The real problem is none of these technologies should be put in front of users in a way that might give them a patina of authority or certainty. Their ability to convincingly bullshit is incredibly dangerous and I'm amazed at how blithely irresponsible these companies are in pushing this technology out in front of users before it can be trusted.
- kken 4y ago>The real problem is none of these technologies should be put in front of users in a way that might give them a patina of authority or certainty. Well, it seems that Microsoft has addressed with Bing in a better way than ChatGPT and Bard by providing actual web references. Sometimes I wonder whether there is generally a mismatch in expectations. People seem to expect the LLMs to output only verified and true information, when it fact it is subject to fallacies very similar to those of a human due to vagueness inherent to written language. I found that if you think of these assistants as an extremely eager and efficient intern, expectations and reality match much better.
- BaseballPhysics 4y ago> Well, it seems that Microsoft has addressed with Bing in a better way than ChatGPT and Bard by providing actual web references. Lol I guarantee you the average bing user isn't checking those references. They're going to run a search, get a result, and use it uncritically, because the average person has no idea what chatgpt is or how LLMs can go wrong.
- charrondev 4y agoThe people use things uncritically all the time. Many people don’t even read past a headline. Someone who won’t check their source on a search headline won’t check the source on anything else they read on the internet either, which is rife with incorrect information (either accidentally or intentionally).
- rhaway84773 4y agoIsn’t it obvious that Pichai is not up the task of running a company like Google? Is there a single new area that Google has claimed leadership in under his tenure as CEO?
- xracy 4y agoYeah, probably because they used up a ton of good will with employees with layoffs, and then immediately face planted. Kinda makes sense that employees would criticize them after that.