3 ms·
> I hate how that's phrased. No one is ending single-family housing. That would be a fair complaint, if the word “housing” had been used in place of “zoning”.
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> I hate how that's phrased. No one is ending single-family housing.
That would be a fair complaint, if the word “housing” had been used in place of “zoning”. Single-family zoning is a legal restriction that allows only single-family housing. Ending it is not the same as ending single-family housing.
If you are going to complain about phrasing, you should complain about the actual phrasing.
- willcipriano 4y agoI got the same impression from the headline. When trying to communicate I have found that it is best to be understood as opposed to being dictionary correct. Personally I would've went with "allow multi-family housing", but I also probably wouldn't click on the article because it's just saying that making smaller homes allows you to have more of them over a given area.
- dorkwood 4y agoI suppose it depends who your audience is. If you’re writing for people who understand what single family zoning is, then suddenly inventing new terminology is likely to confuse them. People who live in areas affected by single family zoning tend to be very familiar with the term.
- epistasis 4y agoPeople don't understand that the single family zoning is actually an apartment ban. So even if it's technically correct, it scares a lot of people unnecessarily. Otherwise intelligent people have their brains broken when it comes to discussions about housing. We need to pick words carefully to not confuse.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoI agree with this (words mean things), but have also been told to my face in community meetings during attempts to upzone parcels “we don’t want more people here.” These are not fancy burbs, average SFH value is ~$300k. The approach with the uneducated is different than that with an adversary. Until more state laws (ie California’s recent legislation) are passed where density developers can reply “that’s a shame”, NIMBYs rule. NY is gearing up for a similar fight. https://www.politico.com/news/2023/02/11/hochul-faces-uprising-housing-plan-00080949 https://www.politico.com/news/2023/02/11/hochul-faces-uprisi...
- raldi 4y agoAnd then NIMBYs call efforts to allow taller buildings “one size fits all”, whereas it’s the exact opposite: the status quo in these neighborhoods is one size (SFHs only) fits all.
- bdw5204 4y agoAs far as an uninformed reader is concerned (think either the typical cable news watcher or the typical apolitical person), "ending single-family zoning" reads as "banning new single-family housing". Most voters, let alone most people, are every bit as clueless about public policy details as the people who held up "keep the government out of my Medicare" signs at the protests against Obamacare so you need to be really careful to explain what the existing policy is and how it is being changed.
- bigbillheck 4y agoI think it's fair to expect a little bit more out of the average hacker news poster.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> As far as an uninformed reader is concerned (think either the typical cable news watcher or the typical apolitical person), "ending single-family zoning" reads as "banning new single-family housing". I really don’t think that’s true. Yes, the average citizen is uninformed about the average policy issue, but that alone doesn’t support a characterization that most unsophisticated readers has the same very specific misunderstanding of a particular policy issue when identified in the usual terms. There are some issues where something like that is the case, and there is polling to suggest that, but just making the unsupported leap from “unsophisticated citizens” to “this particular misunderstanding” with no evidence is not warranted.