5 ms·
"Until 2015 or so, a very small number of these boys comprised the population of pediatric gender dysphoria cases. Then, across the Western world, there began t
by Animats 4y ago
"Until 2015 or so, a very small number of these boys comprised the population of pediatric gender dysphoria cases. Then, across the Western world, there began to be a dramatic increase in a new population: Teenage girls, many with no previous history of gender distress, suddenly declared they were transgender and demanded immediate treatment with testosterone."
That's what's so striking. Why is that happening? There's a controversy over this.[1] It's been observed in (at least) Australia, Canada, the UK, France, Sweden, and the US. People involved in studying this have been attacked, and as a result, there's not much new data since the big controversy in 2018.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rapid-onset_gender_dysphoria_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rapid-onset_gender_dysphoria_c...
- 2devnull 4y agoI witnessed this first hand in a close relative who, in the throws of a multi month long bipolar psychosis, concluded that the source of her mental health problems was gender dysphoria. The internet was very influential in her reaching this conclusion. The internet also allowed her to locate a dr who didn’t restrict sexual reassignment to those without mental health comorbidities. Thankfully the very liberal dr she found was too far for her to travel, since she could not drive and Uber wasn’t yet a thing. She was stabilized on antipsychotics a few months later and completely dropped all discussion of gender dysphoria, something, to be clear, that she had never talked about or hinted at prior to her psychotic episode. It concerns me that had she had this episode a few years later, when the medical ethics had changed and Uber made it possible for a mentally ill person to travel to the city where the dr she found was located, she likely would have undergone some form of reassignment surgery with lasting physical effects and potentially catastrophic effects on her psychological well being. She has been happily married, well more or less happily, for more than a decade now, to a nice man. No sign of gender dysphoria and no recent psychotic episodes.
- Breefield 4y agoYou seriously misunderstand how hard it is to have sex reassignment surgery. Even in states where beginning an HRT regimen is based on informed consent, there are many steps one must go through before having this procedure done. Multiple letters of recommendation from licensed therapists and having been on hormones for years. Not to mention the exorbitant costs even with insurance. Your suggestion that one could Uber to another city and have SRS performed is a gross mischaracterization of the reality trans people face.
- jvanderbot 4y agoThe article provides examples of clinics offering very few steps to treatment, and discusses doctors who bias in favor of treatment. It paints a picture supporting the conclusion that it would have been easy.
- klyrs 4y agoThe gulf between the availability of specialist surgeons and pharmaceuticals is incredibly vast. If the article gave you the impression that you can just walk in and get your SRS did on a whim, perhaps you should reconsider its veracity or at least your understanding of the situation.
- jvanderbot 4y agoI don't have a any understanding of this situation or a horse in this race, was just pointing out that ancestor comment was justified based on the article, which also addressed availability of pharmaceuticals, btw. It'd be nice to have literature or deeper investigation on this.
- bjowen 4y agoThe article is written from experience in one paediatric centre, when the pratice between different centres - and laws in different states - differ vastly. Information about people seeking gender affirming care in different places and stages of transition is not refutable based on this article. And it is anecdata - how many patients had positive outcomes? Article doesn’t tell you. What did the (brand new) centre learn from these cases with negative outcomes? What protocols was it using? Are they the same now? Are they common elsewhere?
- setr 4y agoThat’s a large part of the article’s call-out — there’s no real tracking of outcomes, and looking to do so is met hostility.
- jonhendry18 4y ago
- kevingadd 4y agoGlad to hear your close relative is doing well now, and it sounds like she was in a tough situation. If you did more research though you'd understand that the thing you feared is not especially common or even possible under normal processes, so it's not really worth fearmongering about it on a public forum. In most first-world medical systems there are years-long waiting lists for surgeries, or even to see a specialist at all. Most people I know who've seen specialists about gender issues had to wait months to even talk to someone. Getting surgery on a whim within a few months simply doesn't happen unless you're a wealthy person flying overseas for at-your-own-risk surgery, which is also available for many other purposes. This is similar to how you'll see people fear-mongering about things like teenage children getting surgeries, which simply does not happen. The processes don't allow for it because it would be wildly irresponsible, but you can still find lots of people talking about it as if it happens on a regular basis. In reality, adults in their twenties and thirties sit on waiting lists for years. Note also that even if you were to schedule surgery on short notice, in many cases they require you to have been on the relevant medications for a while because if you were to have sex-related organs removed or modified surgically without having adjusted to your own hormone levels it would be a pretty nasty adjustment.
- 2devnull 4y agoI’m relieved to hear that. It’s easy to get the impression that many children are now starting the process with hormones and whatnot, without too many barriers in place or a sufficient waiting period. It’s probably the most extreme cases that get the spotlight.
- kevingadd 4y agoIn general when medical processes are flawed, the extreme <0.1% cases get the spotlight and instead of being used to advocate for process improvements, they're generalized by people with an agenda to claim that an <0.1% case is a 1% or 10% case. It does a disservice to the outliers who suffered and the sensationalized story is (rightly) ignored by people who might otherwise benefit from the cautionary tale.
- 4y ago
- object-a 4y agoThere are a few non-controversial reasons that this could be the case: 1. The study on Rapid-onset gender dysphoria could be flawed -- it asked parents, and not youths themselves, which might skew the data on the prevalence and incidence of gender dysphoria 2. The number of transgender youth in the US is small[1], estimated at around 300,000. A small absolute increase would result in a large relative increase, even though transgender-identifying youth are a small percent of the population 3. Improved acceptance, awareness, diagnostics and treatment may result in transgender youth seeing more options for themselves, and thus being more public in announcing their status or seeking treatment. It's not that more people are trans or genderfluid, but rather that they're more comfortable being public with their status [1] https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/publications/trans-adults-united-states/ https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/publications/trans-ad...
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoNot sure why you were downvoted, this seems obvious to me.
- ghqst 4y agoI agree with all of these points. "Rapid-onset gender dysphoria" is a bunch of baloney, but I do think there is probably a decent amount of teenagers who misdiagnose based on the internet, since this happens with a lot of other mental disorders as well. I think the issue is that the annoying culture of the left of rejecting all "transphobic" arguments, (i say this as one of these people), means that some clinics are going too far and not being as careful as they should. The answer is probably government regulation, but we have to be careful not to be like the UK, and not just to "ban everything associated with trans healthcare at all" like Republican states are currently trying to do.
- kevingadd 4y agoThis quote from the source you linked seems to suggest an obvious reason why it might be a controversial "diagnosis": > Lisa Littman, at the time an adjunct assistant professor at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, coined the term rapid-onset gender dysphoria in a 2018 study based on an online survey of parents on three anti-trans websites who believed that their teenage children had suddenly manifested symptoms of gender dysphoria and begun identifying as transgender simultaneously with other children in their peer group. Doesn't sound terribly scientific. I do look forward to seeing a robust conclusion drawn from studies over the coming years, though, so we can find out how real it is!
- flippinburgers 4y agoMovements that are dogmatic don't like to be questioned.
- afpx 4y agoI noticed it happening to the pre-teen kids of friends that played a lot of online games. When I asked the kids about it, they said they felt more comfortable online being a different gender because it better matched their personality and expectations.
- ghqst 4y agoI've known a couple of people who masqueraded as the opposite gender online and eventually discovered that they fit more as that gender in reality as well. Online is an interesting playground to experiment with gender identity, because there's less stakes and you can experience people referring to you as a different gender.
- jasonlotito 4y agoIt should be noted that what you are linking to is described thusly. "ROGD has not been recognized by any major professional association as a valid mental health diagnosis" Calling it a controversy isn't accurate. There is no controversy. Someone made some stuff up. It's called Rapid-onset taurus cacas.